Is the Envelope Beneficial to Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access?

Ziyi Xie, Wenqiang Yi, Xuanli Wu, Yuanwei Liu, Arumugam Nallanathan

Abstract

This paper proposes NOMA with Informative Envelope (NOMA-IE), a novel communication scheme that integrates Index Modulation (IM) into the Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) framework. By utilizing the signal's "envelope"—the specific pattern of active subcarriers—to carry additional information, NOMA-IE addresses the critical challenges of intra-cluster interference and the persistent Bit Error Rate (BER) floor. The proposed system achieves significantly higher spectral efficiency and lower error rates than traditional NOMA or OFDM systems in high-signal-to-noise environments.

Introduction

As wireless networks evolve toward 6G, the demand for spectral efficiency has led to the development of Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA). NOMA allows multiple users to share the same frequency and time resources by separating them in the power domain. However, NOMA faces two major hurdles: intra-cluster interference and the "Error Floor," where the BER stops improving even as transmit power increases. This plateau is typically caused by imperfect Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC) at the receiver. The authors of this paper investigate whether the flexibility of subcarrier activation in multi-carrier systems (like OFDM) can be leveraged to carry extra data while simultaneously mitigating these interference problems.

Methodology: The NOMA-IE Framework

The core innovation of NOMA-IE is the integration of Index Modulation into the NOMA transmitter and receiver architecture.

System architecture of NOMA-IE and subcarrier subblock structure.

As shown in the system architecture, the process begins with the Envelope Former. This module jointly decides which subcarriers are active for each user. Rather than only sending data via traditional phase and amplitude constellations, data bits are also mapped to the specific pattern of active subcarriers.

To maintain system stability and simplify detection, the authors implement a Subset Rule: the active subcarriers for the "Near User" (NU, with the stronger channel) must always be a subset of the active subcarriers for the "Far User" (FU). At the receiver, the Near User employs Envelope-Detected SIC (E-SIC), performing a joint search for both the subcarrier pattern and the data symbols.

The Informative Envelope and the Subset Rule

In a standard system, a subcarrier is binary (either "on" or "off"). NOMA-IE introduces a ternary nature where a subcarrier can have 0, 1, or 2 users active on it. This allows the envelope to carry more information than binary index modulation.

Mapping table for mixed index bits to subcarrier indices and subblocks.

The table above illustrates how mixed index bits are mapped to specific subcarrier indices ($I_F, I_N$) and their corresponding signal vectors ($x_F, x_N$). This design is specifically engineered to avoid the overlapping of combined signal constellations, which is a common failure point in traditional NOMA-IM schemes.

Key Insights and Results

A critical breakthrough in this paper is the introduction of a tunable Detection Coefficient ($\beta_e$). The authors proved that the standard detection method (where $\beta_e = 1$) is the primary cause of the error floor when power levels between users are relatively close. By optimizing $\beta_e$ based on power allocation, the decision boundaries are shifted to prevent signal point overlap, effectively eliminating the error floor.

Key performance results include:

  • Superior Efficiency: NOMA-IE provides higher spectral and energy efficiency than conventional OFDM and standard NOMA.
  • Significant BER Gains: In high Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) regimes (above 30 dB), NOMA-IE outperforms standard OFDM-NOMA by approximately 4 dB for the Far User and up to 8 dB for the Near User.
  • Elimination of the Error Floor: Simulations confirmed that with the correct envelope detection coefficient, the BER continues to drop as power increases, whereas previous methods plateaued.

Limitations and Future Work

Despite its advantages, NOMA-IE introduces higher computational complexity due to the joint search required for E-SIC, which may challenge low-power mobile devices. Furthermore, the current study assumes Perfect Channel State Information (CSI) and focuses on two-user clusters. Future research will explore low-complexity versions for massive user clusters and the impact of real-world channel estimation errors.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{xie2024is,
  author = {Ziyi Xie and Wenqiang Yi and Xuanli Wu and Yuanwei Liu and Arumugam Nallanathan},
  title = {{Is the Envelope Beneficial to Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access?}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Communications},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/tcomm.2023.3337269},
}
Figure