Modelling genetic stability in engineered cell populations

Duncan Ingram, Guy‐Bart Stan

Abstract

Predicting the evolution of engineered cell populations is a highly sought-after goal in biotechnology. While models of evolutionary dynamics are far from new, their application to synthetic systems is scarce where the vast combination of genetic parts and regulatory elements creates a unique challenge. To address this gap, we here-in present a framework that allows one to connect the DNA design of varied genetic devices with mutation spread in a growing cell population. Users can specify the functional parts of their system and the degree of mutation heterogeneity to explore, after which our model generates host-aware transition dynamics between different mutation phenotypes over time. We show how our framework can be used to generate insightful hypotheses across broad applications, from how a device's components can be tweaked to optimise long-term protein yield and genetic shelf life, to generating new design paradigms for gene regulatory networks that improve their functionality.

Introduction

In synthetic biology, evolution is often viewed as a hurdle. Engineering a cell to produce pharmaceuticals or biofuels imposes a metabolic burden, consuming vital resources like ribosomes and energy. Consequently, cells that acquire mutations disabling these synthetic functions gain a competitive advantage, growing faster than their functional counterparts. Over time, these "mutant cheaters" inevitably dominate the population—a process known as evolutionary fixation.

Traditional models of this process often oversimplify the dynamics, treating mutations as binary (functional vs. non-functional) and ignoring the intricate relationship between specific genetic components and the host cell's internal economy. There has been a significant need for tools that can predict the "genetic shelf life" of a design in a bioreactor setting.

Methods: A Host-Aware Framework

The researchers developed a mathematical framework based on Ordinary Differential Equations (ODEs) to bridge the gap between molecular DNA design and population-level evolution.

Overview of the host-aware mutation framework in a turbidostat environment.

The framework incorporates several key features:

  • Host-Awareness: By integrating a resource-allocation sub-model, the framework tracks how synthetic gene expression competes for cellular resources. This directly links protein production levels to a specific growth-rate penalty.
  • Mutation Heterogeneity: Moving beyond binary states, the model allows for a multi-dimensional state space where users can define various genetic parts and mutation severities (from fully functional to intermediate to broken).
  • Automated Dynamics: Transition dynamics between different mutation phenotypes are automatically generated based on user-defined parameters such as mutation rates and promoter strengths.
  • Environmental Simulation: The model simulates a turbidostat, the standard laboratory environment for studying long-term evolutionary stability.

Key Insights: The Role of Intermediate States

One of the most significant findings of this framework is the impact of intermediate mutations. By accounting for states where a gene is only partially functional, the model reveals complex population dynamics that binary models fail to capture.

Simulated population dynamics showing the transition from engineered (E) to mutant (M) cells via an intermediate (I) state.

The model highlights a critical trade-off for bioengineers: while high-expression promoters maximize short-term yield, they accelerate mutant takeover. The "optimal" promoter strength depends heavily on the intended duration of the bioreactor run. Furthermore, the framework suggests that mutation heterogeneity can create unexpected inflection points in population performance. For instance, in genetic toggle switches, intermediate mutations might temporarily increase switching capacity before total failure occurs.

Results and Validation

The framework was validated using experimental fluorescence decay data from E. coli populations. The model achieved high-accuracy fits by adjusting only four key parameters related to growth rates and mutation probabilities.

Key results include:

  • Shelf-Life Optimization: The model demonstrates that adjusting expression levels (e.g., promoter strength) is often more effective for extending genetic stability than attempting to lower biological mutation rates.
  • Design Robustness: Analysis of synthetic oscillators (repressilators) showed they are surprisingly resilient; a failure in one gene often leaves enough metabolic burden on the mutant to prevent it from immediately outcompeting the functional population.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This framework provides a predictive "map" for synthetic biology, offering design paradigms to choose DNA parts based on desired "time to failure." While currently calibrated for E. coli, future work involves adapting the host-aware equations for other organisms like yeast or mammalian cells. Additionally, while the model's yield predictions are well-supported, the complex hypotheses regarding regulatory network motifs like toggle switches and repressilators await further long-term experimental validation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Predicting the evolution of engineered cell populations is a highly sought-after goal in biotechnology. While models of evolutionary dynamics are far from new, their application to synthetic systems is scarce where the vast combination of genetic parts and regulatory elements creates a unique challenge. To address this gap, we here-in present a framework that allows one to connect the DNA design of varied genetic devices with mutation spread in a growing cell population. Users can specify the functional parts of their system and the degree of mutation heterogeneity to explore, after which our model generates host-aware transition dynamics between different mutation phenotypes over time. We show how our framework can be used to generate insightful hypotheses across broad applications, from how a device's components can be tweaked to optimise long-term protein yield and genetic shelf life, to generating new design paradigms for gene regulatory networks that improve their functionality.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ingram2023modelling,
  author = {Duncan Ingram and Guy‐Bart Stan},
  title = {{Modelling genetic stability in engineered cell populations}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-023-38850-6},
}
Figure