Lifetime prediction for power converters

Hui HuangWarwick 2012

University of Warwick Logo

Abstract

High reliability in power generation systems is essential for the commercial viability of renewable energy. Power inverters, critical components in these systems, are often the most prone to failure, particularly in offshore wind applications. This research presents a novel methodology for predicting inverter lifetime based on real-world mission profiles. By integrating device-level physics with large-scale system simulations, the proposed model enables optimized design and predictive maintenance. Key findings include the identification of die-attach solder fatigue as the dominant failure mode and the demonstration that nonlinear damage accumulation models provide significantly more accurate lifetime estimates than traditional linear methods.

Introduction

The transition to renewable energy sources like wind and solar is hindered by the reliability of power electronics. Inverters, which manage the conversion and delivery of power to the grid, are notorious "weak links." In harsh environments such as offshore wind farms, a single failure can lead to substantial downtime and prohibitive maintenance costs.

University of Warwick Institutional Crest

This research, conducted at the University of Warwick, addresses the need for an invaluable technique to predict inverter lifetime. Existing models typically fall into two categories: high-accuracy device-level models that are computationally prohibitive for long-term simulation, and fast system-level models that lack physical depth. This work bridges that gap, linking the physics of power devices to large-scale system simulations within a reasonable timeframe.

Methodology

The research employs a multi-layered approach to create a comprehensive lifetime prediction tool.

Physics-Based Electrothermal Simulation

To achieve both accuracy and speed, the study utilizes the Ambipolar Diffusion Equation (ADE) to model the internal carrier distribution of Insulated-Gate Bipolar Transistors (IGBTs) and diodes. These physics-based models are used to generate Look-Up Tables (LUTs). By using LUTs, the system-level simulator (PLECS) can determine power losses instantly, reducing the simulation time for a single switching event to approximately two seconds.

Experimental Power Cycling

A custom-designed experimental rig was used to gather lifetime data from SEMIKRON SKM50GB123D IGBT modules. By testing eleven modules simultaneously, the research identified die-attach solder fatigue as the primary failure mechanism. The study observed that as solder cracks propagate, thermal resistance ($R_{th}$) increases, creating a positive feedback loop of rising junction temperatures and accelerated degradation.

Damage Accumulation Modeling

A significant contribution of this work is the critique of the widely accepted Miner’s Rule, which assumes linear damage accumulation. Under the irregular thermal stresses of real-world "mission profiles" (e.g., varying wind speeds), damage does not accumulate at a constant rate. The research promotes a nonlinear accumulation method that accounts for the acceleration of damage as the component nears its end-of-life, particularly during the crack propagation phase.

Results and Discussion

The application of this model to a wind power case study revealed a stark contrast between traditional and proposed methods. While the linear Miner’s Rule predicted a lifetime of 39.5 years, the nonlinear model provided a more conservative and realistic estimate of 23.1 years.

The study also validated specific degradation metrics:

  • Thermal Resistance ($R_{th}$): A 20% increase serves as a reliable indicator of solder fatigue.
  • On-state Voltage ($V_{ce}$): A 5% increase effectively signals bond wire damage.

Conclusion

The developed framework offers a powerful tool for both converter design and on-line lifetime estimation. By accounting for the physical realities of material fatigue and the nonlinear nature of damage, engineers can better optimize systems for minimal maintenance and maximum power generation. Future work will focus on extending this framework to Silicon Carbide (SiC) devices and further investigating the impact of mean operating temperatures on component aging.

Reference: Huang, H. (2012). Lifetime prediction for power converters. PhD Thesis, University of Warwick, School of Engineering.

Summary updated

Abstract

Renewable energy is developing rapidly and gaining more and more commercial
\nviability. High reliability of the generation system is essential to maximize the
\noutput power. The power inverter is an important unit in this system and is
\nbelieved to be one of the most unreliable parts. In the case of wind power
\ngeneration, especially in off-shore wind, when the system reliability requirement
\nis high, a technique to predict the inverter lifetime is invaluable as it would help
\nthe inverter designer optimize his design for minimal maintenance.
\nPrevious researchers studying inverter lifetime prediction, focus either at device
\nlevel such as device fatigue damage models, or at system level which require
\nexperimental data for their selected device. This work presents a new method
\nto estimate the inverter lifetime from a given mission profile within a reasonable
\nsimulation time. Such model can be used as a converter design tool or an on-line
\nlifetime estimation tool after being configured to a real converter system.
\nThe key contribution of this work is to link the physics of the power devices to a
\nlarge scale system simulation within a reasonable framework of time. With this
\ntechnique, the system down time can be reduced and therefore more power can
\nbe generated. Also, the failure damage to the system is avoided which reduces
\nthe maintenance cost. A power cycling test is designed to gather the lifetime
\ndata of a selected IGBT module. Die-attach solder fatigue is found out to be the
\ndominant failure mode of this IGBT module. The accuracy of widely accepted
\nMiner’s rule, which accumulates damage linearly, is discussed and a nonlinear
\naccumulation method is promoted to predict the lifetime of power inverters.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2012lifetime,
  author = {Hui Huang},
  title = {{Lifetime prediction for power converters}},
  booktitle = {Warwick},
  year = {2012},
}
Figure