TL;DR
This paper introduces "graph counterfactual fairness," a new fairness notion for graph-based machine learning that accounts for biases stemming from both a node's own sensitive attributes and those of its neighbors, as well as their influence on graph structure and features. They propose GEAR, a framework that learns fair node representations by augmenting data with counterfactuals where sensitive attributes are perturbed, and then minimizing representation discrepancies.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In machine learning, especially when dealing with sensitive attributes like race or gender, ensuring fairness in model predictions is crucial. While "counterfactual fairness" aims to achieve this by checking if predictions change when a sensitive attribute is hypothetically altered, existing methods for graph-based data have limitations. They often overlook two key issues: 1) a node's neighbors' sensitive attributes can indirectly influence its prediction, and 2) sensitive attributes can causally affect not just the prediction but also other node features and the graph's structure itself. This paper addresses these gaps by proposing a more comprehensive definition of fairness for graphs and a method to achieve it.
Methods
The core of the proposed solution is the GEAR framework, which consists of three main components:
- Subgraph Generation: To manage the complexity of large graphs, GEAR first extracts "ego-centric" subgraphs for each node. These subgraphs include the central node and its most influential neighbors, identified using importance scores (derived from personalized PageRank). This focuses the analysis on local context.
- Counterfactual Data Augmentation: This module generates counterfactual data by intervening on the sensitive attributes within the subgraphs. It uses a Graph Variational Auto-Encoder (GraphVAE) to learn latent embeddings and reconstruct subgraphs. Crucially, it employs an adversarial learning approach to disentangle sensitive attributes from other features and graph structure, aiming for embeddings that are invariant to sensitive attribute changes. Two types of counterfactuals are generated:
- Self-perturbation: The central node's sensitive attribute is flipped.
- Neighbor-perturbation: The sensitive attributes of neighboring nodes are randomly perturbed.
- Fair Representation Learning: Using Siamese networks, GEAR trains encoders to map original and counterfactual subgraphs into representation spaces. The objective is to minimize the discrepancy between the representations of a node derived from its original subgraph and its counterfactual counterparts. This is achieved by minimizing a combined loss function that includes prediction loss (for downstream tasks) and a fairness loss that enforces consistency across counterfactuals.
Datasets
The paper evaluates GEAR on:
- A synthetic dataset: This dataset is custom-generated to allow for precise control over causal relationships and data generation, enabling a thorough evaluation of the proposed fairness notion.
- Two real-world datasets:
- Bail: This dataset represents defendants released on bail, with edges indicating similarities in criminal records and demographics. The sensitive attribute is race.
- Credit: This dataset contains information on credit card default payments, with edges representing similarities in spending and payment patterns. The sensitive attribute is age.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Beyond Individual Attributes: The most significant insight is the recognition that fairness in graph data cannot solely focus on an individual node's sensitive attribute. The influence of neighbors' sensitive attributes and their cascading effects on graph structure and features are critical and must be addressed.
- Causal Modeling for Graphs: The paper extends counterfactual fairness from i.i.d. data to graphs by explicitly considering causal pathways. This requires a more nuanced approach to generating counterfactuals that accounts for the interconnected nature of graph data.
- Disentanglement via Adversarial Learning: The use of adversarial learning within the counterfactual data augmentation module is key to disentangling sensitive attributes from other influential factors, leading to more robust and fair representations.
- Subgraph-centric Approach: Focusing on local subgraphs rather than the entire graph is a practical and effective strategy for managing computational complexity while retaining relevant contextual information for fairness.
Key Results
- Superior Fairness: GEAR significantly outperforms state-of-the-art fair graph representation learning methods on graph counterfactual fairness metrics (SCF and R²), demonstrating its effectiveness in mitigating biases from neighbors and causal effects on features/structure.
- Comparable Prediction Performance: Despite its strong focus on fairness, GEAR achieves prediction performance (Accuracy, F1-score, AUROC) comparable to or better than existing fair methods and competitive with non-fair methods.
- Ablation Studies: Removing components like self-perturbation, neighbor-perturbation, or the entire counterfactual augmentation module leads to a degradation in fairness, validating the contribution of each part of the GEAR framework.
- Parameter Sensitivity: The study shows that increasing the weight of fairness constraints (λ and λs) improves fairness, albeit with a slight trade-off in prediction performance. Larger subgraph sizes and more neighbor perturbations also generally lead to fairer results.
Limitations and Future Work
- Causal Model Assumption: The paper acknowledges that true causal models for real-world graphs are often unknown. While they propose a method to fit observed data and generate counterfactuals, the accuracy of this fitting process can impact the fairness guarantees. Future work could explore more robust methods for inferring or incorporating causal knowledge.
- Computational Cost: While subgraph generation helps, generating multiple counterfactuals can still be computationally intensive. Further optimizations for scalability might be necessary.
- Single Sensitive Attribute: The current formulation primarily focuses on a single, binary sensitive attribute. Extending the framework to handle multiple sensitive attributes or continuous attributes would be a valuable next step.
- Generalization of Fairness Metrics: The paper introduces SCF for graph counterfactual fairness. Further research into developing and validating a broader suite of graph-specific fairness metrics would be beneficial.
Summary updated