Is Photographic Image Represented the Reality?

Xiaowei Huang

TL;DR

This paper argues that neither traditional nor digital photography truly represents reality, especially with the advent of computer software. It posits that photography is merely an action, and the increasing manipulation capabilities of digital tools further obscure any claim to objective truth, leading to a "loss of the real."

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the philosophical question of whether photographic images, both traditional and digital, can accurately represent reality. It highlights a perceived "loss of the real" due to technological advancements, particularly computer software, which allows for extensive manipulation of images. This raises concerns about the authenticity and objectivity of photographic representations in a world increasingly saturated with digitally altered visuals. The author questions the very definition of a "good image" in the digital age, suggesting it's no longer about skill in capturing a moment but rather proficiency in post-production.

Methods

The paper employs a theoretical and philosophical approach, drawing heavily on existing literature and critical theories. It analyzes concepts like "death of painting," "death of photography," and the "loss of the real" as discussed by various scholars. The author uses comparative analysis between traditional and digital photography, referencing the impact of computer software and digital manipulation techniques. Key theoretical frameworks, such as Marshall McLuhan's "the medium is the message," are used to explore how the medium itself shapes our perception of content.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Photography as Action, Not Representation: The core argument is that photography is fundamentally an "action" – the act of taking a picture – rather than a direct representation of reality.
  • The "Loss of the Real": The increasing sophistication of computer software for image manipulation leads to a situation where the original content of a photograph is altered, creating illusions and blurring the lines between reality and simulation.
  • Medium Over Message: Drawing from McLuhan, the paper suggests that the medium through which an image is presented (e.g., social media vs. a photo album) significantly influences its impact and how it's perceived, often overshadowing the content itself.
  • Subjectivity of Reality: The paper acknowledges that "reality" itself is a complex and subjective concept, with different interpretations across cultures and individuals.
  • Shift in Skill Valuation: In the digital age, the emphasis shifts from the photographer's skill in capturing a moment to their proficiency in using software to manipulate and enhance images.
  • Postmodern Influence: The paper touches upon postmodern theories, suggesting that the digital era fosters a culture of simulation and fragmentation, where the distinction between the real and the simulated becomes increasingly ambiguous.

Key Results

Not applicable, as this is a theoretical and argumentative paper rather than an empirical study. The "results" are the author's conclusions and arguments based on the analysis of existing theories and concepts.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper acknowledges that the term "reality" is broad and can be interpreted in many ways. It also notes that the question of whether manipulated computer-generated art is "art" is still debated. The author suggests that further research is necessary to explore the relationship between reproduction and photographic images in more depth, potentially at an "intensive level of interpretation." The paper also implicitly points to the need for critical media literacy in navigating the increasingly manipulated visual landscape.

Summary updated

Abstract

The development of technology represents the circulations and progresses of culture and society, from ‘death of painting’ (after the invention of photography) to ‘death of photography’ (after the invention of digital image). It seems too severe by using the term ‘death’. In actually, the ‘death’ is not really death since there are still many people who ardently love painting; galleries are opened as usual for the public. In the case of photography, the invention of the digital camera does not entirely take over the traditional role of the photographer. However, the ‘loss of the real’ (Lister, eds. 1995: 1) is the argument here based on the development of technology, for example, computer software. We have entered a new generation where we are surrounded by illusions. It is not a positive progress that technology made for photographic image. The judgment of what we call ‘a good image’ is no longer based on how skillful the photographer is. Instead, we could assume that there is no such things as good or poor taken image, only if you know how to use software. The invention of computer software makes things from impossible to possible. This paper aims to argue that photography is only an action. No matter traditional photograph or digital image, none of them is presented the reality. With the application of computer software, the original content of a photographic image is missing to some degree.
BibTeX
@article{huang2019is,
  author = {Xiaowei Huang},
  title = {{Is Photographic Image Represented the Reality?}},
  journal = {Journal of Social and Political Sciences},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.31014/aior.1991.02.03.103},
}
Figure