Is the Envelope Beneficial to Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access?

Ziyi Xie, Wenqiang Yi, Xuanli Wu, Yuanwei Liu, Arumugam Nallanathan

This academic paper, titled "Is the Envelope Beneficial to Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access?", explores a novel way to squeeze more data out of wireless signals by treating the signal's "envelope"—the pattern of active subcarriers—as a carrier of information itself.

TL;DR

The authors propose NOMA-IE (NOMA with Informative Envelope), a scheme that combines Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access with Index Modulation. By using the signal envelope to carry extra bits and introducing a specialized detection coefficient, they achieve significantly higher spectral efficiency and lower error rates than traditional NOMA or OFDM systems in high-signal-to-noise environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As we look toward 6G, wireless networks need to be more efficient. Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) is a leading candidate because it allows multiple users to share the same frequency at the same time, separated by power levels. However, NOMA faces two major hurdles:

  1. Intra-cluster interference: Users interfere with each other, creating "noise" that is hard to clean up.
  2. The Error Floor: In many NOMA setups, the Bit Error Rate (BER) stops improving even if you increase the transmit power. This is often caused by imperfect Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC) at the receiver.

The authors ask: Can we use the flexibility of how we activate subcarriers in a multi-carrier system (like OFDM) to carry extra data and simultaneously fix these interference problems?

Methods

The authors introduce NOMA-IE, which integrates Index Modulation (IM) into the NOMA framework.

  • Envelope Forming: At the transmitter, a module called the "Envelope Former" jointly decides which subcarriers are active for which user. Instead of just sending data via phase and amplitude (constellations), data bits are also mapped to the pattern of active subcarriers.
  • The Subset Rule: To keep things manageable, the active subcarriers for the "Near User" (the one with the stronger channel) are always a subset of the active subcarriers for the "Far User."
  • Envelope-Detected SIC (E-SIC): At the receiver, the Near User performs a joint search for both the subcarrier pattern and the data symbols.
  • The Detection Coefficient ($\beta_e$): This is the paper's secret sauce. The authors introduce a tunable coefficient used during detection to "shift" the decision boundaries. By optimizing $\beta_e$, they can prevent signal points from overlapping, which effectively eliminates the dreaded error floor.

Datasets

As a theoretical communication systems paper, it does not use external "big data" sets. Instead, the authors evaluate their model using:

  • Monte Carlo Simulations: Thousands of simulated transmissions over Rayleigh fading channels (a standard model for urban wireless environments).
  • Mathematical Derivations: They derive exact closed-form expressions for the Bit Error Rate (BER) for 2-subcarrier and 4-subcarrier blocks to prove their simulation results are grounded in theory.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ternary Information: In a standard system, a subcarrier is either "on" or "off." In NOMA-IE, a subcarrier can have 0, 1, or 2 users active on it. This "ternary" nature allows the envelope to carry more information than binary index modulation.
  • Avoiding the Overlap: Traditional NOMA-IM schemes often suffer because the combined signal constellations of two users overlap, making them indistinguishable. NOMA-IE’s "Envelope Former" design is specifically built to avoid this overlap.
  • The $\beta_e$ Breakthrough: The authors proved that the standard detection method (where $\beta_e = 1$) is actually the cause of the error floor when power levels between users are relatively close. By adjusting this value based on the power allocation, the error floor can be completely removed.

Key Results

  • Superior Efficiency: NOMA-IE provides higher spectral efficiency (more bits per second per Hz) and energy efficiency than conventional OFDM and standard NOMA.
  • Significant BER Gains: In high Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) regimes (above 30 dB), NOMA-IE outperforms standard OFDM-NOMA by approximately 4 dB for the Far User and up to 8 dB for the Near User.
  • Elimination of the Error Floor: Simulations confirmed that with the correct envelope detection coefficient, the BER continues to drop as power increases, whereas previous methods plateaued.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: The "joint search" required for E-SIC is more computationally demanding than simple subcarrier-by-subcarrier detection. This could be a hurdle for low-power mobile devices.
  • Perfect CSI Assumption: The study assumes the receiver has "Perfect Channel State Information" (it knows exactly what the channel is doing). In the real world, estimation errors could degrade performance.
  • Scaling to Many Users: The paper focuses on a two-user cluster. While they mention it can be extended to $N$ users, the complexity of the "Envelope Former" and the detection process would likely grow exponentially. Future work is needed to find low-complexity versions for massive user clusters.

Summary updated

Abstract

Non-orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) is capable of serving different numbers of users in the same time-frequency resource element, and this feature can be leveraged to carry additional information. In the orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) system, a novel enhanced NOMA scheme called NOMA with informative envelope (NOMA-IE) is proposed to explore extra flexibility from the envelope of NOMA signals. In this scheme, data bits are conveyed by the quantified signal envelope in addition to classic signal constellations. The subcarrier activation patterns of different users are jointly decided by the envelope former at the transmitter of NOMA-IE. At the receiver, successive interference cancellation (SIC) is employed, and the envelope detection coefficient is introduced to eliminate the error floor. Theoretical expressions of spectral efficiency, energy efficiency, and detection complexity are provided first. Then, considering the binary phase shift keying modulation, the block error rate and bit error rate are derived based on the two-subcarrier element. The analytical results reveal that the SIC error and the index error are the main factors degrading the error performance. The numerical results demonstrate the superiority of the NOMA-IE over the OFDM and OFDM-NOMA in terms of the error rate performance when all the schemes have the same spectral efficiency and energy efficiency.
BibTeX
@article{xie2024is,
  author = {Ziyi Xie and Wenqiang Yi and Xuanli Wu and Yuanwei Liu and Arumugam Nallanathan},
  title = {{Is the Envelope Beneficial to Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access?}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Communications},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/tcomm.2023.3337269},
}
Figure