Abstract
Background: Literature in the West suggested that bisexual men have a higher smoking rate compared to gay men. Data on patterns of smoking among gay and bisexual men are limited in Eastern countries like China. This study examined the cigarette smoking prevalence for gay versus bisexual men in China and their unique minority stress - smoking pathways. Methods: Between September 2017 and November 2018, we surveyed a convenience sample of 538 gay men and 138 bisexual men recruited from local sexual minority organizations in four metropolitan cities in China (i.e., Beijing, Wuhan, Nanchang, and Changsha). Measures included sexual orientation, sociodemographics, theory-based minority stressors, depressive symptoms, and past 30-day cigarette smoking. Two-group (gay men vs. bisexual men) structural equation modeling (SEM) was used to test possible distinct mechanisms between theory-based stressors, depressive symptoms, and cigarette smoking among gay men and bisexual men, respectively. Results: The average age of participants was 26.51 (SD = 8.41) years old and 76.3% of them had at least a college degree. Bisexual men reported a higher rate of cigarette smoking compared to gay men (39.9% vs. 27.3%). Two-group SEM indicated that the pathways for cigarette smoking were not different between gay and bisexual men. Higher rejection anticipation was associated with greater depressive symptoms (standardized β = 0.32, p < .001), and depressive symptoms was not associated with cigarette smoking. Conclusions: Minority stress, specifically rejection anticipation, may be critical considerations in addressing depressive symptoms, but not smoking, among both gay and bisexual men in China.
Introduction
China faces a significant public health challenge, with over one million smoking-related deaths recorded annually. While Western research has consistently demonstrated that sexual minorities exhibit higher smoking rates than the general population—with bisexual men often smoking more than gay men—data from Eastern cultural contexts remains limited. This study applies Minority Stress Theory to the Chinese context to investigate how chronic stress faced by stigmatized groups contributes to depression and smoking habits.
Minority Stress Theory distinguishes between "distal" stressors (external discrimination) and "proximal" stressors (internalized homophobia, identity concealment, and anticipation of rejection). This research specifically examines whether the psychological pathways from these stressors to health outcomes differ between gay and bisexual men in urban China.
Methodology
The study utilized a convenience sample of 676 self-identified gay (n=538) and bisexual (n=138) men recruited from sexual minority-serving organizations in Beijing, Wuhan, Nanchang, and Changsha. The cohort was relatively young (average age 26.5) and highly educated (76.3% college-educated).
Researchers employed Two-Group Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to analyze the complex web of hypothesized relationships. Before comparing groups, Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) was used to establish measurement invariance, ensuring that survey constructs like "rejection anticipation" were interpreted similarly by both gay and bisexual participants. Path analysis then determined if the strength of relationships between stressors, depression, and smoking varied significantly between the two groups.
Results and Key Findings
The analysis revealed a significant disparity in smoking prevalence: 39.9% of bisexual men were current smokers compared to 27.3% of gay men (p = .004). Despite this difference in prevalence, the SEM results indicated that the underlying psychological mechanisms were remarkably consistent across both groups.
The Role of Rejection Anticipation
"Rejection anticipation"—the hypervigilance and persistent worry about being rejected due to one's sexual orientation—emerged as the most potent predictor of mental health outcomes. It was strongly associated with increased depressive symptoms (standardized β = 0.32, p < .001). This suggests that the psychological burden of fearing stigma can be as impactful as experiencing actual discriminatory events.
The Stigma-Avoidance Hypothesis
In a counterintuitive finding, higher rejection anticipation was associated with a lower likelihood of being a current smoker (standardized β = -0.15, p < .001). The authors propose a "stigma-avoidance" hypothesis: in major Chinese cities where public smoking is increasingly regulated and socially discouraged, sexual minority men may avoid smoking to prevent adding another layer of social disapproval to their existing marginalized status.
The Missing Link to Depression
Notably, depressive symptoms were not significantly associated with cigarette smoking in this sample. This challenges the common "self-medication" hypothesis, suggesting that for this population, smoking may be driven more by social factors or specific group norms than by underlying clinical depression.
Discussion and Implications
The higher smoking rate among bisexual men, despite shared stress pathways with gay men, suggests a "Bisexual Paradox." This disparity may be driven by factors external to the current model, such as "double discrimination" from both heterosexual and gay communities, which warrants further investigation.
Furthermore, the association between being a student and lower smoking rates (despite higher rejection anticipation) suggests that the campus environment or smoke-free policies may provide a protective buffer.
Conclusion
While the study is limited by its cross-sectional design and highly educated urban sample, it provides critical insights into the health of sexual minorities in China. Interventions should prioritize addressing "rejection anticipation" to improve mental health outcomes. However, smoking cessation programs for gay and bisexual men may need to focus on social norms and stigma-avoidance strategies rather than solely addressing depressive symptoms.
Summary updated