Sharing of Very Short IBD Segments between Humans, Neandertals, and Denisovans

Gundula Povysil, Sepp HochreiterbioRxiv 2014 · DOI

Abstract

We analyze the sharing of very short identity by descent (IBD) segments between humans, Neandertals, and Denisovans to gain new insights into their demographic history. Short IBD segments convey information about events far back in time because the shorter IBD segments are, the older they are assumed to be. The identification of short IBD segments becomes possible through next generation sequencing (NGS), which offers high variant density and reports variants of all frequencies. However, only recently HapFABIA has been proposed as the first method for detecting very short IBD segments in NGS data. HapFABIA utilizes rare variants to identify IBD segments with a low false discovery rate. We applied HapFABIA to the 1000 Genomes Project whole genome sequencing data to identify IBD segments that are shared within and between populations. Many IBD segments have to be old since they are shared with Neandertals or Denisovans, which explains their shorter lengths compared to segments that are not shared with these ancient genomes. The Denisova genome most prominently matches IBD segments that are shared by Asians. Many of these segments were found exclusively in Asians and they are longer than segments shared between other continental populations and the Denisova genome. Therefore, we could confirm an introgression from Deniosvans into ancestors of Asians after their migration out of Africa. While Neandertal-matching IBD segments are most often shared by Asians, Europeans share a considerably higher percentage of IBD segments with Neandertals compared to other populations, too. Again, many of these Neandertal-matching IBD segments are found exclusively in Asians, whereas Neandertal-matching IBD segments that are shared by Europeans are often found in other populations, too. Neandertal-matching IBD segments that are shared by Asians or Europeans are longer than those observed in Africans. These IBD segments hint at a gene flow from Neandertals into ancestors of Asians and Europeans after they left Africa. Interestingly, many Neandertal- and/or Denisova-matching IBD segments are predominantly observed in Africans - some of them even exclusively. IBD segments shared between Africans and Neandertals or Denisovans are strikingly short, therefore we assume that they are very old. Consequently, we conclude that DNA regions from ancestors of humans, Neandertals, and Denisovans have survived in Africans. As expected, IBD segments on chromosome X are on average longer than IBD segments on the autosomes. Neandertal-matching IBD segments on chromosome X confirm gene flow from Neandertals into ancestors of Asians and Europeans outside Africa that was already found on the autosomes. Interestingly, there is hardly any signal of Denisova introgression on the X chromosome.

Introduction

To reconstruct the complex tapestry of human evolution, geneticists rely on Identity by Descent (IBD) segments—stretches of DNA shared by individuals due to inheritance from a common ancestor. The length of these segments serves as a molecular clock: recombination breaks segments apart over generations, meaning long segments indicate recent common ancestry, while very short segments point to events tens of thousands of years in the past.

Detecting very short IBD segments (under 100 kbp) has historically been challenging. Such small fragments are often indistinguishable from Identity by State (IBS), where sequences match by random chance or recurrent mutation rather than shared ancestry. This study addresses this limitation by utilizing a novel approach to explore the "twilight zone" of human history, mapping the genetic interactions between modern humans and extinct hominids like Neandertals and Denisovans.

Methodology

The researchers employed HapFABIA, a biclustering algorithm designed specifically to extract short IBD segments from Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) data.

Rare Variant Tagging

HapFABIA leverages rare variants (Minor Allele Frequency $\le$ 5%). Since rare variants are highly unlikely to arise independently in multiple lineages, their presence in a shared segment is a robust indicator of IBD rather than IBS. This allows the detection of segments as small as 10 kbp, a significant improvement over previous methods limited to ~1 Mbp.

Data Sources

The study utilized whole-genome sequencing data from the 1000 Genomes Project (Phase 1), comprising 1,092 individuals across 14 populations (African, European, East Asian, and Admixed American). These were compared against high-coverage reference genomes for the Altai Neandertal (52X) and the Denisovan (31X).

