Job Analysis of Real Estate Brokerage Business based on the AHP Method

Mee-Suk Lee, Jong-Jin KimThe Journal of the Korea Contents Association 2008 · DOI

Abstract

세계화 개방화에 직면한 국내 부동산중개업은 현재의 단순한 거래의 매개자 역할에서 벗어나 고객의 재산가치 향상과 투자요구에 부응하는 전문직 분야로 발전해야 할 필요가 있고, 이를 위해서는 직무분석을 통한 부동산중개업의 효율적 운영에 관한 연구가 그 기초가 된다. 본 연구는 AHP 의사결정기법을 적용하여 국내 부동산중개업의 직무모형을 구축함으로써 부동산중개업의 직무특성을 분석하고, 효율적 운영을 위한 시사점을 도출하려고 하였다. 본 연구의 결과는 다음과 같이 요약될 수 있다. 중개업자들은 효율적인 부동산중개업을 위해서는 소유권 등의 권리관계와 같은 전통적으로 중요한 중개직무와 함께 부동산시장에 영향을 주는 부동산정책, 국내경제의 흐름 및 변화에 대한 이해를 중요하게 인식하고 있다. 그러나 공인중개사시험 준비와 그 이후의 교육을 통해서 이에 대한 지식과 정보를 접할 기회가 거의 없는 실정이다. 따라서 중개업자가 부동산투자 및 상담의 전문직으로 발전하기 위해서는 부동산거래와 관련된 법률적 지식뿐 아니라 부동산시장 경제에 관한 체계적인 교육이 필요하다고 하겠다.

TL;DR

This research utilizes the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) to map the professional responsibilities of real estate brokers in South Korea. The findings indicate that while transaction execution remains a top priority, there is an urgent need for enhanced education in macroeconomics and government policy to transition brokers from simple mediators to professional asset consultants.

The Evolving Role of the Real Estate Broker

In South Korea, real estate brokerage has traditionally been viewed as a simple mediation service—connecting buyers and sellers. However, as the market matures and globalization increases, clients are demanding more sophisticated investment advice and property value enhancement.

There is a significant gap between the current "simple mediator" model and the "professional consultant" model required for the future. Standard licensing exams and continuing education for brokers focus almost exclusively on legal regulations, leaving a void in market analysis and economic forecasting. This paper defines a formal "Job Model" to identify which tasks are most critical for effective business management in this evolving landscape.

Methodology: The AHP Approach

The researchers employed the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), a structured technique for organizing and analyzing complex decisions. The process involved two main phases:

  1. Hierarchy Construction: A panel of nine experts developed a four-level job hierarchy, starting from the ultimate goal of effective management down to 29 specific detailed tasks.
  2. Expert Survey: 44 experienced brokers were surveyed using pairwise comparisons to determine relative importance. After consistency checks, 31 valid responses were analyzed to ensure logical reliability (Consistency Ratio < 0.1).
Hierarchical structure of the real estate brokerage job model used for AHP analysis.

Key Results and Importance Weights

The AHP analysis produced specific importance weights for the main job categories and detailed tasks. "Closing and Contracting" emerged as the most critical category, followed closely by "Property Analysis" and "Market Understanding."

Relative importance weights for main categories, sub-categories, and detailed job tasks.

At the most granular level, the top five most important tasks identified were:

  1. Ownership/Rights Analysis (0.081)
  2. Building Trust (0.078)
  3. Real Estate Policy Analysis (0.069)
  4. Surrounding Physical Environment (0.063)
  5. Investment Logic & Persuasion (0.056)

Strategic Insights

  • Policy Sensitivity: Brokers ranked "Understanding Real Estate Policy" as a top-tier task. This reflects the high sensitivity of the Korean market to government interventions like taxes and price caps.
  • Trust as a Core Competency: Within the "Closing/Contracting" category, "Building Trust" (0.423 sub-weight) was deemed significantly more important than "Adjusting Commission Fees" (0.093). Professional reputation is viewed as the primary tool for closing deals.
  • The Marketing Gap: Marketing was ranked the lowest among the five main categories (0.106). Korean brokers still rely heavily on passive foot traffic or office location rather than active, modern digital marketing strategies.
  • Educational Mismatch: There is a clear mismatch between what brokers find important for business success (market trends, macroeconomics) and the current legal-heavy educational curriculum.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The study highlights that for brokers to evolve into professional consultants, they require systematic education in real estate market economics alongside traditional legal training. While the current findings provide a robust qualitative framework, future research should aim for quantitative analysis, linking these job performance factors directly to business outcomes like revenue and customer satisfaction.

Summary updated

Abstract

세계화 개방화에 직면한 국내 부동산중개업은 현재의 단순한 거래의 매개자 역할에서 벗어나 고객의 재산가치 향상과 투자요구에 부응하는 전문직 분야로 발전해야 할 필요가 있고, 이를 위해서는 직무분석을 통한 부동산중개업의 효율적 운영에 관한 연구가 그 기초가 된다. 본 연구는 AHP 의사결정기법을 적용하여 국내 부동산중개업의 직무모형을 구축함으로써 부동산중개업의 직무특성을 분석하고, 효율적 운영을 위한 시사점을 도출하려고 하였다. 본 연구의 결과는 다음과 같이 요약될 수 있다. 중개업자들은 효율적인 부동산중개업을 위해서는 소유권 등의 권리관계와 같은 전통적으로 중요한 중개직무와 함께 부동산시장에 영향을 주는 부동산정책, 국내경제의 흐름 및 변화에 대한 이해를 중요하게 인식하고 있다. 그러나 공인중개사시험 준비와 그 이후의 교육을 통해서 이에 대한 지식과 정보를 접할 기회가 거의 없는 실정이다. 따라서 중개업자가 부동산투자 및 상담의 전문직으로 발전하기 위해서는 부동산거래와 관련된 법률적 지식뿐 아니라 부동산시장 경제에 관한 체계적인 교육이 필요하다고 하겠다. The purpose of this study is to suggest the way of effective management of real estate brokerage business by establishing the Job Model in real estate brokerage business in Korea. The AHP method, designed for professionals in a field, is used to establish the Job Model. The main result and implication of the study are as follows. The study found that real estate brokers recognize the importance of getting knowledge and information about the patterns and changes of the real estate market and economy, for the effective management of real estate brokerage business. The study therefore suggest that it is necessary to provide the brokers with education chance for the knowledge about the real estate market and economy.
BibTeX
@article{lee2008job,
  author = {Mee-Suk Lee and Jong-Jin Kim},
  title = {{Job Analysis of Real Estate Brokerage Business based on the AHP Method}},
  journal = {The Journal of the Korea Contents Association},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.5392/jkca.2008.8.12.246},
}
Figure