Model-Free Renewable Scenario Generation Using Generative Adversarial Networks

Yize Chen, Yishen Wang, Daniel S. Kirschen, Baosen Zhang

TL;DR

This paper presents a data-driven, "model-free" approach to generating realistic renewable energy scenarios using Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs). By training two competing neural networks, the authors can synthesize high-fidelity wind and solar power profiles that capture complex spatial and temporal correlations without requiring explicit statistical assumptions or manual labeling.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As power grids incorporate more renewable energy, system operators face a massive challenge: intermittency. To plan effectively (e.g., deciding which power plants to turn on or how to manage storage), operators need "scenarios"—sets of possible future time-series data for wind and solar production.

Traditional methods for generating these scenarios are "model-based," meaning they rely on fitting historical data to specific mathematical distributions (like Gaussian or Copula models). These traditional approaches often struggle because:

  1. Complexity: Renewable energy is nonlinear, bounded (0 to max capacity), and highly intermittent.
  2. Scaling: It is mathematically difficult to model the correlations between dozens of different wind farms simultaneously.
  3. Assumptions: If the underlying data doesn't fit the assumed statistical model, the generated scenarios will be unrealistic, potentially leading to poor grid management decisions.

Methods

The authors propose using Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), specifically a variation utilizing Wasserstein Distance (WGAN) to improve training stability.

The architecture consists of two deep neural networks:

  • The Generator ($G$): Takes random noise as input and attempts to transform it into a realistic 24-hour power profile. It uses de-convolutional layers to "up-sample" noise into a structured time series.
  • The Discriminator ($D$): Acts as a critic, looking at both real historical data and the "fake" data from the generator, trying to tell them apart. It uses convolutional layers to extract features from the power profiles.

Through an "adversarial" game, the Generator learns to produce scenarios so realistic that the Discriminator can no longer distinguish them from real history.

Crucially, the authors also implement Conditional GANs (CGANs). By adding "labels" (like the month of the year or the presence of a high-ramp event) to the training process, they can force the model to generate specific types of scenarios on demand—for example, "generate a typical solar profile for a cloudy day in July."

Datasets

The study utilizes high-resolution data from the NREL (National Renewable Energy Laboratory) Integration Datasets:

  • Wind: Data from 24 wind farms in Washington State.
  • Solar: Data from 32 solar power plants in the same region.
  • Resolution: 5-minute intervals, providing a granular look at power fluctuations.
  • Forecasts: 24-hour ahead forecast data was also used to train the conditional models for forecast error scenarios.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Model-Free Advantage: Unlike traditional methods, the GAN doesn't need to know if the data is Gaussian or follows a specific "copula." It learns the underlying "physics" and patterns of the weather implicitly from the raw data.
  • Capturing "Modes": Using Wasserstein distance helps the model capture "mode diversity." This means the GAN doesn't just generate the "average" day; it learns to generate the full spectrum of behaviors, from calm days to extreme ramp events.
  • Spatial Awareness: When fed data from multiple sites simultaneously, the GAN naturally learns the spatial correlations (e.g., if it's windy at Farm A, it’s likely windy at nearby Farm B).
  • Efficiency: Once the network is trained, generating a new scenario is nearly instantaneous—requiring only a single "forward pass" through the neural network, which is much faster than traditional iterative sampling.

Key Results

  • Statistical Fidelity: The generated scenarios' Cumulative Distribution Functions (CDFs) and Autocorrelation plots almost perfectly match historical data, proving the GAN captures both the "amount" of power and the "rhythm" of its changes over time.
  • Spectral Accuracy: Power Spectral Density (PSD) analysis showed that the GAN correctly replicates the periodic diurnal (daily) patterns of wind and solar.
  • Preserving Correlations: The model successfully maintained the spatial correlation matrix between 24 different wind farms, even when 10% noise was added to the training data, demonstrating significant robustness.
  • Superior Conditional Performance: When compared to the standard Gaussian Copula method, the GAN was significantly better at capturing extreme values and the specific shapes of "ramp events" (sudden increases or decreases in power).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Hunger: As a deep learning method, the GAN requires a substantial amount of high-quality historical data to train effectively.
  • Interpretability: While the GAN produces excellent results, it remains a "black box." It is difficult to extract explicit physical rules from the trained weights.
  • Integration into Optimization: The authors suggest that the next step is to integrate these GAN-generated scenarios directly into stochastic optimization tools for real-world grid dispatch and unit commitment.
  • Probabilistic Forecasting: There is potential to extend this work into real-time probabilistic forecasting, where the GAN generates scenarios conditioned on current live weather forecasts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Scenario generation is an important step in the operation and planning of power systems with high renewable penetrations. In this work, we proposed a data-driven approach for scenario generation using generative adversarial networks, which is based on two interconnected deep neural networks. Compared with existing methods based on probabilistic models that are often hard to scale or sample from, our method is data-driven, and captures renewable energy production patterns in both temporal and spatial dimensions for a large number of correlated resources. For validation, we use wind and solar times-series data from NREL integration data sets. We demonstrate that the proposed method is able to generate realistic wind and photovoltaic power profiles with full diversity of behaviors. We also illustrate how to generate scenarios based on different conditions of interest by using labeled data during training. For example, scenarios can be conditioned on weather events (e.g., high wind day, intense ramp events, or large forecasts errors) or time of the year (e.g., solar generation for a day in July). Because of the feedforward nature of the neural networks, scenarios can be generated extremely efficiently without sophisticated sampling techniques.
BibTeX
@article{chen2018model,
  author = {Yize Chen and Yishen Wang and Daniel S. Kirschen and Baosen Zhang},
  title = {{Model-Free Renewable Scenario Generation Using Generative Adversarial Networks}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Power Systems},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1109/tpwrs.2018.2794541},
}

Loading related content...

Figure