Isospin Pomeranchuk effect in twisted bilayer graphene

Yu Saito, Fangyuan Yang, Jingyuan Ge, Xiaoxue Liu, Takashi Taniguchi, Kenji Watanabe, J. I. A. Li, Erez Berg, Andrea F. YoungNature 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

Magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene (MATBG) has emerged as a premier platform for exploring strongly correlated electronic states, including superconductivity and correlated insulators. A particularly intriguing feature of this system is the "cascade" of phase transitions observed at integer fillings of the moiré unit cell. Recent studies by Saito et al. and Rozen et al. have identified a surprising thermodynamic phenomenon within these transitions: an electronic version of the Pomeranchuk effect. In this effect, increasing the temperature or applying a magnetic field drives the system into a more disordered state characterized by higher entropy, revealing the role of "isospin" (spin and valley) degrees of freedom as local, fluctuating moments.

Experimental Methodology

To investigate these thermodynamic properties, researchers employed two distinct but complementary experimental approaches:

  1. Transport Measurements: Saito et al. utilized longitudinal resistivity ($\rho_{xx}$) and Hall effect measurements to map the phase diagram as a function of temperature ($T$), perpendicular magnetic field ($B_\perp$), and carrier density. Minima in conductivity and abrupt changes in carrier density served as indicators of phase boundaries.
  2. Electronic Compressibility: Rozen et al. focused on the inverse compressibility ($\partial \mu / \partial n$), measuring how the chemical potential ($\mu$) varies with electron density ($n$). This was achieved using both local scanning Single Electron Transistors (SET) and a global sensing technique involving a nearby monolayer graphene sheet.

By applying Maxwell relations to the compressibility data—specifically integrating $\partial \mu / \partial n$ over temperature and density—the researchers were able to indirectly determine the system's entropy ($s$) and magnetization ($m$).

Transport signatures of phase transitions in MATBG. (a-b) Longitudinal resistivity $\rho_{xx}$ as a function of perpendicular magnetic field $B_\perp$ and temperature $T$. (c-d) Temperature dependence of $\rho_{xx}$ and Hall density $\nu_H - \nu_0$ showing the emergence of new phases.

The Electronic Pomeranchuk Effect

The Pomeranchuk effect was originally discovered in Helium-3 ($^3$He), where the solid phase possesses higher entropy than the liquid phase due to the freedom of nuclear spins to fluctuate in the solid lattice. In MATBG, a similar mechanism appears to be at play. As the system is heated or subjected to a magnetic field, electrons tend to localize, and their isospin degrees of freedom (spin and valley) begin to fluctuate independently.

This transition is fundamentally driven by the system's tendency to maximize entropy. At filling factors near $\nu \approx -1$ (one hole per moiré cell), the system undergoes a transition into a state with significantly higher entropy. The sharp peaks observed in inverse compressibility measurements suggest that this is a first-order phase transition, where distinct phases coexist at the boundary.

Thermodynamic evidence for the Pomeranchuk effect. (c) Entropy $S - S_0$ per moiré unit cell as a function of filling factor $\nu_0$, showing a peak of approximately $1 k_B$ near integer filling. (d) The derivative of entropy with respect to magnetic field.

Key Findings and Quantitative Analysis

Both experimental groups reported remarkably consistent results:

  • Entropy Increase: The transition near $\nu = -1$ is accompanied by an entropy increase of approximately $\Delta s \approx 1 \times k_B$ per moiré unit cell. This large value is characteristic of a single free isospin degree of freedom per cell, supporting the picture of localized, fluctuating moments.
  • Phase Stability: A new metallic phase emerges at temperatures above ~5 K or magnetic fields exceeding ~6 T for fillings near $\nu = -1$.
  • Isospin Fluctuations: The magnitude of the entropy change implies that the high-temperature/high-field phase is not a simple insulator but a state where isospins behave like independent local moments.

Discussion and Outlook

While these findings establish the existence of an electronic Pomeranchuk effect in MATBG, several questions remain. The exact nature of the fluctuating isospins—whether they are purely spin, purely valley, or a complex mixture—has yet to be definitively determined. Furthermore, the relationship between this effect and the "cascades" seen at other integer fillings ($\nu = 1, 2, 3$) requires further exploration.

The discovery suggests that MATBG may host physics similar to "heavy fermion" systems or "double exchange" materials like manganites, where local magnetic moments coexist with itinerant electrons. This opens exciting possibilities for discovering new forms of colossal magnetoresistance or exotic magnetic orders in moiré superlattices.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{saito2021isospin,
  author = {Yu Saito and Fangyuan Yang and Jingyuan Ge and Xiaoxue Liu and Takashi Taniguchi and Kenji Watanabe and J. I. A. Li and Erez Berg and Andrea F. Young},
  title = {{Isospin Pomeranchuk effect in twisted bilayer graphene}},
  booktitle = {Nature},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41586-021-03409-2},
}
Figure