Results and Discussion

Global Patterns of Archaic Introgression

The analysis identified approximately 1.35 million short IBD segments on the autosomes. The results confirm and refine existing models of archaic gene flow:

  • Denisovan Signal: East Asian populations showed the highest enrichment for Denisovan-matching segments (Odds Ratio: 5.83), while African populations showed the lowest (0.24). These segments were often longer in Asians than in other groups, confirming introgression occurred after the migration out of Africa.
  • Neandertal Signal: Enrichment was most pronounced in Asians (22.16) and Europeans (12.98). Neandertal-matching segments in these populations were significantly longer than those found in Africans, supporting post-migration gene flow.

The African Reservoir

A major finding was the presence of Neandertal- and Denisova-matching segments in African populations, sometimes exclusively. These segments are "strikingly short," suggesting they are extremely old. Rather than representing recent "back-to-Africa" migrations, these fragments likely represent ancestral DNA from the common progenitors of humans and archaic hominids that has persisted in Africa for hundreds of thousands of years.

X-Chromosome Dynamics

The X chromosome provided unique insights. While Neandertal signals were present (though weaker than on autosomes), there was virtually no signal of Denisova introgression on the X chromosome. This suggests either strong selective pressure against Denisovan DNA on the X chromosome or a sex-biased history of interaction, such as male Denisovans primarily contributing to the human gene pool.

Conclusion

By pushing the boundaries of IBD detection to the 10 kbp scale, this research reveals a more nuanced history of human-archaic interaction. While confirming major introgression events in Eurasia, the discovery of ancient shared segments in Africa highlights the deep roots of our species. Future work with larger datasets and additional ancient genomes will continue to refine our understanding of these ancient demographic events.

Reference: Povysil, G., & Hochreiter, S. (2014). Sharing of Very Short IBD Segments between Humans, Neandertals, and Denisovans. Research Report, Institute of Bioinformatics, Johannes Kepler University Linz.

Summary updated

Abstract

We analyze the sharing of very short identity by descent (IBD) segments between humans, Neandertals, and Denisovans to gain new insights into their demographic history. Short IBD segments convey information about events far back in time because the shorter IBD segments are, the older they are assumed to be. The identification of short IBD segments becomes possible through next generation sequencing (NGS), which offers high variant density and reports variants of all frequencies. However, only recently HapFABIA has been proposed as the first method for detecting very short IBD segments in NGS data. HapFABIA utilizes rare variants to identify IBD segments with a low false discovery rate. We applied HapFABIA to the 1000 Genomes Project whole genome sequencing data to identify IBD segments that are shared within and between populations. Many IBD segments have to be old since they are shared with Neandertals or Denisovans, which explains their shorter lengths compared to segments that are not shared with these ancient genomes. The Denisova genome most prominently matches IBD segments that are shared by Asians. Many of these segments were found exclusively in Asians and they are longer than segments shared between other continental populations and the Denisova genome. Therefore, we could confirm an introgression from Deniosvans into ancestors of Asians after their migration out of Africa. While Neandertal-matching IBD segments are most often shared by Asians, Europeans share a considerably higher percentage of IBD segments with Neandertals compared to other populations, too. Again, many of these Neandertal-matching IBD segments are found exclusively in Asians, whereas Neandertal-matching IBD segments that are shared by Europeans are often found in other populations, too. Neandertal-matching IBD segments that are shared by Asians or Europeans are longer than those observed in Africans. These IBD segments hint at a gene flow from Neandertals into ancestors of Asians and Europeans after they left Africa. Interestingly, many Neandertal- and/or Denisova-matching IBD segments are predominantly observed in Africans - some of them even exclusively. IBD segments shared between Africans and Neandertals or Denisovans are strikingly short, therefore we assume that they are very old. Consequently, we conclude that DNA regions from ancestors of humans, Neandertals, and Denisovans have survived in Africans. As expected, IBD segments on chromosome X are on average longer than IBD segments on the autosomes. Neandertal-matching IBD segments on chromosome X confirm gene flow from Neandertals into ancestors of Asians and Europeans outside Africa that was already found on the autosomes. Interestingly, there is hardly any signal of Denisova introgression on the X chromosome.
BibTeX
@misc{povysil2014sharing,
  author = {Gundula Povysil and Sepp Hochreiter},
  title = {{Sharing of Very Short IBD Segments between Humans, Neandertals, and Denisovans}},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1101/003988},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure