Intrabeam Scattering Studies at CesrTA

Michael Ehrlichman, W. Hartung, M. Palmer, Daniel Peterson, N. Rider, David A. Rubin, James Shanks, C. Strohman, Shiqi Wang, R. Campbell, R. HoltzapplearXiv 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Intrabeam scattering (IBS) limits the emittance and single-bunch current that can be achieved in electron or positron storage ring colliders, damping rings, and light sources. Much theoretical work on IBS exists, and while the theories have been validated in hadron and ion machines, the presence of strong damping makes IBS in lepton machines a different phenomenon. We present the results of measurements at CesrTA of IBS dominated beams, and compare the data with theory. The beams we study have parameters typical of those specified for the next generation of wiggler dominated storage rings: low emittance, small bunch length, and few GeV energy. Our measurements are in good agreement with IBS theory, provided a tail-cut procedure is applied.

Introduction

In the quest for brighter light sources and higher-luminosity particle colliders, achieving "low emittance"—packing particles into the smallest possible volume—is essential. However, as bunch density increases, particles begin to crowd each other, leading to Intrabeam Scattering (IBS). This collective effect, characterized by multiple small-angle Coulomb scatterings, causes the beam to "blow up" or increase in emittance. While well-understood in proton and ion machines, lepton (electron/positron) machines are unique due to strong radiation damping. In these rings, beam size represents a delicate equilibrium between IBS "heating" and synchrotron radiation "cooling."

Methodology and the Tail-Cut Procedure

The researchers utilized the CesrTA facility at Cornell, a storage ring optimized for low-emittance physics. Experiments were conducted at 2.085 GeV using both positrons and electrons to identify species-dependent effects. Key instrumentation included an x-ray beam size monitor (xBSM) for vertical dimensions, a visible-light interferometer for horizontal size, and a streak camera for longitudinal bunch length.

The study's most critical contribution is the application of a "tail-cut." In lepton rings, large-angle scattering events are so rare that they occur less than once per damping time. These events create non-Gaussian tails rather than affecting the core beam size measured by standard instruments. By mathematically excluding these rare events from the IBS growth rate calculation, the researchers reconciled theory with experimental observations.

Figure 2: (a) The ratio of scattering rate to damping rate as a function of scattering angle. (b) Horizontal beam size measurements compared against theory with various tail-cut thresholds, demonstrating that the cut is essential for data alignment.

Results and Theoretical Convergence

The team compared three major IBS formalisms: Kubo-Oide, Bjorken-Mtingwa, and Piwinski. They found that these theories yield nearly identical results when the Coulomb log and tail-cuts are treated consistently.

Figure 6: Comparison of (a) horizontal beam size, (b) vertical beam size, and (c) bunch length against various IBS theories. The horizontal and longitudinal data show strong agreement, while the vertical data reveals an unexplained anomaly at high currents.

Quantitative agreement was excellent for horizontal beam size and bunch length. For instance, horizontal emittance increased from 3.8 nm-rad at low current to 10.4 nm-rad at high intensity. However, the vertical beam size exhibited an unexpected "positive curvature" blow-up at very high currents ($> 8 \times 10^{10}$ particles). This "vertical mystery" suggests the onset of additional physics, such as resonances or beam instabilities, not accounted for in standard IBS theory.

Conclusion

The CesrTA measurements validate that IBS theory, when modified with a tail-cut procedure to account for radiation damping, accurately predicts the performance limits of high-intensity lepton beams. This work provides a vital roadmap for the design of next-generation low-emittance storage rings, ensuring that collective effects are properly modeled in the pursuit of higher luminosity and brightness.

Summary updated

Abstract

Intrabeam scattering (IBS) limits the emittance and single-bunch current that can be achieved in electron or positron storage ring colliders, damping rings, and light sources. Much theoretical work on IBS exists, and while the theories have been validated in hadron and ion machines, the presence of strong damping makes IBS in lepton machines a different phenomenon. We present the results of measurements at CesrTA of IBS dominated beams, and compare the data with theory. The beams we study have parameters typical of those specified for the next generation of wiggler dominated storage rings: low emittance, small bunch length, and few GeV energy. Our measurements are in good agreement with IBS theory, provided a tail-cut procedure is applied.
BibTeX
@misc{ehrlichman2013intrabeam,
  author = {Michael Ehrlichman and W. Hartung and M. Palmer and Daniel Peterson and N. Rider and David A. Rubin and James Shanks and C. Strohman and Shiqi Wang and R. Campbell and R. Holtzapple},
  title = {{Intrabeam Scattering Studies at CesrTA}},
  year = {2013},
  eprint = {1308.0035},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1308.0035},
}
Figure