Multi-operator Network Sharing for Massive IoT

Yong Xiao, Marwan Krunz, Tao Shu

Abstract

Recent study predicts that by 2020 up to 50 billion IoT devices will be connected to the Internet, straining the capacity of wireless network that has already been overloaded with data-hungry mobile applications, such as high-definition video streaming and virtual reality(VR)/augmented reality(AR). How to accommodate the demand for both massive scale of IoT devices and high-speed cellular services in the physically limited spectrum without significantly increasing the operational and infrastructure costs is one of the main challenges for operators. In this article, we introduce a new multi-operator network sharing framework that supports the coexistence of IoT and high-speed cellular services. Our framework is based on the radio access network (RAN) sharing architecture recently introduced by 3GPP as a promising solution for operators to improve their resource utilization and reduce the system roll-out cost. We evaluate the performance of our proposed framework using the real base station location data in the city of Dublin collected from two major operators in Ireland. Numerical results show that our proposed framework can almost double the total number of IoT devices that can be supported and coexist with other cellular services compared with the case without network sharing.

Introduction: The Challenge of Massive IoT

As we transition into an era with an estimated 50 billion connected devices, mobile network operators are facing a severe "spectrum crunch." Traditional cellular networks are primarily optimized for high-speed, data-intensive applications like 4K video streaming and augmented reality. In contrast, massive IoT (mIoT) deployments typically involve millions of low-power sensors generating low-throughput, intermittent traffic.

The core challenge is twofold. First, coexistence: operators must integrate millions of low-power IoT sensors into frequency bands already occupied by high-speed services without causing significant interference. Second, cost: building dedicated physical infrastructure for IoT is economically unfeasible given the low average revenue per user (ARPU) of sensor devices. While existing standards like Narrowband IoT (NB-IoT) and eMTC provide a foundation, they are limited by the physical boundaries of a single operator's licensed spectrum and significant signaling overhead.

Comparison of existing cellular IoT technologies including EC-GSM-IoT, NB-IoT, and eMTC.

Proposed Framework: Active RAN Sharing

To address these hurdles, this paper proposes a novel framework based on Active Radio Access Network (RAN) Sharing, as defined in 3GPP Releases 13-15. Unlike passive sharing, which is limited to sharing physical sites or towers, active sharing allows multiple operators to share radio equipment and spectrum resources.

The framework explores two primary architectural models:

  1. Spectrum Pooling: Multiple operators merge their individual licensed bands into a unified common pool. This pool is typically managed by a "Master Operator" (MOP), simplifying management and enabling more efficient channel reuse across the combined footprint.
  2. Spectrum Leasing: A primary operator leases a portion of its spectrum and base station capacity to a secondary operator. In this model, the primary owner's traffic usually retains priority.
Architectural models for network sharing: (a) Spectrum Pooling and (b) Spectrum Leasing.

To optimize these shared environments, the authors integrate advanced technologies such as Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA)—allowing multiple devices to share frequency resources via power-domain multiplexing—and Network Slicing, which creates virtualized, isolated "lanes" tailored to specific IoT requirements (e.g., ultra-reliable lanes for emergency sensors).

Performance Evaluation

The framework was validated using a trace-driven simulation based on real-world infrastructure data. The study utilized the GPS locations of over 200 base stations from two major telecommunication operators in Dublin, Ireland. This ensured the simulation reflected realistic deployment densities and overlapping coverage areas.

Key Results

  • Capacity Gains: Spectrum Pooling consistently outperformed both Spectrum Leasing and standalone "No Sharing" scenarios. In Dublin’s city center and suburban areas, the pooling model allowed for significantly more efficient interference management.
  • Doubling Capacity: Under realistic constraints—where traditional cellular users tolerate only a 10-20% degradation in throughput—the proposed framework almost doubled the total number of coexisting IoT devices compared to traditional standalone operations.
  • Geographic Impact: The benefits of sharing were most pronounced in suburban areas with larger cell sizes. In these regions, lower base station density makes the efficient use of pooled spectrum even more critical for maintaining coverage and capacity.

Discussion and Future Outlook

The study reveals a "QoS Paradox": network sharing provides the most dramatic performance boosts when cellular users have the most stringent Quality of Service (QoS) requirements. When users are highly sensitive to interference, the coordinated resource allocation provided by a shared framework becomes essential to "fitting" IoT devices into the spectral gaps.

However, moving from theory to deployment involves significant hurdles:

  • Implementation Complexity: Active RAN sharing requires tight synchronization between competing operators and increases the complexity of core network management.
  • Economic Incentives: A critical non-technical challenge is "Fair Revenue Division." Operators require mathematical guarantees that they will be compensated fairly based on the infrastructure and spectrum they contribute to the pool.
  • Dynamic Traffic: Future research must address the "bursty" nature of IoT traffic and the mobility of devices, as the current model assumes saturated traffic conditions.

By leveraging collaborative resource management, operators can overcome the physical limits of their individual spectrum holdings, paving the way for the massive IoT era without the need for prohibitive infrastructure investment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent study predicts that by 2020 up to 50 billion IoT devices will be connected to the Internet, straining the capacity of wireless network that has already been overloaded with data-hungry mobile applications, such as high-definition video streaming and virtual reality(VR)/augmented reality(AR). How to accommodate the demand for both massive scale of IoT devices and high-speed cellular services in the physically limited spectrum without significantly increasing the operational and infrastructure costs is one of the main challenges for operators. In this article, we introduce a new multi-operator network sharing framework that supports the coexistence of IoT and high-speed cellular services. Our framework is based on the radio access network (RAN) sharing architecture recently introduced by 3GPP as a promising solution for operators to improve their resource utilization and reduce the system roll-out cost. We evaluate the performance of our proposed framework using the real base station location data in the city of Dublin collected from two major operators in Ireland. Numerical results show that our proposed framework can almost double the total number of IoT devices that can be supported and coexist with other cellular services compared with the case without network sharing.
BibTeX
@article{xiao2019multi,
  author = {Yong Xiao and Marwan Krunz and Tao Shu},
  title = {{Multi-operator Network Sharing for Massive IoT}},
  journal = {IEEE Communications Magazine},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=4cWL4MEvWl},
}
Figure