Comparative Analysis of Personal Trainers’ Job Roles in Latecomer Growth Cities Using DACUM (Developing A Curriculum): A Comparative Study of Zhengzhou and Seoul

Jun Yan, Jing Yu, K S Choi, Jeong‐Ju YooThe Asian Journal of Kinesiology 2025 · DOI

Abstract

OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to systematically analyze the job roles of personal trainers in Latecomer Growth Cities using the DACUM method, focusing on identifying core Duties and Tasks, and comparing CVR (Content Validity Ratio), convergence, and consensus between Zhengzhou and Seoul. METHODS: A structured DACUM-based job analysis was conducted, involving 130 personal trainers in Zhengzhou. Surveys assessed 65 Tasks across nine Duties. Quantitative metrics (CVR, convergence, consensus) were applied, with comparative analysis against Seoul’s data. RESULTS: High CVR and consensus were observed in core Duties (exercise program design, instruction, safety management) across both cities, indicating universal standards. Significant disparities emerged in extended roles (client communication, personal branding), with Zhengzhou showing lower procedural compliance and Seoul demonstrating superior system maturity. CONCLUSIONS: DACUM effectively highlights regional differences in job role perceptions. Personal trainers’ roles must expand beyond foundational skills to include communication and digital competencies.

Introduction

The global fitness industry is expanding rapidly, yet the professional standards for personal trainers vary significantly across different urban landscapes. In "latecomer growth cities"—rapidly urbanizing areas like Zhengzhou, China—the demand for fitness services often outstrips the development of formal professional systems. This creates a "gray area" of undefined qualifications and inconsistent service quality. This study addresses this gap by systematically breaking down the actual job roles of personal trainers in these emerging markets compared to a highly developed market like Seoul, South Korea.

Methodology

The researchers employed the Developing A Curriculum (DACUM) method, a highly structured, participatory approach to job analysis widely used in vocational training. The process involves identifying core duties and specific tasks through expert workshops and validating them through quantitative surveys.

The DACUM job analysis process flowchart used to define personal trainer roles.

Trainers were surveyed on two dimensions for each task: "Necessity" (5-point Likert scale) and "Execution" (Binary Yes/No). To ensure statistical rigor, three metrics were applied: the Content Validity Ratio (CVR), Convergence (Standard Deviation < 0.50), and Consensus (threshold ≥ 0.75).

Data and Participants

The primary dataset consisted of 130 personal trainers working in gyms and health centers in Zhengzhou, representing the latecomer growth city. The demographics showed a predominantly male workforce with varying levels of experience, as detailed in the table below.

Table 1: Demographic characteristics and experience levels of the study participants in Zhengzhou.

Key Results and Discussion

Universal Core Skills vs. Procedural Gaps

The study found that core fitness training skills—such as exercise program design, instruction, and safety management—are universal, showing high validity and consensus in both Zhengzhou and Seoul. However, a significant "procedural gap" was identified in Zhengzhou. Trainers there scored poorly on administrative tasks like using Physical Activity Readiness Questionnaires (PAR-Q) and obtaining informed consent. For instance, only 45.7% of Zhengzhou trainers reported executing informed consent, highlighting a major liability risk compared to the highly systematized Seoul market.

The Impact of Compensation on Collaboration

In Zhengzhou, tasks related to teamwork and cooperation showed negative validity scores (CVR of -0.500). This suggests that performance-based compensation structures in emerging markets may inadvertently pit trainers against each other, turning potential knowledge-sharing into a competitive disadvantage.

Digital and Marketing Challenges

Both cities struggled with formalizing "Personal Branding and Marketing" as a core competency. While Zhengzhou trainers are highly active on digital media to acquire clients, they lack systemic support. Conversely, Seoul relies on mature automated systems but may lag in human-to-human digital engagement.

Conclusion

DACUM analysis effectively highlights that as fitness markets evolve, the role of the personal trainer must expand beyond physical instruction to include legal compliance, digital workflow adoption, and communication. For latecomer growth cities, the priority should be standardizing operating procedures and legal protections. For mature markets like Seoul, the focus should shift toward integrating advanced technologies like AI and wearables into the trainer's professional repertoire.

Summary updated

Abstract

OBJECTIVES This study aimed to systematically analyze the job roles of personal trainers in Latecomer Growth Cities using the DACUM method, focusing on identifying core Duties and Tasks, and comparing CVR(Content Validity Ratio), convergence, and consensus between Zhengzhou and Seoul.METHODS A structured DACUM-based job analysis was conducted, involving 130 personal trainers in Zhengzhou. Surveys assessed 65 Tasks across nine Duties. Quantitative metrics (CVR, convergence, consensus) were applied, with comparativeanalysis against Seoul’s data.RESULTS High CVR and consensus were observed in core Duties (exercise program design, instruction, safety management) across both cities, indicating universal standards. Significant disparities emerged in extended roles (client communication, personal branding), with Zhengzhou showing lower procedural compliance (e.g., pre-assessment documentation) and Seoul demonstrating superior system maturity. Zhengzhou’s Tasks A-2 (PAR-Q use) and A-3 (informed consent) failed validation thresholds (CVR &lt;0.42), while Seoul maintained higher execution rates.CONCLUSIONS DACUM effectively highlights regional differences in job role perceptions. Personal trainers’ roles must expand beyond foundational skills to include communication and digital competencies. Tailored training programs and standardized protocols are recommended for Latecomer Growth Cities, while mature systems should prioritize role redefinition and continuous education.
BibTeX
@article{yan2025comparative,
  author = {Jun Yan and Jing Yu and K S Choi and Jeong‐Ju Yoo},
  title = {{Comparative Analysis of Personal Trainers’ Job Roles in Latecomer Growth Cities Using DACUM (Developing A Curriculum): A Comparative Study of Zhengzhou and Seoul}},
  journal = {The Asian Journal of Kinesiology},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.15758/ajk.2025.27.3.11},
}
Figure