Abstract
Enchondroma is a benign cartilaginous bone tumor that rarely occurs in the axial skeleton. This report details a rare case of an enchondroma located in the cervical spine of a 24-year-old woman. The patient presented with neck pain, neurological deficits, and hand muscle wasting, initially mimicking more common spinal pathologies. Following a C4 right hemilaminectomy and facetectomy, histological examination confirmed the diagnosis. Six months post-surgery, the patient showed significant symptomatic improvement with no recurrence, highlighting the efficacy of aggressive surgical resection for these rare lesions.
Introduction
Enchondromas are benign tumors typically found within the medullary cavity of long tubular bones, most commonly in the hands and feet. Their occurrence in the spine is exceptionally rare, with only 11 cases involving the cervical spine reported in the literature between 1960 and 2010. Due to their rarity in the axial skeleton, these tumors often present diagnostic challenges, frequently being misidentified as more common or aggressive bone tumors such as aneurysmal bone cysts or giant cell tumors.
Case Presentation
A 24-year-old female patient presented with a history of persistent neck pain, restricted neck movement, and numbness along the right scapula. Physical examination revealed weakness and wasting of the right hand, suggesting nerve root compression.
Radiologic examinations, including Computed Tomography (CT) and Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), identified a 15 x 23 mm lobulated, round tumor in the right lamina of the C4 vertebra. The lesion showed extracortical extension into the C4-5 foramen. While the imaging provided clear evidence of a mass, the specific characteristics—such as T2-weighted hyperintensity—were non-specific, leading to presumptive diagnoses of more common spinal bone tumors.
Surgical Management and Histopathology
To address the neural compression and obtain a definitive diagnosis, the surgical team performed a C4 right hemilaminectomy and partial facetectomy. The goal was near-complete removal of the tumor mass while maintaining spinal stability.
Post-operative histological examination served as the gold standard for diagnosis. Microscopic analysis revealed classic features of an enchondroma: cartilaginous tissue composed of chondrocytes with bland-looking nuclei. These cells were situated within sharp-edged lacunar spaces and separated by fibro-osseous septa.
Discussion
Diagnostic Mimicry and Progression
The primary challenge in managing spinal enchondromas is their ability to mimic other lesions. Because they grow slowly, they often remain asymptomatic for years. Symptoms typically manifest only when the tumor achieves "extracortical extension," breaking through the bone to compress adjacent neural structures. This case underscores the necessity of including enchondroma in the differential diagnosis of spinal tumors, even when radiologic features suggest more common pathologies.
Pathogenesis and Treatment
The authors discuss the metaplasia hypothesis, suggesting these tumors may arise from the transformation of connective tissue or from displaced remnants of embryonic cartilage. Regardless of origin, the consensus for treatment remains aggressive surgical resection. While benign, incomplete removal can lead to recurrence. However, when entirely excised, the recurrence rate is reported to be less than 10%.
Conclusion
At the 6-month follow-up, the patient reported total resolution of neck pain and significant improvement in neurological deficits. A follow-up MRI at three years confirmed no evidence of tumor recurrence. This case demonstrates that while cervical enchondromas are rare and diagnostically complex, aggressive surgical intervention can lead to excellent long-term clinical outcomes. Future work involving molecular profiling may eventually help clinicians distinguish these benign lesions from low-grade malignant chondrosarcomas without the need for extensive invasive sampling.
Summary updated