COVID-19 and the history of antiseptic surgery: how to tackle these little beasts

Teresa Tan, Ch Yee, Chi‐Fai Ng, Jeremy Yuen‐Chun TeohHong 2020 · DOI

Abstract

In the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic, a significant divide emerged between Western health recommendations and the practices of several Asian territories regarding universal masking. This commentary explores that tension by drawing a historical parallel to the 19th-century resistance against antiseptic surgery. By examining the legacies of Ignaz Semmelweis and Joseph Lister, the authors argue that pragmatic, low-risk interventions—such as masking—are essential tools in a public health crisis, even when definitive clinical trials have yet to be completed.

Introduction

The global response to the COVID-19 pandemic in early 2020 was characterized by a stark contrast in public health policy. While regions like Hong Kong, Taiwan, and China adopted universal masking almost immediately, many Western health organizations initially advised that masks were only necessary for the symptomatic or for healthcare professionals. This debate highlighted a fundamental tension in modern medicine: the requirement for "evidence-based" data from large-scale clinical trials versus the urgent need for pragmatic action during a burgeoning crisis.

This paper frames the modern masking debate through the lens of medical history, suggesting that the skepticism faced by early proponents of masks mirrors the professional pushback encountered by the pioneers of antisepsis.

The Lessons of History: Semmelweis and Lister

The authors utilize a historical comparative analysis to examine two pivotal figures in medical history:

  1. Ignaz Semmelweis: In the mid-19th century, Semmelweis demonstrated that hand washing in chlorinated lime solution could reduce mortality in obstetrics wards from nearly 20% to below 1%. Despite this success, he was ostracized by the medical community. His theories were rejected largely because he could not provide a biological explanation for why hand washing worked, as germ theory had not yet been established. When his practices were abandoned after his death, mortality rates in his former hospital increased sixfold.
  2. Joseph Lister: Building on the later work of Louis Pasteur, Lister promoted the use of carbolic acid to sterilize surgical instruments and wounds. Like Semmelweis, he faced initial mockery and resistance from a professional culture that viewed blood-stained hands and surgical coats as "proud battle marks" of experience.

These cases illustrate a recurring pattern: simple, life-saving hygiene interventions are often met with resistance due to professional ego, the inconvenience of changing established habits, and a lack of immediate "gold standard" evidence.

The Modern Parallel: Universal Masking

The authors argue that the 2020 debate over universal masking fell into the same "evidence gap" trap that hindered Semmelweis. Early in the pandemic, the lack of large-scale randomized controlled trials (RCTs) led some to dismiss masking as unproven. However, this perspective ignored the observational evidence of success in regions where masking was culturally normative and common.

Key Insights

  • The Precautionary Principle: The paper advocates for pragmatism. Universal masking is a "small inconvenience" with a high potential for saving lives. In the context of a novel and deadly virus, waiting for years of clinical trials before acting can be a fatal mistake.
  • Synergistic Intervention: Masking should not be viewed as a standalone solution but as a synergistic tool that works alongside hand washing, social distancing, and quarantine measures.
  • Aerosol Control: The authors point to emerging evidence (e.g., Leung et al., 2020) suggesting that masks are effective at limiting the shedding of respiratory viruses in exhaled breath, providing a mechanical rationale for their use even in the absence of specific COVID-19 RCTs.

Conclusion

The history of antiseptic surgery teaches us that waiting for a complete scientific explanation or a perfect dataset can result in unnecessary loss of life. At the time of this commentary's publication in June 2020, the observational success of masking in Asian territories provided a compelling case for its adoption elsewhere. The authors conclude that public health policy must remain flexible and practical when facing novel threats, prioritizing the precautionary principle over rigid adherence to traditional evidence hierarchies during an emergency. Ultimately, the "little beasts" of infection—whether bacteria in the 19th century or viruses in the 21st—require a swift and pragmatic defense.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{tan2020covid,
  author = {Teresa Tan and CH Yee and Chi‐Fai Ng and Jeremy Yuen‐Chun Teoh},
  title = {{COVID-19 and the history of antiseptic surgery: how to tackle these little beasts}},
  booktitle = {Hong},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.12809/hkmj208617},
}
Figure