Abstract
A comprehensive literature search was performed using a combination of keywords (MeSH terms and free text words) including 'COVID-19'/ 'SARS-CoV*'/'SARS'/'MERS' , 'aerosol' , 'surgery' , 'operation/procedure' , 'endoscopy' , and 'healthcare workers' . MEDLINE, Embase, the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials were searched up to 18 July 2020. Preprint servers, medRxiv, and bioRxiv were also searched for information up to that date. The search was limited to studies published during or after 2003, when the SARS outbreak began. Only articles published in English or published in another language but containing an English abstract were included. The search results were supplemented by guidelines from professional bodies.
Introduction
Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, healthcare workers (HCWs) faced unprecedented infection risks, with over 22,000 infected globally by April 2020. A primary concern was "Aerosol-Generating Procedures" (AGPs)—medical interventions like intubation, endoscopy, or the use of high-speed surgical drills that create fine mists capable of carrying viral particles.
The challenge was twofold:
- Ambiguity: There was no clear consensus on which specific procedures constituted an AGP.
- Safety vs. Efficacy: Surgeons and endoscopists needed to balance the urgency of patient care with the need to protect the surgical team, often with conflicting recommendations from different professional bodies.
Methodology
The authors conducted a narrative review of literature published between 2003 (the start of the SARS outbreak) and July 18, 2020. They searched major databases including MEDLINE, Embase, and the Cochrane Library, as well as preprint servers like medRxiv and bioRxiv to capture the most current data available at the time. This search was supplemented by clinical guidelines from international professional societies. The review categorizes mitigation strategies into preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative phases, with specific deep dives into various surgical sub-specialties.
General Mitigation Strategies
The review identifies several cross-specialty strategies to reduce transmission risk:
- Anesthesia as a Risk Filter: One of the most effective ways to reduce aerosol generation is to avoid general anesthesia when possible. Regional or spinal anesthesia prevents the need for airway manipulation (intubation/extubation), which are high-intensity aerosol events.
- The Laparoscopy Paradox: Early in the pandemic, there was concern that laparoscopic surgery was more dangerous than open surgery due to the pressurized CO2 used to inflate the abdomen. However, the review suggests that laparoscopy may actually be safer if performed with closed-circuit smoke evacuation and ultra-small incisions, as it keeps the aerosol contained within the patient.
- Environmental Discipline: Beyond PPE, the authors emphasize "door discipline"—using telephones or intercoms to communicate between the operating theatre and the outside to minimize air turbulence caused by frequent door opening. The use of HEPA filters and negative-pressure rooms is also emphasized due to viral persistence in aerosols for up to 3 hours.
- PPE Efficacy: A cited cohort study found that wearing Level 3 PPE (including N95 masks and full gowns) resulted in a 95.3% reduction in an anesthetist’s risk of contracting COVID-19 compared to Level 1 PPE.
Specialty-Specific Mitigation Strategies
Different surgical sub-specialties face unique risks based on the anatomical sites and tools involved. The following table summarizes the evidence for aerosol generation and corresponding mitigation strategies across seven key surgical fields.
Key technical adjustments highlighted in the review include:
- Maxillofacial/Dental: Using high-volume suction, rubber dams, and preoperative oral rinses (0.12% chlorhexidine) to reduce the microbial load in oral aerosols.
- Neurosurgery: Preferring non-powered instruments or microdebriders over high-speed drills to minimize aerosolization, and using 3D ventilated masks for endoscopic skull base surgery.
- Ophthalmology: Installing protective shields on slit lamps and preferring applanation tonometry over non-contact methods which are considered AGPs.
Limitations and Future Work
The primary limitation is the time-bound nature of the review; it reflects the "early-pandemic" landscape and does not account for the impact of vaccines or later viral variants. Additionally, much of the early guidance was based on low-quality evidence or expert opinion rather than randomized controlled trials. The authors call for more rigorous clinical studies to definitively categorize AGPs and validate the long-term effectiveness of proposed mitigation tools, such as barrier boxes and specialized surgical masks.
Conclusion
This narrative review provides a comprehensive roadmap for mitigating COVID-19 transmission during high-risk surgical and endoscopic procedures. By emphasizing preoperative screening, specialized PPE, and technical modifications, the framework aims to protect healthcare workers while maintaining essential surgical services during a pandemic.
Summary updated