Abstract
A 49-year-old woman with a history of breast cancer presented with left leg pain. Initial MRI suggested a lumbar disc herniation (HNP) compressing the S1 nerve root. Despite conservative treatment, the pain persisted, leading to surgical decompression. Intraoperatively, the S1 nerve root was found to be compressed by a soft, gray tumor located ventrally, rather than the expected disc material. The tumor was resected, and the nerve root was adequately decompressed. Notably, the surrounding bone was intact with no signs of metastasis on CT. Pathological examination confirmed the tumor as adenocarcinoma, consistent with the patient's primary breast cancer. This case underscores the importance of considering metastatic lesions in the differential diagnosis of radiculopathy in patients with a history of malignancy.
Introduction: The Great Mimic
In clinical practice, "sciatica" or leg pain is most frequently attributed to a lumbar disc herniation (HNP). When a patient has a history of cancer, clinicians typically look for vertebral bone metastases as the cause of neurological symptoms. However, this case highlights a critical diagnostic pitfall: a soft-tissue metastasis that settles in the epidural space and invades the disc itself without destroying the surrounding bone.
Because the resulting mass looks identical to a herniated disc on a standard MRI and lacks the hallmark bone destruction on CT, it can lead to a misdiagnosis. This report serves to alert the medical community that radiculopathy in a cancer patient should be treated with high suspicion, even if imaging suggests a routine mechanical issue.
Methods
The diagnostic and therapeutic workflow for this patient included:
- Neurological Examination: Assessing motor strength and sensory deficits.
- Advanced Imaging: Utilizing Computed Tomography (CT) to check bone integrity and T2-weighted Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) to visualize nerve compression.
- Interventional Diagnostics: A nerve root block was performed to confirm the source of the pain.
- Surgical Intervention: Decompression surgery was performed to remove the compressing mass.
- Histopathology & Immunohistochemistry: The resected tissue was analyzed using Hematoxylin and Eosin (HE) staining and specific markers (CD68, HMB45, Cytokeratin, and Vimentin) to confirm the tumor's origin.
Results and Intraoperative Findings
The patient’s MRI showed a classic L5-S1 disc protrusion, and CT scans showed no evidence of bone erosion. This atypical spread—where the tumor occupies the epidural space while leaving the vertebral bone intact—suggests an unusual pathway, possibly through the venous system or direct invasion of the disc space.
The diagnosis was only corrected during surgery. Instead of the expected pearly-white nucleus pulposus (disc material), surgeons discovered a "dark red," "severely tight" tissue adhered to the nerve root.
Pathological confirmation identified the tissue as adenocarcinoma, matching the patient’s original breast cancer. Post-surgery, the patient’s motor strength improved from grade 4/5 to 5/5, and her pain was initially relieved. However, the systemic disease was aggressive; her pain returned shortly after, and she passed away three months later due to widespread metastases.
Discussion and Conclusion
This case is exceptionally rare; only ten cases of solid cancer metastases to the spinal nerve root ganglia have been reported. The primary limitation highlighted here is the diagnostic failure of standard imaging: MRI was unable to distinguish between a benign disc and a malignant tumor in this context.
Future work might investigate whether specialized imaging sequences, such as PET-MRI or diffusion-weighted imaging, could better differentiate these masses. Ultimately, while surgery is effective for immediate symptom relief, the presence of such a metastasis indicates advanced systemic disease requiring urgent, multimodal oncological care. Clinicians must maintain a high index of suspicion for metastatic lesions in any patient with a history of malignancy presenting with new-onset radiculopathy.
Summary updated