Modeling and simulation of synthetic nanopores using MsSimPore

Marie-Thérèse Wolfram, Jan‐Frederik Pietschmann, Martin Burger, C. Trautmann, Zuzanna S. Siwy, Veronika Bayer, Gael Nguyen, Matthew PevarnikarXiv 2012 · arXiv

Abstract: MsSimPore is a novel finite element software package for the simulation of ion flow through nanopores, which are radially symmetric or whose lateral extension is negligible to the longitudinal one. Its graphical user interface allows for the variation of experimental parameters and the subsequent visualization of the calculated results. MsSimPore offers different solver options, either simulations of the concentration profiles for single applied voltages or the calculation of current-voltage and rectification curves. In this paper we discuss the basic features of MsSimPore and the underlying mathematical modeling. Furthermore we compare the simulations with current voltage curves, obtained from conical and cigar shaped nanopores, under different experimental conditions.

Introduction: The Challenge of Nanopore Miniaturization

Nanopores—nanoscale channels in synthetic membranes—are foundational components for next-generation biological sensors and ionic logic gates. A critical functional characteristic of these pores is ion current rectification. Similar to a semiconductor diode, a conically shaped nanopore can rectify current, allowing ions to flow more efficiently in one direction than the other.

While the impact of pore diameter on rectification is well-documented, the role of pore length has often been overlooked. As research shifts toward ultra-thin membranes like graphene or thin polymers to achieve higher sensitivity, understanding the "miniaturization effect" becomes vital. Standard 1D models frequently fail for short pores because they neglect "access resistance"—the electrochemical behavior of ions immediately outside the pore entrances. Conversely, full 3D models are computationally prohibitive for high-throughput parameter sweeps. MsSimPore was developed to bridge this gap.

Methods: The MsSimPore Approach

MsSimPore utilizes a specialized 1D reduction of the Poisson-Nernst-Planck (PNP) equations, which describe the coupled dynamics of ion concentration and electric potential. A key innovation of the software is the explicit inclusion of bulk electrolyte reservoirs at both ends of the pore.

Schematic of the nanopore geometry in MsSimPore, including the PET membrane and surrounding electrolyte baths.

By modeling these reservoirs, MsSimPore captures the critical voltage drops and concentration gradients occurring at the pore entrances—a necessity for accurately representing short pores where access resistance dominates. The software employs a hybrid discontinuous Galerkin finite element scheme, ensuring numerical stability even at the high surface charge densities (up to -2 e/nm²) often encountered in experimental setups.

Key Insights: Length and Surface Charge Optimization

Simulations conducted with MsSimPore reveal that rectification is highly sensitive to pore length. A pore that functions as a strong diode at a length of 12 µm may behave as a simple ohmic resistor when shortened to under 100 nm. This "miniaturization penalty" suggests that geometric scaling alone is insufficient for maintaining performance in thin-film devices.

Furthermore, the research identified a counterintuitive "sweet spot" for surface charge. Increasing the surface charge density does not indefinitely improve rectification. Instead, there is an optimum density beyond which performance declines.

Rectification as a function of surface charge density, showing a peak at approximately -0.4 e/nm².

As shown in the figure, rectification peaks and then decreases at higher charge densities. This occurs because extreme surface charges make the pore so selective that it excludes one type of ion almost entirely, which paradoxically reduces the asymmetry of the current flow between forward and reverse bias. For a 187 nm long pore, maximum rectification was observed at a surface charge of approximately -0.25 e/nm², providing a specific target for experimental optimization.

Results and Validation

The accuracy of MsSimPore was validated against experimental current-voltage (I-V) data from 12-µm long conical nanopores etched into PET foils. The simulations successfully reproduced experimental curves across varying pH levels and KCl concentrations (0.1 M and 0.01 M), correctly predicting how changes in surface charge (driven by pH) influence ion transport.

The study demonstrates that lost rectification in short pores can be recovered by precisely tailoring the surface charge and the specific internal geometry (e.g., adjusting the cone angle or adopting "cigar-shaped" profiles).

Conclusion and Future Work

MsSimPore provides a robust and efficient tool for designing and optimizing synthetic nanopores. While the current 1D model assumes radial symmetry and treats ions as point charges, it offers a powerful framework for exploring the vast parameter space of nanopore physics. Future iterations may incorporate non-linear PNP equations to account for ion crowding in extremely narrow pores (< 2 nm). Additionally, the tool holds promise for solving "inverse problems," allowing researchers to deduce the hidden internal geometry and charge distribution of a nanopore from its measured I-V characteristics.

Summary updated

Abstract

MsSimPore is a novel finite element software package for the simulation of ion flow through nanopores, which are radially symmetric or whose lateral extension is negligible to the longitudinal one. Its graphical user interface allows for the variation of experimental parameters and the subsequent visualization of the calculated results. MsSimPore offers different solver options, either simulations of the concentration profiles for single applied voltages or the calculation of current-voltage and rectification curves. In this paper we discuss the basic features of MsSimPore and the underlying mathematical modeling. Furthermore we compare the simulations with current voltage curves, obtained from conical and cigar shaped nanopores, under different experimental conditions.
BibTeX
@misc{wolfram2012modeling,
  author = {Marie-Thérèse Wolfram and Jan‐Frederik Pietschmann and Martin Burger and C. Trautmann and Zuzanna S. Siwy and Veronika Bayer and Gael Nguyen and Matthew Pevarnik},
  title = {{Modeling and simulation of synthetic nanopores using MsSimPore}},
  year = {2012},
  eprint = {1209.4164},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1209.4164},
}
Figure