Multi-Operator Network Sharing for Massive IoT

Yong Xiao, Marwan Krunz, Tao Shu

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel multi-operator network sharing framework designed to accommodate the "massive IoT" era without requiring prohibitive infrastructure investment. By leveraging 3GPP’s Radio Access Network (RAN) sharing architectures and spectrum pooling, the authors demonstrate that operators can nearly double the number of supported IoT devices while maintaining high-quality service for traditional cellular users.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As we move toward a world with an estimated 50 billion connected devices, mobile operators face a "spectrum crunch." Traditional cellular networks are optimized for high-speed, data-hungry applications (like video streaming), whereas IoT devices typically generate low-throughput, intermittent traffic.

The challenge is twofold:

  1. Coexistence: How do you fit millions of low-power IoT sensors into the same frequency bands as high-speed 5G services without causing massive interference?
  2. Cost: Building dedicated infrastructure for IoT is economically unfeasible.

Existing solutions like Narrowband IoT (NB-IoT) and eMTC help, but they still struggle with signaling overhead (the "RACH" procedure) and the physical limits of a single operator's licensed spectrum.

Methods

The authors propose a framework based on Active RAN Sharing (introduced in 3GPP Releases 13-15). Unlike "passive" sharing (just sharing a cell tower site), active sharing allows operators to share the actual radio equipment and spectrum.

The paper explores two primary sharing models:

  • Spectrum Pooling: Multiple operators merge their licensed bands into a common pool managed by a "Master Operator" (MOP). This reduces management complexity and allows for more efficient channel reuse.
  • Spectrum Leasing: One operator leases a portion of its spectrum and base stations to another, typically giving priority to the primary owner's traffic.

To make this work, the authors discuss the integration of Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA), which allows multiple devices to share the same frequency at the same time by using different power levels or codes, and Network Slicing, which creates virtual "lanes" in the network tailored to specific IoT needs (e.g., a high-reliability lane for fire alarms vs. a high-latency lane for smart meters).

Datasets

The study validates its framework using a trace-driven simulation based on real-world infrastructure:

  • Base Station Locations: Actual GPS data for over 200 base stations in the city of Dublin, Ireland.
  • Operators: Data was collected from two major Irish telecommunication operators to ensure the simulation reflected realistic deployment densities and overlaps.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Pooling: The most significant "aha moment" is that spectrum pooling isn't just a marginal gain; it can nearly double the capacity for IoT devices in certain scenarios. This is because it allows for much more flexible interference management across a wider frequency block.
  • The QoS Paradox: Interestingly, network sharing provides the most dramatic performance boost when cellular users have stringent Quality of Service (QoS) requirements. When users are sensitive to even small amounts of interference, the coordination provided by a shared framework is essential to fitting IoT devices into the gaps.
  • Economic Incentives are Key: The authors highlight that the biggest hurdle isn't just technical—it's "Fair Revenue Division." Operators need a mathematical guarantee that they will be compensated fairly based on the resources they contribute to the pool.

Key Results

  • Capacity Boost: In simulations of Dublin’s city center and suburban areas, the Spectrum Pooling model consistently outperformed both "No Sharing" and "Spectrum Leasing" models.
  • Doubling Down: Under practical constraints (where cellular users tolerate only 10-20% throughput degradation), the proposed framework almost doubled the total number of coexisting IoT devices compared to traditional standalone operation.
  • Cell Size Impact: The benefits of sharing are most pronounced as cell sizes increase (suburban areas), where the lower density of base stations makes efficient spectrum use more critical.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Implementation Complexity: While the gains are high, the authors acknowledge that active RAN sharing significantly increases the complexity of the core network and requires tight synchronization between competing operators.
  • Dynamic Traffic Control: The current simulation assumes "saturated" traffic (devices always having data to send). Future work is needed to model highly dynamic, "bursty" IoT traffic and mobile devices that move rapidly between cells.
  • Revenue Modeling: While the paper mentions fair revenue division, the specific game-theoretic models to ensure all operators stay "honest" and incentivized in a shared pool remain a complex area for further research.

Summary updated

Abstract

A recent study predicts that by 2020, up to 50 billion Internet of Things (IoT) devices will be connected to the Internet, straining the capacity of the wireless infrastructure, which has already been overloaded with data-hungry mobile applications. How to accommodate the demand for both massive-scale IoT devices and high-speed cellular services in the physically limited spectrum without significantly increasing the operational and infrastructure costs is one of the main challenges for operators. In this article, we introduce a new multi-operator network sharing framework that supports the coexistence of IoT and high-speed cellular services. Our framework is based on the radio access network sharing architecture recently introduced by 3GPP as a promising solution for operators to improve their resource utilization and reduce system roll-out cost. We evaluate the performance of our proposed framework using real base station location data in the city of Dublin collected from two major operators in Ireland. Numerical results show that our proposed framework can almost double the total number of supported IoT devices that can be supported and simultaneously coexist with other cellular services.
BibTeX
@article{xiao2019multi,
  author = {Yong Xiao and Marwan Krunz and Tao Shu},
  title = {{Multi-Operator Network Sharing for Massive IoT}},
  journal = {IEEE Communications Magazine},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=4cWL4MEvWl},
}

Loading related content...

Figure