Large Scale Variational Inference and Experimental Design for Sparse Generalized Linear Models

Matthias W. Seeger, Hannes Nickisch

TL;DR

This paper introduces novel, scalable algorithms for approximate Bayesian inference in sparse generalized linear models, enabling efficient estimation of uncertainties and optimal experimental design for large-scale problems like image reconstruction. They achieve this by developing new convexity results for variational inference and leveraging numerical linear algebra techniques like the Lanczos algorithm.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern statistical and machine learning applications often deal with datasets where the number of variables far exceeds the number of observations (high-dimensional data). Sparsity, the idea that only a few variables are truly important, is a key principle for handling such data. While sparse point estimation (finding the single best estimate) has seen significant progress, higher-order problems like estimating uncertainty (e.g., covariance) or optimizing data acquisition (experimental design) for sparse models have lagged, especially for large-scale applications. Existing variational Bayesian inference methods, while powerful for capturing uncertainty, often struggle with scalability and lack theoretical guarantees of convexity. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing scalable, theoretically grounded methods for approximate Bayesian inference and experimental design in sparse generalized linear models.

Methods

The authors propose a variational inference framework that approximates the true posterior distribution with a simpler, tractable one. Specifically, they use a Gaussian-form lower bound relaxation for the intractable terms in the posterior. A key contribution is proving that this variational problem is convex under certain conditions related to the concavity of the log-posterior.

To handle large-scale problems, they develop two classes of double-loop algorithms. These algorithms iteratively optimize a surrogate objective function by alternating between:

  1. Outer loop updates: Bounding complex coupling terms (like the determinant of a large matrix) using Fenchel duality.
  2. Inner loop updates: Minimizing a simpler, decoupled objective, often solved efficiently using an iteratively reweighted least squares (IRLS) algorithm.

A crucial component for scalability is the efficient computation of Gaussian marginal variances. For this, they leverage the Lanczos algorithm, a powerful numerical technique for approximating spectral properties of large matrices, which reduces the problem to matrix-vector multiplications.

For experimental design, they use a Bayesian sequential design approach, scoring candidate measurements based on how much they reduce posterior uncertainty. This scoring also relies on the Lanczos algorithm for efficient computation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the theoretical framework and algorithmic development, with applications to general "natural images" and "medical imaging" as motivating examples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Convexity of Variational Inference: The paper provides a significant theoretical result by establishing conditions under which variational inference for sparse generalized linear models becomes a convex optimization problem. This is crucial for guaranteeing convergence to a global optimum.
  • Scalability via Lanczos Algorithm: The use of the Lanczos algorithm is a key enabler for handling large-scale problems. It efficiently computes necessary Gaussian variances and spectral information, reducing the computational burden from intractable matrix inversions to matrix-vector multiplications.
  • Experimental Design for Uncertainty: The paper highlights that for effective experimental design, especially for complex signals like natural images, it's not just about finding a sparse point estimate but about capturing the full posterior uncertainty. Their Bayesian approach directly addresses this.
  • Limitations of Exact Sparsity: The authors argue that relying on exact sparsity (forcing many coefficients to be exactly zero) can be detrimental for uncertainty estimation and experimental design, as it discards valuable information about posterior correlations. Their methods aim for faithful uncertainty representation without this extreme sparsification.

Key Results

  • Scalable Algorithms: The proposed double-loop algorithms are demonstrated to be orders of magnitude faster than previous methods for large-scale problems, reducing computations to standard primitives like least squares and variance estimation.
  • Convexity Guarantees: The paper provides theoretical guarantees for the convexity of the variational inference problem under specific conditions, simplifying optimization.
  • Improved Experimental Designs: Designs optimized by their Bayesian framework are shown to outperform those based on compressed sensing theory for natural images.
  • General Applicability: The framework is shown to be applicable to various sparse models, including those with Laplace or Student's t priors, and generalized linear models like logistic regression.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Lanczos Algorithm Accuracy: While the Lanczos algorithm provides scalability, its accuracy in estimating Gaussian variances can be limited for certain types of matrices (e.g., those with linear spectral decay). This can affect the theoretical guarantees of global convergence in practice, though empirical results suggest it often performs well.
  • Stopping Rules: Establishing reliable stopping rules for the outer loop iterations, especially when exact gradients are hard to compute, remains an open problem.
  • Model Mismatch: The authors acknowledge that real-world data generation processes may not perfectly match the assumed models. Their data-dependent design approach aims to mitigate this, but further research on robustness to model mismatch is suggested.
  • Hyperparameter Optimization: While the framework can be used for hyperparameter optimization, this problem is generally non-convex and requires further investigation.
  • New Benchmark Datasets: The paper does not introduce new datasets but uses general examples like natural images and medical imaging data. The development of specific benchmarks for evaluating experimental design in these domains could be a future direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sparsity is a fundamental concept of modern statistics, and often the only general principle available at the moment to address novel learning applications with many more variables than observations. While much progress has been made recently in the theoretical understanding and algorithmics of sparse point estimation, higher-order problems such as covariance estimation or optimal data acquisition are seldomly addressed for sparsity-favouring models, and there are virtually no algorithms for large scale applications of these. We provide novel approximate Bayesian inference algorithms for sparse generalized linear models, that can be used with hundred thousands of variables, and run orders of magnitude faster than previous algorithms in domains where either apply. By analyzing our methods and establishing some novel convexity results, we settle a long-standing open question about variational Bayesian inference for continuous variable models: the Gaussian lower bound relaxation, which has been used previously for a range of models, is proved to be a convex optimization problem, if and only if the posterior mode is found by convex programming. Our algorithms reduce to the same computational primitives than commonly used sparse estimation methods do, but require Gaussian marginal variance estimation as well. We show how the Lanczos algorithm from numerical mathematics can be employed to compute the latter. We are interested in Bayesian experimental design here (which is mainly driven by efficient approximate inference), a powerful framework for optimizing measurement architectures of complex signals, such as natural images. Designs optimized by our Bayesian framework strongly outperform choices advocated by compressed sensing theory, and with our novel algorithms, we can scale it up to full-size images. Immediate applications of our method lie in digital photography and medical imaging. We have applied our framework to problems of magnetic resonance imaging design and reconstruction, and part of this work appeared at a conference (Seeger et al., 2008). The present paper describes our methods in much greater generality, and most of the theory is novel. Experiments and evaluations will be given in a later paper.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{seeger2009large,
  author = {Matthias W. Seeger and Hannes Nickisch},
  title = {{Large Scale Variational Inference and Experimental Design for Sparse Generalized Linear Models}},
  booktitle = {Sampling-based Optimization in the Presence of Uncertainty},
  year = {2009},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=R_mdBFhj9K},
}
Figure