Benchmark Study of Transient Stability during Power-Hardware-in-the-Loop and Fault-Ride-Through capabilities of PV inverters

Carina Lehmal, Ziqian Zhang, Robert SchürhuberarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Standard certification for PV inverters often relies on ideal voltage source testing, which neglects the complex interactions between inverters and the electrical grid. This study utilizes Power-Hardware-in-the-Loop (PHIL) simulation to evaluate the Fault-Ride-Through (FRT) capabilities of commercial 10kW inverters. Results indicate a significant "testing gap," where inverters passing standard tests exhibit instability under realistic grid conditions due to feedback loops.

Introduction

As global energy systems transition toward renewable sources, the stability of the electrical grid increasingly depends on the control logic of photovoltaic (PV) inverters. During grid faults, such as short circuits, inverters are required to perform Fault-Ride-Through (FRT), maintaining connectivity and providing reactive power support. However, current industry standards typically evaluate these capabilities using an "ideal voltage source" setup. This simplified approach ignores grid impedance and the resulting feedback loops where inverter current injection modifies terminal voltage.

Figure 1: Standard inverter testing using an ideal voltage source, which lacks the realistic feedback loops found in actual grid environments.

Methodology

The researchers benchmarked four commercial 10kW PV inverters (A, B, C, and D) using two methodologies:

  1. Ideal Voltage Source Testing: The conventional setup where the inverter is connected to a source with zero internal resistance and no feedback.
  2. Power-Hardware-in-the-Loop (PHIL): A sophisticated simulation where a physical inverter interacts with a real-time simulator running a CIGRE benchmark grid model. This setup captures the dynamic "feedback effect" between the hardware and the simulated environment.
Figure 6: The PHIL simulation environment, highlighting the bidirectional feedback effect between the physical inverter and the real-time grid model.

Tests were conducted according to Austrian TOR Type A guidelines, specifically focusing on Low-Voltage Ride-Through (LVRT) scenarios with voltage dips lasting approximately 120ms.

Key Results and Discussion

The study revealed a stark disparity in performance between the two testing environments. While the aggregate pass rate for the inverters was 77.7% under ideal conditions, it dropped to 36.7% in the PHIL setup.

  • Software-Driven Stability: Despite similar hardware specifications, the inverters performed differently, suggesting that transient stability is primarily a function of internal control loops and filter designs.
  • The Deception of Steady-State Metrics: Inverter D, which boasted the lowest Total Harmonic Distortion (THD) of 2.55% in standard tests, proved to be the least reliable in PHIL tests with a mere 11.6% pass rate. This indicates that low-noise operation during steady state does not guarantee resilience during transient events.
  • Performance Leaders: Inverter A demonstrated robust engineering, achieving a 97.7% pass rate across all test cases and showing near-instantaneous recovery after faults. In contrast, Inverter B required over 500ms to stabilize.

Conclusion

The findings suggest that current certification standards are overly optimistic and may mask systemic risks to grid security. The "feedback effect" inherent in real-world grids can trigger instabilities that are invisible in simplified laboratory tests. The authors recommend updating grid standards to incorporate more realistic testing methodologies, such as PHIL, to ensure the long-term stability of renewable-heavy power systems.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{lehmal2025benchmark,
  author = {Carina Lehmal and Ziqian Zhang and Robert Schürhuber},
  title = {{Benchmark Study of Transient Stability during Power-Hardware-in-the-Loop and Fault-Ride-Through capabilities of PV inverters}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2501.13503},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.13503},
}
Figure