Joint representation of molecular networks from multiple species improves gene classification

Christopher A. Mancuso, Kayla A. Johnson, Renming Liu, Arjun Krishnan

TL;DR

GenePlexusZoo is a new framework that merges molecular networks from six different species into a single, reusable feature space for machine learning. By leveraging evolutionary conservation and many-to-many orthology, it significantly boosts the accuracy of gene classification and enables the discovery of disease-related genes across species—even when direct genetic matches are missing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Predicting the function of a gene or its role in a disease (gene classification) is a cornerstone of modern biomedicine. Most researchers use network-based machine learning, which looks at how genes interact within a single species (like humans). However, these networks are often "noisy" (containing errors) and "incomplete" (missing many interactions).

While we know that biological processes are often conserved across evolution, existing methods to "borrow" data from other species have major flaws. They usually only handle two species at a time, rely on overly simplistic one-to-one gene mappings (ignoring the complex reality where one human gene might relate to three mouse genes), or create representations that can't be easily reused for new tasks.

Methods

The authors introduce GenePlexusZoo, a framework designed to create a joint representation of molecular networks.

  1. Multi-Species Integration: They combined networks from six species: human, mouse, zebrafish, fruit fly, nematode worm, and baker’s yeast.
  2. Handling Orthology: Instead of simple 1-to-1 mappings, they used the eggNOG database to incorporate "many-to-many" orthology links, connecting genes across species based on shared evolutionary ancestry.
  3. Feature Engineering: They compared two main ways to represent these networks:
  4. AdjMat (Adjacency Matrix): A raw representation of who-interacts-with-whom.
  5. N2V (node2vec): A low-dimensional embedding technique that uses random walks to "summarize" a gene's position and neighborhood in the network.
  6. The "Secret Sauce": To ensure the model actually learned cross-species relationships, they used degree-weighted random walks. This prevents the algorithm from getting "stuck" in the dense network of a single species and encourages it to traverse the orthology links to other species.
  7. Study-Bias Evaluation: To mimic real-world discovery, they used a "study-bias holdout" method—training the model on well-characterized genes and testing its ability to predict the roles of less-studied genes.

Datasets

  • Molecular Networks: BioGRID (physical protein-protein interactions) and IMP (integrated functional relationships).
  • Gene Sets for Training/Testing: Gene Ontology (biological processes), Monarch (phenotypes), and DisGeNet (human diseases).
  • Orthology Mapping: Primarily eggNOG, with WORMHOLE used for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Evolutionary "Free Lunch": Even if your goal is only to predict human gene functions, including data from yeast or flies makes your model more accurate. The extra information helps "fill in the gaps" of the noisy human network.
  • Embeddings are the Bridge: In raw adjacency matrices, genes from different species look very "disjoint" (separated). Node embeddings (N2V) successfully bring functionally similar genes from different species closer together in a shared mathematical space.
  • Functional "Phenologs": The model can identify relevant biological processes in a model species even when the specific genes involved have no direct orthologs in humans. It recognizes the functional neighborhood rather than just matching gene names.
  • Reusability: Unlike many deep learning models that must be retrained for every new disease, GenePlexusZoo creates a "reusable feature space" that can be applied to any new gene set on-the-fly.

Key Results

  • Within-Species Boost: Using multi-species features improved human gene classification across almost all tasks compared to using human-only data.
  • Cross-Species Transfer: Node embeddings (N2V) significantly outperformed raw adjacency matrices in transferring knowledge (e.g., training on human data to predict mouse gene functions).
  • Case Study (Bardet-Biedl Syndrome): When trained on human BBS genes, the model successfully identified ciliary processes in all five model species. Remarkably, it identified 13 top processes where the model-species genes had no known orthologs to the human BBS genes, demonstrating its ability to find novel biological connections.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: Creating these joint representations is resource-intensive. The authors noted that training some models required up to 500 GB of RAM and over 24 hours of computation.
  • Scalability: As more species and more complex data (like single-cell networks) are added, the "Zoo" will grow. The authors suggest that future iterations might use Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) with neighbor sampling to handle even larger datasets more efficiently.
  • Phenotype Complexity: While function prediction saw huge gains, phenotype prediction remains a harder nut to crack, likely due to the inherent complexity of how genes manifest as physical traits across vastly different organisms.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Network-based machine learning (ML) has the potential for predicting novel genes associated with nearly any health and disease context. However, this approach often uses network information from only the single species under consideration even though networks for most species are noisy and incomplete. While some recent methods have begun addressing this shortcoming by using networks from more than one species, they lack one or more key desirable properties: handling networks from multiple species, incorporating many-to-many orthology information, or generating a network representation that is reusable across different types of and newly-defined prediction tasks. Here, we present GenePlexusZoo, a framework that casts molecular networks from multiple species into a single reusable feature space for network-based ML. We demonstrate that this multi-species network representation improves both gene classification within a single species and knowledge-transfer across species, even in cases where the inter-species correspondence is undetectable based on shared orthologous genes. Thus, GenePlexusZoo enables effectively leveraging the high evolutionary molecular, functional, and phenotypic conservation across species to discover novel genes associated with diverse biological contexts.
BibTeX
@article{mancuso2024joint,
  author = {Christopher A. Mancuso and Kayla A. Johnson and Renming Liu and Arjun Krishnan},
  title = {{Joint representation of molecular networks from multiple species improves gene classification}},
  journal = {PLOS Computational Biology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pcbi.1011773},
}
Figure