Model‐based detection and analysis of introgressed Neanderthal ancestry in modern humans

Matthias Steinrücken, Jeffrey P. Spence, Jack Kamm, Emilia Wieczorek, Yun S. Song

TL;DR

Researchers have developed diCal-admix, a new hidden Markov model (HMM) that uses explicit demographic history to pinpoint Neanderthal DNA fragments in modern human genomes. Their analysis suggests that the "purging" of Neanderthal ancestry over millennia was likely driven by a high "genetic load" (accumulated weak mutations) in the small Neanderthal population, rather than fundamental biological incompatibilities between the two groups.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

When modern humans migrated out of Africa, they encountered and interbred with Neanderthals. Today, non-African individuals carry a small percentage of Neanderthal DNA. However, identifying exactly which segments of a person's genome are "archaic" is difficult because these fragments have been broken down by recombination over 50,000 years.

Existing methods often rely on machine learning "features" or simple sequence similarity, which can be prone to errors or lack biological context. Furthermore, there is an ongoing debate in evolutionary biology: Why is Neanderthal DNA depleted in certain parts of our genome (like the X-chromosome)? Is it because Neanderthal-human hybrids were partially infertile (Dobzhansky-Müller incompatibilities), or simply because Neanderthals had a small population that accumulated slightly "bad" mutations which natural selection is now slowly scrubbing away?

Methods

The authors introduce diCal-admix, a model-based approach built on the Conditional Sampling Distribution (CSD).

  • The HMM Engine: It treats a modern human genome as a mosaic. At any given point, the DNA is "copied" from either a modern African reference (representing the ancestral human lineage) or a Neanderthal reference.
  • Demographic Awareness: Unlike "black box" methods, diCal-admix explicitly incorporates parameters like the time of the human-Neanderthal split (~325,000 years ago) and the time of the interbreeding event (~47,500 years ago).
  • Posterior Decoding: The model calculates the probability of Neanderthal ancestry at every window across the genome, allowing for a high-resolution map of introgression.
  • Simulations: They used the coalescent simulator msprime to generate synthetic data, proving the method is robust even if the demographic parameters (like the exact date of interbreeding) are slightly off.

Datasets

  • 1000 Genomes Project (Phase I): Specifically focusing on Europeans (CEU) and East Asians (CHB and CHS).
  • YRI (Yoruba in Ibadan, Nigeria): Used as an "introgression-free" modern human reference panel.
  • Altai Neanderthal: A high-coverage genome from an individual found in the Altai Mountains, used as the archaic reference.
  • Simulated Data: Extensive datasets generated via msprime to benchmark accuracy and precision.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Genetic Load" Hypothesis: The study provides evidence that selection against Neanderthal DNA was likely due to mutational load. Because Neanderthals had a very small effective population size, natural selection was inefficient, allowing slightly deleterious mutations to pile up. When these entered the much larger human population, they were "purged" by more efficient selection.
  • Questioning Incompatibilities: They tested for Dobzhansky-Müller Incompatibilities (DMIs)—specific "clashes" between human and Neanderthal proteins. By analyzing protein-protein interaction networks, they found no significant evidence that interacting proteins were less likely to be co-introgressed, casting doubt on the idea that hybrids were biologically "broken."
  • The X-Chromosome Depletion: Neanderthal ancestry is roughly 5 times lower on the X-chromosome than on autosomes. The authors show through forward simulations that this doesn't necessarily require complex hybrid sterility models; even moderate selection against the Neanderthal genetic load can explain this pattern.
  • Adaptive Introgression: Consistent with previous work, they found that genes related to hair and skin (keratin pathways) are enriched for Neanderthal DNA, suggesting these archaic variants helped humans adapt to colder, non-African environments.

Key Results

  • Average Ancestry: They detected an average of 1.03% Neanderthal ancestry in Europeans and 1.25% in East Asians. These figures are slightly lower than some previous estimates but confirm the trend that East Asians carry more archaic DNA.
  • X-Chromosome: A dramatic reduction was observed, with only ~0.2% to 0.28% Neanderthal ancestry on the X-chromosome.
  • Fragment Lengths: diCal-admix was particularly effective at detecting shorter fragments that other methods might miss, providing a more complete picture of the "genomic landscape" of ancestry.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Phasing Challenges: The method requires "phased" data (knowing which mutations are on which chromosome copy). While modern human data is easily phased, ancient genomes like the Altai Neanderthal are not, requiring the use of "pseudo-haplotypes."
  • Simplified Recombination: The model assumes a constant recombination rate across a chromosome, which is a simplification of biological reality.
  • Single Pulse Model: The current study assumes a single event of interbreeding. Future versions could be expanded to model multiple pulses of introgression, which some researchers believe occurred in East Asian history.
  • Expanding the Reference: Incorporating more high-quality ancient genomes (like the recently sequenced Vindija Neanderthal) could further refine the detection of these ancient genetic echoes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Genetic evidence has revealed that the ancestors of modern human populations outside Africa and their hominin sister groups, notably Neanderthals, exchanged genetic material in the past. The distribution of these introgressed sequence tracts along modern-day human genomes provides insight into the selective forces acting on them and the role of introgression in the evolutionary history of hominins. Studying introgression patterns on the X-chromosome is of particular interest, as sex chromosomes are thought to play a special role in speciation. Recent studies have developed methods to localize introgressed ancestries, reporting long regions that are depleted of Neanderthal introgression and enriched in genes, suggesting negative selection against the Neanderthal variants. On the other hand, enriched Neanderthal ancestry in hair- and skin-related genes suggests that some introgressed variants facilitated adaptation to new environments. Here, we present a model-based introgression detection method called dical-admix. We demonstrate its efficiency and accuracy through extensive simulations and apply it to detect tracts of Neanderthal introgression in modern human individuals from the 1000 Genomes Project. Our findings are largely concordant with previous studies, consistent with weak selection against Neanderthal ancestry. We find evidence that selection against Neanderthal ancestry was due to higher genetic load in Neanderthals resulting from small effective population size, rather than widespread Dobzhansky-Müller incompatibilities (DMIs) that could contribute to reproductive isolation. Moreover, we confirm the previously reported low level of introgression on the X-chromosome, but find little evidence that DMIs contributed to this pattern.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{steinrucken2018modelbased,
  author = {Matthias Steinrücken and Jeffrey P. Spence and Jack Kamm and Emilia Wieczorek and Yun S. Song},
  title = {{Model‐based detection and analysis of introgressed Neanderthal ancestry in modern humans}},
  booktitle = {Molecular},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1111/mec.14565},
}
Figure