Crystalline rocks of the Strawberry Lake area, Front Range, Colorado

Edward Young1991 · DOI

Abstract

This report presents a detailed petrographic and geochemical study of the Proterozoic basement rocks in the Strawberry Lake area, located between the Continental Divide and Granby, Colorado. The region is primarily underlain by biotite gneiss and two major plutonic bodies: the Boulder Creek Granodiorite (Routt Plutonic Suite) and the Silver Plume Granite (Berthoud Plutonic Suite). By utilizing a novel geochemical classification system based on felsic-mafic (F) and silica-saturation (S) ratios, this research challenges traditional magmatic models, suggesting instead that these plutons may have formed through metamorphic-metasomatic "granitization."

Introduction

The "granite controversy"—the debate over whether large granitic bodies result from cooling magma (magmatism) or the chemical transformation of pre-existing rocks (granitization)—remains a foundational topic in geology. This USGS Bulletin re-examines the Proterozoic units of the Strawberry Lake quadrangle to provide new insights into this debate. The study area contains a complex assembly of 1,700-million-year-old Boulder Creek Granodiorite and 1,500-million-year-old Silver Plume Granite, both hosted within an older biotite-gneiss complex.

Methodology: The F-S Method

The core innovation of this study is the application of the "F-S method," which uses two calculated ratios to distinguish between magmatic and metamorphic origins:

  • F (Felsic-Mafic Ratio): $(SiO_2 + Na_2O + K_2O) / (FeO + Fe_2O_3 + MgO + CaO)$
  • S (Silica-Saturation Ratio): $SiO_2 / (Al_2O_3 + Na_2O + K_2O + MgO + CaO + Fe_2O_3 + FeO)$

By comparing these ratios against established trends, the author identifies whether a rock's chemistry aligns with magmatic differentiation or metamorphic-metasomatic processes. Additionally, the study utilizes magnesium content in biotite as a proxy for thermal history and calculates a "coefficient of trace element accumulation" ($R$) to evaluate enrichment factors against average crustal abundances.

Key Geological Findings

The Case for Granitization

The F-S plots for the major plutons in the Strawberry Lake area consistently fall into fields associated with metamorphic-metasomatic processes rather than magmatic ones. The author suggests that these "plutons" are actually transformed biotite gneiss that reached a state of high-grade metamorphism without necessarily becoming a fully liquid magma. This is supported by petrographic evidence of "inherited" zircons—crystals featuring older cores with younger overgrowths—indicating they survived the transformation of the precursor gneiss.

Enclave Geochemistry and Trace Elements

The study highlights significant trace element enrichment, particularly in uranium (U) and thorium (Th), confirming the Front Range's status as a distinct radioactive province.

  • Boulder Creek Granodiorite: In this specific area, it is more mafic and less radioactive than the regional average.
  • Silver Plume Granite: Conversely, this unit is more felsic and exhibits higher radioactivity.
  • Granitic Enclaves: These fragments trapped within the gneiss and plutons are surprisingly enriched in Thorium and Light Rare Earth Elements (LREE), suggesting selective chemical migration during the transformation of the bedrock.
  • Lamprophyre Paradox: The biotite lamprophyres (minette-vogesites) exhibit a unique chemistry, being enriched in both felsic elements (K, U, Th, Pb) and mafic elements (Mg, P, Ti, Cr). The author interprets these as products of end-stage ultrametamorphism.

Mineralogical Discovery

The paper documents the first reported occurrence of meionite (a calcium-rich scapolite) in Colorado, discovered within a Tertiary andesite porphyry dike in the study area.

Conclusion and Future Work

The application of the F-S method suggests that the major Proterozoic plutons of the Front Range may have a more complex, non-magmatic origin than previously assumed. While the author acknowledges that these findings might be controversial, the geochemical evidence points toward a metamorphic-metasomatic model for crustal evolution in this region. Future research using these ratios in other complex crystalline terrains is recommended to test the broader applicability of the granitization model.

Summary updated

Abstract

This report is a petrographic and geochemical study of the bedrock and a petrologic discussion based on felsic-mafic and silica-saturation ratios of the Strawberry Lake area. This volume is published as chapters A and B. These chapters are not available separatelyThe Strawberry lake area lies between the Continental Divide and Granby, Colorado, just north of Tabernash. It is underlain by Proterozoic rocks composed of biotite gneiss and two plutons-Boulder Creek Granodiorite of the Routt Plutonic Suite and Silver Plume Granite of the Berthoud Plutonic Suite. Relict enclaves of biotite gneiss are not uncommon in the Boulder Creek Granodiorite, in the Silver Plume Granite, and in the granitic enclaves in the biotite gneiss. Granitic and mafic enclaves in the Boulder Creek Granodiorite, granitic enclaves in the Silver Plume Granite and in the biotite gneiss, and a Tertiary andesite porphyry dike complete the rock types.
BibTeX
@misc{young1991crystalline,
  author = {Edward Young},
  title = {{Crystalline rocks of the Strawberry Lake area, Front Range, Colorado}},
  year = {1991},
  doi = {10.3133/b1937},
}
Figure