Entropic evidence for a Pomeranchuk effect in Magic Angle graphene

Shahal Ilani, Asaf Rozen, Jeong Min Park, Uri Zondiner, Yuan Cao, Daniel Rodan‐Legrain, Takashi Taniguchi, Kenji Watanabe, Yuval Oreg, Ady Stern, Erez Berg, Pablo Jarillo‐HerreroResearch 2020 · DOI

Abstract

In the 1950s, Pomeranchuk predicted that liquid $^3$He could solidify upon heating due to high excess spin entropy in the solid phase. This study demonstrates an analogous effect in magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene (MATBG). Using local and global electronic entropy measurements, researchers observed a dramatic increase in electronic entropy (~1 $k_B$ per unit cell) near a filling of one electron per moiré unit cell. This entropy is quenched by an in-plane magnetic field, indicating a magnetic origin. The resulting phase diagram reveals a temperature- and field-driven transition from a conventional metal to a correlated state with nearly-free magnetic moments, characterized by a significant separation of energy scales between itinerant and localized properties.

Introduction

The study of Magic Angle Twisted Bilayer Graphene (MATBG) has revolutionized condensed matter physics by providing a tunable platform to explore the boundary between itinerant and localized electronic states. While previous research focused on transport properties and spectroscopy, the fundamental thermodynamic nature of MATBG's correlated states remained elusive. This work addresses this gap by measuring electronic entropy—a key thermodynamic variable—to probe the "Dirac revivals" occurring at integer filling factors.

Experimental Methodology

The researchers employed two complementary techniques to map the thermodynamic landscape of MATBG:

  1. Local Scanning Probe: A scanning nanotube single-electron transistor (SET) measured local inverse compressibility ($d\mu/dn$). By applying Maxwell’s relations to the temperature dependence of the chemical potential ($d\mu/dT$), the team extracted the local electronic entropy.
  2. Global Sensing: A monolayer graphene sensor integrated into the device stack provided average chemical potential measurements across the entire MATBG flake.

These measurements were performed on hBN-encapsulated MATBG devices with a twist angle of approximately $1.13^\circ$.

Results and Discussion

The Electronic Pomeranchuk Effect

The central discovery is an electronic analogue of the Pomeranchuk effect. In $^3$He, heating drives a transition to a solid phase because the solid's disordered spins provide higher entropy. In MATBG, near a filling of $\nu = 1$, heating the system triggers a transition into a "correlated" state. This state is thermodynamically favored at higher temperatures because it possesses a large excess entropy of approximately $1 k_B$ per moiré unit cell.

Figure 1: Entropy measurements and phase diagram showing the Pomeranchuk-like transition in MATBG.

Magnetic Origin and Entropy Quenching

To determine the source of this high entropy, the researchers applied an in-plane magnetic field ($B_{||}$). They found that a field of 12T quenched the entropy difference by approximately $0.9 k_B$. This strong suppression confirms that the entropy originates from magnetic moments (spins) that are nearly free at zero field but become polarized and "locked" by the external magnetic field.

A Paradoxical "Hybrid" State

The phase observed above $\nu = 1$ exhibits a unique dichotomy. It behaves like a metal (no thermodynamic gap, high conductivity) and shows Dirac-like compressibility, suggesting itinerant electrons. Simultaneously, it displays properties typically associated with localized moments, such as the large, field-sensitive entropy. This suggests a hybrid nature that challenges standard models of moiré materials.

Separation of Energy Scales

A critical finding is the vast difference in energy scales governing these properties. The electronic "reset" (marked by a jump in compressibility) onsets at approximately 30 K. However, the bandwidth of magnetic excitations—the energy scale at which the spins begin to interact or order—is much lower, at 3 K or less. This separation suggests that the magnetic moments are "soft" and decoupled from the primary electronic structure changes.

Conclusion

The observation of a Pomeranchuk-like effect in MATBG provides a new lens through which to view moiré materials. The existence of a hybrid phase with nearly-free magnetic moments and itinerant electrons suggests that the physics of these systems is more complex than simple band-insulator or Mott-insulator models. Future research will explore whether similar entropic drivers exist at other integer fillings and how this magnetic entropy influences the emergence of superconductivity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract In the 1950's, Pomeranchuk predicted that, counterintuitively, liquid 3He may solidify upon heating, due to a high excess spin entropy in the solid phase. Here, using both local and global electronic entropy and compressibility measurements, we show that an analogous effect occurs in magic angle twisted bilayer graphene. Near a filling of one electron per moiré unit cell, we observe a dramatic increase in the electronic entropy to about 1k B per unit cell. This large excess entropy is quenched by an in-plane magnetic field, pointing to its magnetic origin. A sharp jump in the compressibility as a function of the electron density, associated with a reset of the Fermi level back to near the Dirac point, marks a clear boundary between two phases. We map this jump as a function of electron density, temperature, and magnetic field. This reveals a phase diagram that is consistent with a Pomeranchuk-like temperature- and field-driven transition from a rather conventional metal to a correlated state with nearly-free magnetic moments. The correlated state features an unusual dichotomy between properties associated with itinerant electrons, such as the absence of a thermodynamic gap, metallicity, and a Dirac-like compressibility, and properties usually associated with localized moments, such as a large entropy and its disappearance with magnetic field. Moreover, the energy scales characterizing these two sets of properties are vastly different: whereas the compressibility jump onsets at T∼30K, the bandwidth of magnetic excitations is ∼3K or smaller. This dichotomy and the large separation of energy scales have key implications for the physics of correlated states in twisted bilayer graphene.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ilani2020entropic,
  author = {Shahal Ilani and Asaf Rozen and Jeong Min Park and Uri Zondiner and Yuan Cao and Daniel Rodan‐Legrain and Takashi Taniguchi and Kenji Watanabe and Yuval Oreg and Ady Stern and Erez Berg and Pablo Jarillo‐Herrero},
  title = {{Entropic evidence for a Pomeranchuk effect in Magic Angle graphene}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-72511/v1},
}
Figure