Executive Summary
The MSIS 2016 report marks a paradigm shift in Information Systems (IS) education, moving away from a rigid list of prescribed courses toward a flexible, global "competency model." By defining exactly what a graduate should be able to do—rather than just what they should know—it provides a universal framework for universities to design master’s programs that align with specific professional roles and diverse industry needs.
Addressing the Evolution of Information Systems
For decades, graduate curriculum recommendations in Information Systems were "course-based," essentially providing a syllabus for universities to follow. However, this approach faced three major hurdles in a rapidly changing environment:
- The Velocity of Change: Technology moves faster than academic bureaucracy. By the time a specific course list is approved, the underlying tech might already be obsolete.
- Regional Diversity: Previous models were heavily focused on North American educational systems, making them difficult to apply in Europe, Asia, or Australia, where degree structures and credit systems differ significantly.
- The "Business" Silo: Historically, MSIS degrees were synonymous with business schools. The authors argue that IS is now critical in healthcare, government, and law, requiring a model that works outside the traditional corporate domain.
The MSIS 2016 task force set out to create a "living" model that focuses on outcomes (competencies) rather than inputs (courses), allowing for global flexibility and interdisciplinary application.
Methodology: A Collaborative Global Framework
The development of the model was led by a Joint ACM/AIS Task Force, utilizing a multi-staged, collaborative approach to ensure global relevance and professional alignment.
The task force employed several key design principles:
- Competency-Based Design: Instead of a Body of Knowledge (BoK), they defined competencies as a dynamic combination of knowledge, skills, and attitudes.
- Hierarchical Structure: They organized the model into nine Competency Areas (e.g., Data Management, Enterprise Architecture), which are further broken down into 88 Competency Categories.
- Attainment Levels: Borrowing from frameworks like SFIA (Skills Framework for the Information Age), they defined four levels of mastery: Awareness, Novice, Supporting, and Independent.
- Professional Profiling: The authors used "personas" or professional profiles (like Business Analyst or Systems Analyst) to demonstrate how different career paths require different "mixes" of these competencies.
Synthesis of Global Standards
As a pedagogical framework rather than an empirical study, the paper synthesizes and maps against several major industry and regional frameworks to ensure broad applicability:
- e-CF 3.0: The European e-Competence Framework.
- SFIA: The Skills Framework for the Information Age.
- O*NET: The Occupational Information Network.
- Primary Survey Data: Qualitative and quantitative feedback from the global IS academic and professional community.
Key Insights: Competency over Knowledge
A central insight of the MSIS 2016 model is that theoretical knowledge does not equate to professional capability. The model prioritizes the ability to perform tasks successfully in high-stakes environments.
- The "Independent" Ceiling: The authors acknowledge that a master’s degree alone cannot produce an "Expert." The highest level a program should realistically target is the "Independent Contributor," who can work without constant supervision.
- Domain Independence: The report explicitly decouples IS from "Business." It provides examples of how an MSIS could be tailored for Healthcare Informatics or a Digital Start-up, treating the "Domain of Practice" as a modular component of the degree.
- Process over Prescription: Instead of saying "Teach Course X," the paper provides a 10-step process for universities to derive their own curriculum based on the job profiles they want their graduates to fill.
Results and Discipline Mapping
The paper culminates in a comprehensive map of the IS discipline, reflecting a modern emphasis on digital transformation and social responsibility:
- 9 Core Areas: Including "Innovation, Organizational Change, and Entrepreneurship" and "Ethics, Impacts, and Sustainability."
- 88 Categories: Each with a specified "minimum level" for all MSIS graduates. For example, 22 categories are required at the Awareness level, 46 at Novice, and 20 at Supporting.
- Mapping Blueprints: The report provides detailed tables showing how specific modules (like "User Experience Design") contribute to various competencies, serving as a guide for program directors.
Limitations and Future Outlook
The authors identify several inherent challenges in transitioning to this new model:
- Institutional Inertia: Moving from a course-based to a competency-based model requires a cultural shift in how faculty design and assess learning.
- Currency Maintenance: While the "Areas" are stable, the "Sample Competencies" (the specific tasks) will need frequent updates to stay relevant to industry trends like AI or cloud-native development.
- Assessment Difficulty: Measuring "competency" is harder than grading a multiple-choice test on "knowledge." Future work must focus on developing better pedagogical strategies and assessment tools to verify these higher-level skills.
The task force views MSIS 2016 not as a final document, but as a foundation for an ongoing, global dialogue on the identity and value of Information Systems as a discipline.
Summary updated