Minority stress, depression, and cigarette smoking among Chinese gay versus bisexual men: A two-group structural equation model analyses

Jingjing Li, Danqin Huang, Michael Windle, Cam Escoffery, Wei Wang, Xiaoyan Li, Kevin Tao, Regine Haardörfer, Shiyue Li, Carla J. Berg, Hong Yan

Introduction

In Western contexts, research consistently shows that bisexual men experience higher rates of cigarette smoking compared to gay men. This is often attributed to "minority stress"—the chronic psychological burden faced by stigmatized groups. However, data from East Asian countries, particularly China, remains limited. This study investigates whether these disparities exist within the Chinese cultural context, where Confucian values and collectivist social structures heavily influence the experiences of sexual minorities.

Methods and Study Population

Researchers conducted a survey between 2017 and 2018, recruiting a convenience sample of 676 men (538 gay, 138 bisexual) from local sexual minority organizations in four major Chinese metropolitan hubs: Beijing, Wuhan, Nanchang, and Changsha. The participants were predominantly urban and well-educated, with 76.3% holding at least a college degree.

The study utilized Two-Group Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to analyze the relationships between theory-based minority stressors (e.g., everyday discrimination, rejection anticipation, internalized homophobia), depressive symptoms (measured via the CES-D scale), and past 30-day cigarette smoking. This approach allowed researchers to test whether the psychological "pathways" leading to smoking differed between gay and bisexual men.

Key Findings

The Bisexual Smoking Disparity

The study confirmed a significant disparity in smoking prevalence: 39.9% of bisexual men reported current smoking, compared to 27.3% of gay men ($p = .004$). This aligns with trends observed in Western literature, potentially reflecting a "double stigma" where bisexual individuals face rejection from both the heterosexual majority and the gay community, leading to a weaker sense of belonging to supportive networks.

Rejection Anticipation and Mental Health

Despite the difference in raw smoking rates, the SEM revealed that the underlying psychological mechanisms were remarkably similar for both groups. A primary driver of mental health struggles was "rejection anticipation." In a society where "saving face" and family harmony are paramount, the mere expectation of social ostracization was the strongest predictor of depressive symptoms ($\beta = 0.30$).

Interestingly, the research found no direct path from depressive symptoms to cigarette use in this cohort. This suggests that for these men, smoking might not serve as a "self-medication" tool for depression, but is instead driven by social factors or environmental cues. Furthermore, higher rejection anticipation was actually associated with lower smoking rates ($\beta = -0.15$). The authors hypothesize that individuals fearing rejection might avoid social environments where smoking is common to minimize the risk of being "outed" or judged.

Conclusion and Limitations

While the study provides critical insights into the intersection of sexual orientation and health in China, it has limitations. The convenience sample was highly educated and urban, which may not represent the experiences of rural or less-educated populations. Additionally, the cross-sectional nature of the data prevents definitive causal conclusions.

The findings suggest that public health interventions and tobacco cessation programs in China must be tailored to the unique stressors faced by sexual minority men. Addressing the mental health needs of this population requires a nuanced understanding of how cultural expectations and minority stress—particularly the pervasive impact of rejection anticipation—interact to influence health behaviors.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Background:</bold> Literature in the West suggested that bisexual men have a higher smoking rate compared to<bold> </bold>gay men. Data on patterns of smoking among gay and bisexual men are limited in Eastern Asian countries like China. This study examined the cigarette smoking prevalence for gay versus bisexual men in China and their unique minority stress - smoking pathways. <bold>Methods: </bold>Between September 2017 and November 2018, we surveyed a convenience sample of 538 gay men and 138 bisexual men recruited from local sexual minority organizations in four metropolitan cities in China (i.e., Beijing, Wuhan, Nanchang, and Changsha). Measures included sexual orientation, sociodemographics, theory-based minority stressors, depressive symptoms, and past 30-day cigarette smoking. Two-group (gay men vs. bisexual men) structural equation modeling (SEM) was used to test possible distinct mechanisms between theory-based stressors, depressive symptoms, and cigarette smoking among gay men and bisexual men, respectively. <bold>Results: </bold>The mean age of participants was 26.51 (SD = 8.41) years old and 76.3% of them had at least a college degree. Bisexual men reported a higher rate of cigarette smoking compared to gay men (39.9% vs. 27.3%). Two-group SEM indicated that the pathways for cigarette smoking were not different between gay and bisexual men. Higher rejection anticipation was associated with greater depressive symptoms (standardized β = 0.32, p &lt; .001), and depressive symptoms were not associated with cigarette smoking. <bold>Conclusions: </bold>Minority stress, specifically rejection anticipation, may be critical considerations in addressing depressive symptoms, but not smoking, among both gay and bisexual men in China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2020minority,
  author = {Jingjing Li and Danqin Huang and Michael Windle and Cam Escoffery and Wei Wang and Xiaoyan Li and Kevin Tao and Regine Haardörfer and Shiyue Li and Carla J. Berg and Hong Yan},
  title = {{Minority stress, depression, and cigarette smoking among Chinese gay versus bisexual men: A two-group structural equation model analyses}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.2.17811/v3},
}
Figure