Abstract
In two dimensions, intrinsic second-order topological insulators (SOTIs) are characterized by topological corner states that emerge at the intersections of distinct edges with reversed mass signs, enforced by spatial symmetries. Here, we present a comprehensive investigation within the class BDI to clarify the symmetry conditions ensuring the presence of intrinsic SOTIs in two dimensions. We reveal that the (anti-)commutation relationship between spatial symmetries and chiral symmetry is a reliable indicator of intrinsic corner states. Through first-principles calculations, we identify several ideal candidates within carbon-based polymorphic graphyne structures for realizing intrinsic SOTIs under sublattice approximation. Furthermore, we show that the corner states in these materials persist even in the absence of sublattice approximation. Our findings not only deepen the understanding of higher-order topological phases but also open new pathways for realizing topological corner states that are readily observable.
Introduction
In the landscape of topological materials, first-order insulators are known for their protected edge states in 2D. Second-order topological insulators (SOTIs) represent a more exotic phase where protected states emerge not on the edges, but at the corners of a 2D crystal. These "intrinsic" corner states are guaranteed by the bulk crystal symmetry. However, realizing them in real materials is challenging because they often rely on symmetries like chiral symmetry, which are typically only approximate in physical systems. This study clarifies the symmetry conditions for SOTIs in Class BDI systems and identifies polymorphic graphyne as a promising experimental platform.
Theoretical Framework and Sublattice Approximation
The researchers utilized a minimal Dirac Hamiltonian to model edge states and determine the conditions under which a "mass term" flips sign at corners, a prerequisite for topological corner states. A key finding is the "commutation indicator": in 2D BDI systems, proper rotations must anticommute with chiral symmetry, while mirror symmetries must commute with it to ensure intrinsic corner states.
To bridge theory and reality, the authors employed a sublattice approximation. By partitioning atoms into two groups (Group-A and Group-B) and assuming electrons only hop between different sublattices, an effective chiral symmetry is enforced. This approximation simplifies the identification of topological phases in complex carbon allotropes like graphyne.
GY-1-5 Graphyne as a Candidate SOTI
Using first-principles Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations and Wannier tight-binding models, the study identified the GY-1-5 configuration of polymorphic graphyne as an ideal SOTI candidate. GY-1-5 belongs to the p2mm plane group and features a mix of $sp$ and $sp^2$ hybridized carbon bonds. It possesses a significant bulk band gap of 0.38 eV, which is large enough for potential room-temperature applications.
Simulations of large nanodisks containing thousands of atoms revealed the presence of zero-energy states (under the sublattice approximation) that are spatially localized at the corners. These states are a direct consequence of the non-trivial topology of the bulk and the specific symmetry of the GY-1-5 lattice.
Robustness and Outlook
A critical insight of this work is that these corner states are robust. While the sublattice approximation places them exactly at zero energy, they persist even when the approximation is relaxed (i.e., when next-nearest-neighbor hopping is included). In such cases, the states shift slightly in energy but remain trapped within the bulk band gap, protected by the underlying topology.
Future research will likely focus on the experimental synthesis of GY-1-5 and the use of Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM) to directly image these corner states. These findings pave the way for utilizing higher-order topological phases in quantum computing and low-power electronic devices.
Summary updated