Multi-Criteria Decision-Making in SMEs Venture Capital Allocation: Analytic Hierarchy Process and Double Auction Approach

Muhamad Hariz Muhamad Adnan, Satria Abadi, Citrawati Jatiningrum, Hafizul Fahri Hanafi, Nurul Akhmal Mohd Zulkefli, Deshinta Arrova DewiJournal of Advanced Research in Applied Sciences and Engineering Technology 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are vital contributors to global economies and play a crucial role in reducing unemployment. However, their growth is often stifled by limited access to financing. To address this, this study proposes a hybrid multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) framework that combines the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) with a double auction method. By identifying and weighting key success factors, this approach facilitates an efficient and objective matching process between SMEs seeking venture capital and potential investors.

Introduction

SMEs represent approximately 90% of businesses and over 50% of employment worldwide. Despite their economic significance, "access to credit" remains a primary barrier to their expansion. Investors, including banks and venture capitalists, often lack standardized tools to evaluate the potential success of small businesses, leading to subjective or biased investment decisions. This paper introduces a systematic marketplace for venture capital that leverages mathematical weighting and simultaneous bidding to improve matching efficiency.

Methodology

The research follows a structured three-phase methodology designed to move from broad criteria identification to specific, weighted evaluation metrics.

The three-phase methodological framework for identifying and weighting SME success criteria.
  1. Criteria Identification: A comprehensive literature review identified 12 potential success factors for SMEs.
  2. Expert Filtering: Using purposive judgment sampling, a panel of 10 experts (including SME owners and credit analysts) surveyed the criteria. Only factors reaching a 75% consensus threshold were retained.
  3. Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP): The core analytical phase involved pairwise comparisons of the filtered criteria. Using "Expert Choice" software, the researchers determined the relative importance (weighting) of each factor while ensuring logical consistency in expert judgments.

The Hybrid Framework: AHP and Double Auction

The novelty of this approach lies in the integration of AHP scores into a Double Auction framework. In this model, both investors (buyers) and SMEs (sellers) submit bids and demands simultaneously. The platform acts as a "smart marketplace," matching participants based on the SME’s calculated AHP score, the required financing amount, and proposed investment terms such as interest rates or equity stakes.

Key Results and Analysis

The AHP analysis successfully prioritized 10 final criteria for SME evaluation. The model achieved an Inconsistency Ratio of 0.01, significantly below the 0.10 threshold, indicating high reliability in the expert rankings.

Radar chart visualizing the relative weights of the ten identified SME success criteria.

As illustrated in the radar chart, Income emerged as the most critical factor with a weight of 0.190. This suggests that for most investors, a proven revenue stream remains the primary indicator of eligibility and future success. Conversely, Location was ranked as the least important factor (0.041). The researchers attribute this to the rise of digital accessibility and technology, which has diminished the importance of physical coordinates in the modern business landscape.

Other significant factors included Experience (0.115) and Business Capital (0.110), highlighting the value placed on the entrepreneur's track record and existing financial foundation.

Discussion and Conclusion

By combining AHP—a ranking tool—with a Double Auction—a price-discovery tool—this framework creates a data-driven environment for capital allocation. While the current study relies on expert panels from Southeast Asia, the methodology provides a scalable blueprint for other emerging markets.

Future work should focus on the empirical deployment of the web-based matching platform and exploring how success criteria weights might shift across different industries (e.g., tech startups vs. traditional manufacturing) or varying economic climates. Ultimately, this hybrid approach offers a path toward removing human bias from venture capital distribution, ensuring that high-potential SMEs receive the support they need to thrive.

Summary updated

Abstract

Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) make a significant contribution to the economy and can reduce the unemployment rate. To improve their success, SMEs often need outside support, such as venture capital or other sources of financing. For governments, private investors, and banks to provide financial support, it is important to identify relevant criteria to evaluate the future success of SMEs. To evaluate SMEs and allocate venture capital effectively, this study proposes a multi-criteria decision-making technique that combines the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and the double auction method. The double auction approach is used to match SMEs with investors based on their AHP scores and funding needs. The AHP is used to assess the importance of various factors that influence SME success. This study aims to support an effective and informed decision-making process for the distribution of venture capital to SMEs by bringing these two methods together to promote their growth and success.
BibTeX
@article{adnan2024multi,
  author = {Muhamad Hariz Muhamad Adnan and Satria Abadi and Citrawati Jatiningrum and Hafizul Fahri Hanafi and Nurul Akhmal Mohd Zulkefli and Deshinta Arrova Dewi},
  title = {{Multi-Criteria Decision-Making in SMEs Venture Capital Allocation: Analytic Hierarchy Process and Double Auction Approach}},
  journal = {Journal of Advanced Research in Applied Sciences and Engineering Technology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.37934/araset.54.1.8090},
}
Figure