This paper presents a fascinating piece of geological detective work, resolving an identity crisis for a rock formation in Manitoba that has significant implications for how we hunt for diamonds.
TL;DR
Researchers have reclassified the only known "kimberlite" in Manitoba’s Wekusko Lake as a beforsite (a type of magnesiocarbonatite). While the rock contains "indicator minerals" nearly identical to those found in diamond-rich kimberlites, its chemical and isotopic signature proves it originated from a different volcanic process, suggesting that diamond explorers need to be more cautious when interpreting mineral trails.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In the world of mineral exploration, finding a kimberlite is often the "holy grail" because these rare volcanic rocks are the primary transport mechanism for diamonds from the Earth's mantle to the surface. For decades, the Wekusko Lake area in Manitoba was home to the province's only provisionally identified kimberlite.
Early reports in the 1980s and 90s identified "indicator minerals"—specifically high-magnesium garnets and spinels—that are classic signatures of diamond-bearing pipes. However, the site lacked rigorous petrographic and geochemical data. The authors sought to determine if this rock was truly a kimberlite or a "look-alike" that might mislead exploration efforts in the Trans-Hudson Orogen region.
Methods
The authors employed a multi-disciplinary "forensic" approach to analyze drill core samples (EPV-12A-94 and GBO-16):
- Petrography: Using polarized microscopy and back-scattered-electron (BSE) imaging to examine the rock's texture and mineral structure.
- Mineral Chemistry: Electron microprobe analysis (EMPA) and Laser-Ablation ICP-MS were used to determine the major and trace element compositions of specific minerals like phlogopite, spinel, and ilmenite.
- Whole-Rock Geochemistry: Borate-fusion ICP-MS to look at the overall chemical makeup of the rock.
- Isotope Analysis: Stable-isotope ($\delta^{13}C$, $\delta^{18}O$) and radio-isotope ($^{87}Sr/^{86}Sr$) analysis to determine the source of the magma (mantle vs. crust).
Datasets
The study relied on:
- Primary samples from the GBO-16 and EPV-12A-94 drill holes.
- Comparison datasets of mineral compositions from "bona fide" kimberlites and diamond inclusions worldwide (citing Kong et al., 1999 and Wyatt et al., 2004).
- Trace-element datasets for micas from both carbonatites and kimberlites for comparative classification.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Identity Crisis: While the rock looks like a kimberlite because it contains high-Cr and high-Mg spinel and ilmenite, the "groundmass" (the matrix holding the crystals) is 70–85% carbonate. This makes it a carbonatite, specifically a beforsite.
- The Phlogopite "Tell": While major elements in micas can be ambiguous, trace elements (like Niobium and Manganese) in the Wekusko Lake phlogopite clearly matched carbonatite signatures rather than kimberlitic ones.
- A Geological First: This is the first documented case of a carbonatite containing extremely Chromium- and Magnesium-rich macrocrysts that are chemically indistinguishable from diamond-indicator minerals.
- Shared Roots: The similarity of the spinel and ilmenite to kimberlitic versions suggests that while the rock type is different, the parental magmas likely originated from a similar mantle source as kimberlites.
Key Results
- Mineralogy: The rock is dominated by dolomite with high levels of Strontium (Sr), Barium (Ba), and Rare Earth Elements (REE), which are hallmarks of carbonatites.
- Isotopic Signature: Carbon isotope values ($\delta^{13}C$ of -7.6 to -5.3‰) confirm a mantle origin, but heavy oxygen isotopes suggest the rock interacted with low-temperature fluids after forming.
- Geochemical Ratios: The rock shows high Nb/Ta and Zr/Hf ratios, which differ significantly from the average hypabyssal kimberlite.
- Classification: The authors officially reclassify the Wekusko Lake "kimberlite" as a fine-grained magnesiocarbonatite (beforsite).
Limitations and Future Work
- The Missing Garnets: Although previous 1993 reports claimed the presence of G10 and G9 garnets (the most reliable diamond indicators), the authors of this study did not observe any garnets in their samples. This discrepancy remains an open question—did the earlier study misidentify minerals, or are garnets simply very rare and localized in this formation?
- Geodynamic Context: The authors note that a detailed radio-isotope study is currently underway to better understand the exact timing of the emplacement and the geodynamic regime of the mantle source.
Summary updated