Interference of nematic quantum critical quasiparticles: A route to the octet model

Eun-Ah Kim, Michael J. LawlerPhysical 2010 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We study the effect of nematic quantum critical fluctuations on quasiparticle interference. We show that nematic quantum critical fluctuations, which cause back and forth sloshing of the $d$-wave nodes along the underlying Fermi surface, provide a natural mechanism for the accumulation of coherence that has been present in QPI experiments.

Introduction: The Mystery of the Octet Model

In the study of high-temperature cuprate superconductors, Scanning Tunneling Spectroscopy (STS) is a primary tool for mapping the Local Density of States (LDOS). When these maps are Fourier-transformed, they reveal Quasiparticle Interference (QPI) patterns.

A long-standing mystery in this field is the "octet model": despite the inherent nanoscale disorder and "glassy" nature of cuprates, their QPI patterns are remarkably simple, consisting of eight well-defined dispersing peaks. Standard theories using non-interacting Bogoliubov quasiparticles predict a much messier pattern. The challenge is to identify a physical mechanism that explains why only the "tips" of the constant-energy contours remain coherent enough to produce these sharp peaks.

Methods: Modeling Nematic Fluctuations

We employ a many-body physics approach to model electron scattering off impurities. Instead of a simple "free" propagator, we introduce a self-energy term ($\Sigma$) into the Green’s function to capture the effects of nematic quantum critical fluctuations.

Using the T-matrix formalism, we calculate how isolated impurities modulate the LDOS. We linearize the electron dispersion around the four nodes of the $d$-wave superconductor and test the model against various scattering centers, including charge and magnetic impurities. Experimental parameters for electron velocity ($v_F$) and gap slope ($v_\Delta$) are drawn from ARPES and thermal conductivity data.

Key Insights: Nematicity as a Coherence Filter

Our core finding is that "nematic" fluctuations—where electrons break the crystal's rotational symmetry—act as a selective coherence filter. Near a Quantum Critical Point (QCP), these fluctuations cause the superconducting nodes to "slosh" back and forth along the Fermi surface.

Phase diagram showing the nematic quantum critical region (shaded) and the associated "sloshing" of d-wave nodes on the Fermi surface.

This sloshing introduces a strongly momentum-dependent decoherence. Quasiparticles at the "tips" of the energy contours remain coherent with long lifetimes, while those elsewhere are severely damped. This selective damping naturally "carves out" the octet model from the messy background, explaining why only specific scattering vectors ($q_i$) appear as sharp peaks in experiments.

Key Results: Sharpening the QPI Pattern

While free-particle models produce broad, faint segments in QPI maps, our nematic critical model produces sharp, unambiguous peaks at the exact locations predicted by the octet model.

Calculated QPI maps (a-c) demonstrating how the inclusion of nematic fluctuations and specific impurity types highlights the characteristic $q_i$ vectors of the octet model.

Key results include:

  • Peak Sharpening: The model reproduces the eight-peak pattern with high fidelity, matching experimental observations in materials like $Bi_2Sr_2CaCu_2O_{8+\delta}$.
  • Impurity Sensitivity: The theory explains why different impurities highlight different peaks; charge impurities favor sign-reversing scattering, while magnetic centers (like vortices) favor sign-preserving scattering.
  • Gap Renormalization: The model accounts for the "flattening" of the gap slope observed in underdoped cuprates, linking it directly to the emergence of nematicity.

Conclusion and Future Work

Nematic quantum criticality provides a robust theoretical foundation for the octet model. While this explains low-energy coherence, future research is needed to investigate the "glassy" features that emerge at higher energy scales and to determine if other types of quantum criticality could produce similar filtering effects.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the effect of nematic quantum critical fluctuations on quasiparticle interference. We show that nematic quantum critical fluctuations, which cause back and forth slushing of the $d$-wave nodes along the underlying Fermi surface, provide a natural mechanism for the accumulation of coherence that has been present in QPI experiments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kim2010interference,
  author = {Eun-Ah Kim and Michael J. Lawler},
  title = {{Interference of nematic quantum critical quasiparticles: A route to the octet model}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.81.132501},
}
Figure