Chromite and platinum group elements mineralization in the Santa Elena Ultramafic Nappe (Costa Rica): geodynamic implications

Federica Zaccarini, Giorgio Garuti, Joaquín A. Proenza, Lolita Campos, Oskar Thalhammer, Thomas Aiglsperger, John LewisGeologica 2011 · DOI

Abstract

Chromitites associated with strongly altered peridotite from six distinct localities in the Santa Elena ultramafic nappe (Costa Rica) have been investigated for the first time. Santa Elena chromitites commonly display a compositional variation from extremely chromiferous (Cr/(Cr+Al)=0.81) to intermediate and aluminous (Cr/(Cr+Al)=0.54). This composition varies along a continuous trend, corresponding to calculated parental liquids which may have been derived from the differentiation of a single batch of boninitic magma with Cr-rich and (Al, Ti)-poor initial composition. Fractional precipitation of chromite probably occurred during differentiation of the boninitic melt and progressive metasomatic reaction with mantle peridotite. The distribution of platinum group elements (PGE) displays the high (Os+Ir+Ru)/(Rh+Pt+Pd) ratio typical of ophiolitic chromitites and, consistently, the platinum group minerals (PGM) encountered are mainly Ru-Os-Ir sulfides and arsenides. Textural relations of most of the platinum group elements suggest crystallization at magmatic temperatures, possibly under relatively high sulfur fugacity as indicated by the apparent lack of primary Os-Ir-Ru alloys. The chemical and mineralogical characteristics of chromitites from the Santa Elena ultramafic nappe have a strong affinity to podiform chromitites in the mantle section of supra-subduction-zone ophiolites. Calculated parental melts of the chromitites are consistent with the differentiation of arc-related magmas, and do not support the oceanic spreading center geodynamic setting previously proposed by some authors.

Introduction: The Santa Elena Geological Puzzle

The Santa Elena Peninsula in Costa Rica has long been a subject of geodynamic debate. Researchers have historically disagreed on its origin: was it formed at an oceanic spreading center influenced by a mantle plume (akin to the Galapagos), or was it part of a "supra-subduction zone" (SSZ) island arc?

Regional and local geological context of the Santa Elena Peninsula, showing the study area within the Caribbean Plate and the specific geological units of the nappe.

Identifying the tectonic setting is complicated by intense tropical weathering and hydrothermal alteration, which have transformed primary minerals into secondary phases like serpentine and talc. However, chromian spinel (chromite) is remarkably resistant to these processes. By analyzing the chemistry of chromite cores and associated Platinum Group Elements (PGE), this study provides a "black box" record of the original magmatic conditions.

Methodology

The research team investigated six localities (Jag-1 through Jag-6) within the Santa Elena nappe. The analytical workflow included:

  • Electron Microprobe (WDS): Over 500 analyses mapped the major oxide compositions of unaltered chromite cores.
  • ICP-MS: Eleven massive chromitite samples were analyzed for bulk PGE and Gold concentrations using Nickel-sulfide preconcentration.
  • Mineralogical Scanning: Polished sections were examined via reflected light and electron microscopy to identify tiny (<10µm) Platinum Group Minerals (PGM).
  • Parental Melt Modeling: Empirical equations were used to back-calculate the chemistry of the parental magma in equilibrium with the chromite.

Results and Geodynamic Implications

The study introduces a critical primary dataset for the region, benchmarking Santa Elena against global ophiolite databases.

Satellite view of the study area showing sample locations Jag1 through Jag6 and their respective Chromium numbers (Cr#).

The chromite displayed a wide variation in Cr# (Cr/(Cr+Al)) ranging from 0.81 to 0.54. This continuous trend is characteristic of podiform chromitites found in the mantle sections of SSZ ophiolites. The high-Cr, low-Ti signature points directly to boninitic magmas—high-magnesium, low-titanium melts almost exclusively associated with subduction zones. The data suggests these variations resulted from the differentiation of a single batch of magma as it migrated through the mantle.

PGE Fingerprinting

The PGE distribution showed high ratios of "IPGE" (Os, Ir, Ru) relative to "PPGE" (Rh, Pt, Pd). This chondrite-normalized "slope" is a classic signature of ophiolitic mantle chromitites. The dominant PGMs identified were Ru-Os-Ir sulfides (laurite-erlichmanite) and arsenides (irarsite), indicating crystallization at high magmatic temperatures under relatively high sulfur fugacity, likely due to sulfur assimilation from the surrounding mantle.

Conclusion

The chemical and mineralogical evidence from the Santa Elena chromitites "unequivocally fit" the profile of supra-subduction zone peridotites. These findings strongly contradict previous models suggesting an oceanic spreading center origin. While this study focused on "Area A" of the nappe, future work in the more remote "Area B" and detailed structural mapping will further refine our understanding of this ancient subduction-related plumbing system.

Summary updated

Abstract

Chromitites associated with strongly altered peridotite from six distinct localities in the Santa Elena ultramafic nappe (Costa Rica) have been investigated for the first time. Santa Elena chromitites commonly display a compositional variation from extremely chromiferous (Cr/(Cr+Al)=0.81) to intermediate and aluminous (Cr/(Cr+Al)=0.54). This composition varies along a continuous trend, corresponding to calculated parental liquids which may have been derived from the differentiation of a single batch of boninitic magma with Cr-rich and (Al, Ti)-poor initial composition. Fractional precipitation of chromite probably occurred during differentiation of the boninitic melt and progressive metasomatic reaction with mantle peridotite. The distribution of platinum group elements (PGE) displays the high (Os+Ir+Ru)/(Rh+Pt+Pd) ratio typical of ophiolitic chromitites and, consistently, the platinum group minerals (PGM) encountered are mainly Ru-Os-Ir sulfides and arsenides. Textural relations of most of the platinum group elements suggest crystallization at magmatic temperatures, possibly under relatively high sulfur fugacity as indicated by the apparent lack of primary Os-Ir-Ru alloys. The chemical and mineralogical characteristics of chromitites from the Santa Elena ultramafic nappe have a strong affinity to podiform chromitites in the mantle section of supra-subduction-zone ophiolites. Calculated parental melts of the chromitites are consistent with the differentiation of arc-related magmas, and do not support the oceanic spreading center geodynamic setting previously proposed by some authors
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zaccarini2011chromite,
  author = {Federica Zaccarini and Giorgio Garuti and Joaquín A. Proenza and Lolita Campos and Oskar Thalhammer and Thomas Aiglsperger and John Lewis},
  title = {{Chromite and platinum group elements mineralization in the Santa Elena Ultramafic Nappe (Costa Rica): geodynamic implications}},
  booktitle = {Geologica},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1344/105.000001696},
}
Figure