Anomalous scaling of the penetration depth in nodal superconductors

Jian-Huang She, Michael J. Lawler, Eun-Ah KimPhysical 2015 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Recent findings of anomalous superlinear scaling of low-temperature $(T)$ penetration depth (PD) in several nodal superconductors near putative quantum critical points suggest that the low-temperature PD can be a useful probe of quantum critical fluctuations in a superconductor. On the other hand, cuprates, which are poster child nodal superconductors, have not shown any such anomalous scaling of PD, despite growing evidence of quantum critical points (QCP). Then it is natural to ask when and how can quantum critical fluctuations cause anomalous scaling of PD? Carrying out the renormalization group calculation for the problem of two-dimensional superconductors with point nodes, we show that quantum critical fluctuations associated with a point group symmetry reduction result in nonuniversal logarithmic corrections to the $T$ dependence of the PD. The resulting apparent power law depends on the bare velocity anisotropy ratio. We then compare our results to data sets from two distinct nodal superconductors: ${\mathrm{YBa}}_{2}{\mathrm{Cu}}_{3}{\mathrm{O}}_{6.95}$ and ${\mathrm{CeCoIn}}_{5}$. Considering all symmetry-lowering possibilities of the point group of interest, ${C}_{4v}$, we find our results to be remarkably consistent with ${\mathrm{YBa}}_{2}{\mathrm{Cu}}_{3}{\mathrm{O}}_{6.95}$ being near a vertical nematic QCP and ${\mathrm{CeCoIn}}_{5}$ being near a diagonal nematic QCP. Our results motivate a search for diagonal nematic fluctuations in ${\mathrm{CeCoIn}}_{5}$.

Introduction

In "nodal" superconductors, the superconducting gap vanishes at specific points or lines called nodes. Standard theory predicts that the magnetic penetration depth (PD)—a measure of how far a magnetic field can penetrate the material—should change linearly with temperature ($T$) at very low temperatures.

Phase diagram of a nodal superconductor near a quantum critical point (QCP) at $x_c$.

However, experiments have shown that while some materials follow this $T$-linear rule, others, such as the heavy-fermion superconductor $CeCoIn_5$, exhibit "super-linear" scaling (e.g., $T^{1.5}$). This behavior typically emerges near a Quantum Critical Point (QCP), where a material is poised between two phases of matter at absolute zero. This research addresses why quantum criticality alters scaling in some materials but not in others, like the cuprates, which often maintain standard $T$-linear scaling despite proximity to a QCP.

Methods

The authors employed Renormalization Group (RG) calculations to study how the physics of these systems changes across scales. They modeled low-energy excitations near nodes as 2D Dirac fermions and analyzed their coupling to symmetry-breaking fluctuations of an order parameter appearing at the QCP. Specifically, they focused on transitions that preserve nodes but lower the $C_{4v}$ point-group symmetry of the square lattice, categorizing fluctuations into "vertical" nematic (stretching along x or y axes) and "diagonal" nematic (stretching along diagonals). A 1/N expansion was used to derive the temperature dependence of the electromagnetic response kernel.

Key Results and Discussion

The core discovery is that quantum critical fluctuations do not produce a simple new power law. Instead, they generate nonuniversal logarithmic corrections to the $T$-linear behavior. Over a limited experimental temperature range, these corrections appear as an "apparent" power law.

Analytical expressions for the inverse square of the penetration depth ($\delta\lambda^{-2}$) based on the type of symmetry-breaking coupling.

The scaling behavior is determined by the nature of the symmetry breaking:

  • Vertical Nematicity ($\tau_x$ coupling): Leads to "sub-linear" corrections. In $YBa_2Cu_3O_{6.95}$ (YBCO), extreme velocity anisotropy makes these corrections nearly invisible, explaining its observed $T$-linear behavior.
  • Diagonal Nematicity ($\tau_z$ coupling): Leads to "super-linear" corrections. The anomalous scaling in $CeCoIn_5$ is identified as a signature of a diagonal nematic QCP.

By fitting theoretical models to experimental data for YBCO and $CeCoIn_5$, the researchers found that YBCO's data is consistent with a vertical nematic QCP, while $CeCoIn_5$ likely sits near a diagonal nematic QCP. This suggests $CeCoIn_5$ fluctuates toward a state favoring diagonal lattice distortion.

Conclusion

This study provides a theoretical framework that reconciles conflicting experimental data in nodal superconductors. By showing that logarithmic corrections from quantum critical fluctuations can mimic power laws, it explains the diverse scaling of penetration depth. These results motivate further experimental searches for diagonal nematic fluctuations in $CeCoIn_5$ using techniques like elastoresistance or strain-response measurements. Future work may extend these findings from 2D point nodes to 3D systems with line nodes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent findings of anomalous superlinear scaling of low-temperature $(T)$ penetration depth (PD) in several nodal superconductors near putative quantum critical points suggest that the low-temperature PD can be a useful probe of quantum critical fluctuations in a superconductor. On the other hand, cuprates, which are poster child nodal superconductors, have not shown any such anomalous scaling of PD, despite growing evidence of quantum critical points (QCP). Then it is natural to ask when and how can quantum critical fluctuations cause anomalous scaling of PD? Carrying out the renormalization group calculation for the problem of two-dimensional superconductors with point nodes, we show that quantum critical fluctuations associated with a point group symmetry reduction result in nonuniversal logarithmic corrections to the $T$ dependence of the PD. The resulting apparent power law depends on the bare velocity anisotropy ratio. We then compare our results to data sets from two distinct nodal superconductors: ${\mathrm{YBa}}_{2}{\mathrm{Cu}}_{3}{\mathrm{O}}_{6.95}$ and ${\mathrm{CeCoIn}}_{5}$. Considering all symmetry-lowering possibilities of the point group of interest, ${C}_{4v}$, we find our results to be remarkably consistent with ${\mathrm{YBa}}_{2}{\mathrm{Cu}}_{3}{\mathrm{O}}_{6.95}$ being near a vertical nematic QCP and ${\mathrm{CeCoIn}}_{5}$ being near a diagonal nematic QCP. Our results motivate a search for diagonal nematic fluctuations in ${\mathrm{CeCoIn}}_{5}$.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{she2015anomalous,
  author = {Jian-Huang She and Michael J. Lawler and Eun-Ah Kim},
  title = {{Anomalous scaling of the penetration depth in nodal superconductors}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.92.035112},
}
Figure