Competency-Based Approach to Information Systems Program Development: Guidance from the MSIS 2016 Global Competence Model

Heikki Topi, Helena Karsten, Susan A. Brown, João Álvaro Carvalho, Brian Donnellan, Jun Shen, Bernard C. Y. TanJournal of the Association for Information Systems 2016

Abstract

This paper outlines a major paradigm shift in graduate Information Systems (IS) education, transitioning from traditional topic-driven curricula to a competency-based model. It presents multiple perspectives on competency-driven approaches for developing and evaluating degree programs, comparing them to earlier "body of knowledge" (BoK) methods. Central to this discussion is the introduction of the MSIS 2016 global competency model, a collaborative effort designed to improve the quality of graduate education and align academic outcomes with the practical needs of the global workforce.

Introduction: A Paradigm Shift in IS Education

For decades, academic programs in Information Systems were constructed around a "content-driven" approach. These programs were typically defined by a static list of topics or a specific "Body of Knowledge" (BoK) that dictated what instructors were expected to teach. However, as the digital landscape evolved at an unprecedented pace, this model began to show its limitations. The traditional BoK approach often struggled to keep pace with industry shifts and failed to clearly articulate the professional value of an IS graduate to potential employers.

Presented as a panel proposal for the AIS SIG-ED IAIM 2016 Conference, this work details the transition toward a "competency-based" model. This new framework shifts the focus from what is being taught in the classroom to what students can actually do upon graduation. By prioritizing measurable professional competencies, the MSIS 2016 Global Competence Model aims to bridge the gap between academic theory and industry practice.

The Problem: The Disconnect Between Academy and Industry

The authors identify a significant disconnect in the IS field: while universities focus on delivering lectures and covering syllabi, the professional world prioritizes outcomes—specifically, the ability of a graduate to perform complex tasks within a business context. Furthermore, the IS discipline has historically faced an identity crisis, situated at the intersection of business and computing without a universally recognized professional standard.

Without a clear definition of what an IS professional is capable of, the field risks losing its distinct identity to pure Computer Science or general Business Administration. There is a pressing need for a globally recognized, outcome-focused standard that defines the unique professional identity of IS graduates and ensures their relevance in a rapidly changing global economy.

Methodology: Developing the MSIS 2016 Model

The development of the MSIS 2016 Global Competency Model represents a departure from previous top-down curriculum recommendations. Instead, it was built through a highly collaborative, global process designed to capture a wide range of perspectives:

  • Global Task Force: The model was spearheaded by a representative group with members spanning three continents and six countries, ensuring the framework was not limited to a single regional perspective.
  • Iterative Feedback Loops: Over a two-year period (2015–2016), the task force conducted four separate surveys and released multiple interim deliverables to gather feedback from the global IS academic and professional community.
  • Framework Integration: Rather than reinventing the wheel, the authors analyzed and integrated existing regional competency frameworks. This included the European e-Competence Framework (e-CF) and the Skills Framework for the Information Age (SFIA) used internationally.
  • Outcome-Based Design: The core methodology involves defining "program learning outcomes" that translate directly into professional competencies. This moves the educational focus away from instructor-led delivery toward student-centered achievement.

Key Insights: From Teaching to Learning

The most significant insight of the MSIS 2016 model is the fundamental shift from teaching to learning. This encourages a broader range of pedagogical models beyond the traditional classroom lecture, allowing for experiential learning, project-based assessments, and other methods that better simulate professional environments.

Professional Identity and Global Harmonization

By explicitly articulating competencies, the IS field can better distinguish its unique value proposition. The model argues that focusing on professional roles does not mean reducing university education to mere vocational training. Instead, it incorporates high-level general competencies—such as critical thinking and ethical leadership—that enable life-long learning and career progression.

Furthermore, the paper highlights the effort to achieve global harmonization. By bringing together disparate regional standards (like Europe's e-CF and various Australian curriculum models) into a single, cohesive global model, the MSIS 2016 framework provides a common language for IS education worldwide.

Results and Impact

The primary result of this effort is the MSIS 2016 Global Competency Model itself. The adoption of this model offers several key benefits to the IS community:

  1. Strengthened Professional Image: It provides clearer communication to employers regarding the specific capabilities of IS graduates.
  2. Improved Quality Assurance: It offers a robust foundation for accreditation bodies to evaluate programs based on tangible outcomes rather than just course lists.
  3. Institutional Flexibility: The competency-driven approach allows individual universities to reach the same competency goals using different teaching methods or local contexts, fostering innovation in curriculum delivery.

Limitations and Future Directions

The authors acknowledge the inherent tension in developing a global curriculum: it must remain "fresh" enough to reflect cutting-edge technology—such as big data, artificial intelligence, and cloud computing—while still nurturing the "core" competencies that have defined the IS discipline for decades.

Future work focuses on the practical implementation of the model in universities worldwide and aligning with global accreditation bodies to adopt competency-based evaluation metrics. Finally, the authors emphasize the need for continuous revision to ensure the model evolves alongside the digital landscape, preventing it from becoming a static document like the 2006 model it replaced.

Summary updated

Abstract

The panel has three objectives: First, it will present multiple perspectives on competency-driven approaches to developing and evaluating degree programs in Information Systems and compare the competency-driven approach to earlier, teaching topic or body of knowledge –driven approaches. Second, it will introduce the (nearly) completed version of the MSIS 2016 global competency model to the members of the global IS community and celebrate IS community’s efforts to improve the quality of graduate education. Third, the panel will discuss the essential role the competency-driven approach has as a foundation of MSIS 2016.
BibTeX
@article{topi2016competency,
  author = {Heikki Topi and Helena Karsten and Susan A. Brown and João Álvaro Carvalho and Brian Donnellan and Jun Shen and Bernard C. Y. Tan},
  title = {{Competency-Based Approach to Information Systems Program Development: Guidance from the MSIS 2016 Global Competence Model}},
  journal = {Journal of the Association for Information Systems},
  year = {2016},
}
Figure