Abstract
This study examines the impact of the COVID-19 crisis on impression management (IM) practices among French listed companies. As the pandemic significantly disrupted business activities, we investigate whether managers altered their presentation of non-GAAP financial results through "obfuscation" strategies. Analyzing annual earnings releases from SBF 120 companies between 2018 and 2020, we observe a general decrease in impression management during the crisis, particularly in the hardest-hit sectors. However, this decline is less pronounced for firms that underperformed relative to their industry or experienced the sharpest drops in performance. Our findings suggest that when poor results might be attributed to internal failures rather than just the external shock, managers remain concerned with their corporate image and maintain higher levels of spin.
Introduction: The "Corporate Spin" Dilemma
During the unprecedented global shock of the COVID-19 pandemic, corporate communication faced a unique challenge. Managers of French listed firms had to navigate a landscape where bad news was not only expected but often seen as inevitable. This research explores how these firms adjusted their "corporate spin"—technically known as Impression Management (IM)—in their financial reporting during this period.
Impression management involves the strategic selection and presentation of information to influence how stakeholders perceive company performance. This is most visible in the reporting of Non-GAAP Earnings (NGEs)—alternative performance metrics that fall outside standard accounting frameworks like IFRS. Because these metrics are less regulated, they offer significant leeway for managers to "frame" the narrative.
Research Objectives: Transparency vs. Obfuscation
The study addresses a fundamental question in financial communication: Does a global crisis incentivize managers to increase "spin" to protect their reputation, or does it encourage transparency because investors already anticipate poor results?
Unlike the 2008 financial crisis, which originated within the financial sector, COVID-19 was an "exogenous" shock. This provided a rare opportunity to observe communication strategies when managers could not be directly blamed for the economic downturn. The researchers hypothesized that while the "stigma" of bad news might be lower, the pressure to maintain an "illusion of control" might still drive certain firms toward obfuscation.
Methodology: A Deep Dive into Corporate Language
To capture the nuances of financial rhetoric, the authors employed a rigorous manual coding process rather than relying solely on automated text analysis.
The Sample
The study focused on 84 firms from the French SBF 120 index, covering the period from 2018 to 2020. This yielded 252 firm-year observations, specifically focusing on the 180 instances where companies utilized Non-GAAP metrics in their press releases.
Scoring Impression Management
Using the framework established by Brennan et al. (2009), the researchers calculated an IM score based on three primary dimensions:
- Tone: The balance of positive versus negative keywords.
- Emphasis: The placement of information (e.g., headlines), frequency of repetition, and use of intensifiers (e.g., "exceptionally strong").
- Performance Comparisons: How current results were benchmarked against historical data to highlight successes or downplay failures.
Key Findings: The "Windfall" of Crisis and the Underperformer's Persistence
The research revealed a complex shift in how French companies communicated during 2020.
1. A General Shift Toward Transparency
On average, the level of impression management significantly decreased during the pandemic. The total IM score dropped from a pre-crisis mean of 0.049 to -0.011 in 2020. Interestingly, communication regarding Non-GAAP earnings actually displayed a slight "negativity bias" during the crisis year. This suggests a "windfall effect": since the market already expected disaster, managers felt less pressure to sugarcoat the results and prioritized long-term credibility over short-term image management.
2. The Sectoral Divide
The decrease in spin was most pronounced in sectors hit hardest by the pandemic, such as industrials and basic materials. In these industries, the external cause of poor performance was so obvious that attempting to "spin" the numbers would likely be dismissed by investors as "cheap talk."
3. The Underperformer's Dilemma
The most critical finding is that this trend toward transparency was not universal. Firms that underperformed relative to their sector peers (intra-sectoral underperformance) or those in the bottom decile of performance change maintained significantly higher levels of IM.
When a company's results are worse than its direct competitors, the "it's just the virus" excuse loses its potency. In these cases, managers appear to use impression management to mask potential internal failures and maintain an "illusion of control," signaling to investors that they are still capable of managing the crisis.
4. The Rise of Attributional Statements
The study also noted a surge in "attributional statements"—explanations of why results occurred. The percentage of press releases featuring these statements jumped from 16.4% in 2018 to 39.6% in 2020. Managers frequently attributed negative outcomes to both the external pandemic and internal strategic shifts, attempting to balance honesty with a narrative of proactive management.
Conclusion and Implications
This research highlights that while major crises can lead to a general increase in financial transparency, the "quality" of corporate communication remains highly dependent on relative performance. For investors and auditors, the takeaway is clear: pay closest attention to the "spin" of firms that are lagging behind their peers, as these are the entities most likely to use impression management to obscure internal weaknesses.
Summary updated