Reliability analysis and reliable operation of three-level ANPC inverter

Xiaolin Zheng, Xiao‐Xiao Huang, Peiyu Chen, Zhiqiang Chong, Zhongchen YuanFrontiers in Energy Research 2023 · DOI

Abstract

The three-level active neutral-point-clamped (3L-ANPC) inverters have been widely used in medium-voltage high-power electrical drives. The purpose of this paper is to achieve the reliable operation for 3L-ANPC inverters by reliability analysis and optimal switching and control strategies, while the performance of output waveforms of inverters is maintained. This paper starts by analyzing the power loss and the reliability of power semiconductor devices. On this basis, a mathematical model is derived for online condition monitoring of semiconductor devices. Then, the modulation strategies of the passive commutation mode and the active commutation mode are designed for the 3L-ANPC inverter, and the power loss distributions are analyzed among different semiconductor devices accordingly. Finally, three optimized strategies are designed to improve the reliability of the 3L-ANPC inverter under different load conditions based on different commutation modes and the developed reliability model. Both the simulation using MATLAB Simulink as well as PLECS have been conducted to verify the validity of analysis and control for improving reliability of 3L-ANPC inverters in this paper.

Introduction: The Challenge of Power Loss Distribution

In high-power applications such as wind energy and industrial motor drives, multilevel inverters are essential for handling high voltages with efficiency. However, the classic Neutral-Point-Clamped (NPC) topology suffers from a significant drawback: unequal power loss distribution. In standard NPC designs, specific transistors experience higher thermal stress than others, leading to localized hotspots and premature component failure.

Comparison of (A) Diode-clamping 3L-NPC and (B) 3L-ANPC inverter topologies.

To address this, the Active NPC (ANPC) variant introduces additional switches (T5 and T6) to provide more controllable paths for current. This flexibility allows for better heat balancing, provided that the switching strategies are intelligently managed. This paper proposes a framework to optimize these strategies in real-time to maximize system longevity.

Methodology: Reliability-Oriented Control

The researchers developed a multi-step framework for reliability-oriented operation based on three core pillars:

  1. Online Condition Monitoring: A mathematical model calculates conduction and switching losses in real-time, feeding into a Cauer thermal network to estimate the junction temperature ($T_j$) of every IGBT and diode.
  2. Lifetime Modeling: Using the LESIT study and Miner’s rule, the system calculates accumulated physical damage. For irregular or random loads, the Rainflow Algorithm is employed to extract thermal cycles from temperature data, allowing the controller to account for the damage caused by thermal swings ($\Delta T$).
  3. Commutation Mode Design: The study defines two distinct current paths: Passive Commutation (relying on diodes) and Active Commutation (utilizing the extra IGBTs).

Based on these models, three optimized strategies were designed to minimize the variance of power loss (for constant loads) or the variance of consumed lifetime (for periodic/random loads), ensuring all components age at a uniform rate.

Key Results and Lifetime Extension

The proposed strategies were validated using high-fidelity simulations in MATLAB/Simulink and PLECS, calibrated with manufacturer data for the Infineon FF100R12RT4 IGBT module. The results demonstrated significant improvements in reliability:

  • Thermal Balancing: For constant loads, the variance in junction temperature was reduced from 5.97 to 2.92 $^\circ C^2$, indicating a much more even heat distribution across the inverter leg.
  • Lifetime Extension: In periodic load simulations, the estimated lifetime of the most stressed device (T2) increased from 20.6 years using standard passive commutation to 40.1 years using the optimized strategy—effectively doubling the component's life.
  • Waveform Quality: Crucially, these reliability gains were achieved without degrading the total harmonic distortion (THD) of the output voltage or significantly increasing total system losses.

Conclusion

By shifting the control philosophy from simple efficiency to "variance minimization" of thermal stress, this research provides a robust path for extending the life of 3L-ANPC inverters. While the implementation adds software and sensing complexity, the potential to nearly double the operational life of critical power electronics makes it a compelling strategy for high-availability industrial and renewable energy systems. Future work will focus on experimental validation through hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) testing and accounting for the initial fatigue state of retrofitted devices.

Summary updated

Abstract

The three-level active neutral-point-clamped (3L-ANPC) inverters have been widely used in medium-voltage high-power electrical drives. The purpose of this paper is to achieve the reliable operation for 3L-ANPC inverters by reliability analysis and optimal switching and control strategies, while the performance of output waveforms of inverters is maintained. This paper starts by analyzing the power loss and the reliability of power semiconductor devices. On this basis, a mathematical model is derived for online condition monitoring of semiconductor devices. Then, the modulation strategies of the passive commutation mode and the active commutation mode are designed for the 3L-ANPC inverter, and the power loss distributions are analyzed among different semiconductor devices accordingly. Finally, three optimized strategies are designed to improve the reliability of the 3L-ANPC inverter under different load conditions based on different commutation modes and the developed reliability model. Both the simulation using MATLAB Simulink as well as PLECS have been conducted to verify the validity of analysis and control for improving reliability of 3L-ANPC inverters in this paper.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zheng2023reliability,
  author = {Xiaolin Zheng and Xiao‐Xiao Huang and Peiyu Chen and Zhiqiang Chong and Zhongchen Yuan},
  title = {{Reliability analysis and reliable operation of three-level ANPC inverter}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2022.1124523},
}
Figure