Cold-spots and glassy nematicity in underdoped cuprates

Kyungmin Lee, Steven A. Kivelson, Eun-Ah KimPhysical 2016 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

There is now copious direct experimental evidence of various forms of (short-range) charge order in underdoped cuprate high temperature superconductors, and spectroscopic signatures of a nodal-antinodal dichotomy in the structure of the single-particle spectral functions. In this context we analyze the Bogoliubov quasiparticle spectrum in a superconducting nematic glass. The coincidence of the superconducting "nodal points" and the nematic "cold-spots" on the Fermi surface naturally accounts for many of the most salient features of the measured spectral functions (from angle-resolved photoemission) and the local density of states (from scanning tunneling microscopy).

Introduction: The Nodal-Antinodal Dichotomy

A persistent mystery in high-temperature cuprate superconductors is the "nodal-antinodal dichotomy." In momentum space, electrons traveling diagonally (the "nodes") behave as coherent, well-defined quasiparticles. Conversely, electrons moving along the principal axes (the "antinodes") appear heavily scattered or "smudged" in spectroscopic data. While standard theories often struggle to reconcile these behaviors, this paper proposes that a "nematic glass"—a state with local, randomly oriented directional preferences—provides a unifying explanation.

Theoretical Framework: The Nematic Glass Model

The authors utilize a Bogoliubov-de Gennes (BdG) Hamiltonian to model a d-wave superconductor on a lattice. The critical innovation is the introduction of a disorder potential with a d-wave form factor, representing a nematic glass. Unlike isotropic point impurities, this potential's scattering strength is inherently direction-dependent.

Fermi surface and angular dependence of the scattering rate showing 'cold-spots' at the nodes.

The simulations were performed on large lattices (up to $512 \times 512$ sites) using self-consistent calculations to allow the superconducting gap to adjust to the local glassy environment. This approach ensures that the interplay between superconductivity and disorder is captured accurately.

Key Insights: Symmetry as a Filter

The core of the theory lies in the "Cold-Spot Coincidence." In a d-wave superconductor, the energy gap vanishes at the nodes. Simultaneously, the d-wave symmetry of the nematic glass ensures that scattering is weakest at these same nodal points—effectively creating "cold-spots" on the Fermi surface.

This symmetry acts as a filter: low-energy nodal electrons are shielded from the glassy disorder, preserving their coherence. In contrast, antinodal electrons experience the full force of the scattering, leading to the observed spectroscopic smearing. Remarkably, the authors find that even short-range nematic correlations ($\xi \approx 2a$) are sufficient to reproduce this dichotomy.

Results and Validation

The model's predictions were compared against experimental ARPES, STM, and optical conductivity data.

Real-Space Heterogeneity in STM

One of the most striking successes of the model is its reproduction of energy-dependent spatial heterogeneity. In STM experiments, the local density of states (LDOS) appears relatively homogeneous at low energies (near the Fermi level) but becomes increasingly "patchy" at higher energies.

Real-space maps of local density of states showing increased heterogeneity at higher energies.

As shown in the figure above, the simulated LDOS at $E=0$ is smooth because it is dominated by protected nodal states. At higher energies ($E = -0.2t$), the contribution from disordered antinodal states leads to significant spatial fluctuations, matching experimental observations.

Spectroscopic Signatures

The model also successfully replicates the "two-peak" structure in antinodal ARPES data—a sharp quasiparticle peak accompanied by a broad incoherent shoulder—while maintaining a single sharp peak at the nodes. Furthermore, it produces the characteristic optical conductivity of underdoped cuprates: a narrow Drude peak at low frequency and a broad mid-infrared peak.

Discussion and Future Directions

While the static nematic glass model excels at low temperatures, it fails to capture the persistence of the "two-peak" optical structure above the superconducting transition temperature ($T_c$). This suggests that at higher temperatures, the system may transition from a glass to a dynamic "nematic liquid."

The authors propose uniaxial strain as a "smoking-gun" experimental test. By applying strain to align the nematic domains, the "anomalous" scattering features should diminish, providing direct evidence for the role of glassy nematicity in these complex materials.

Summary updated

Abstract

There is now copious direct experimental evidence of various forms of (short-range) charge order in underdoped cuprate high temperature superconductors, and spectroscopic signatures of a nodal-antinodal dichotomy in the structure of the single-particle spectral functions. In this context we analyze the Bogoliubov quasiparticle spectrum in a superconducting nematic glass. The coincidence of the superconducting ``nodal points'' and the nematic ``cold-spots'' on the Fermi surface naturally accounts for many of the most salient features of the measured spectral functions (from angle-resolved photoemission) and the local density of states (from scanning tunneling microscopy).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lee2016cold,
  author = {Kyungmin Lee and Steven A. Kivelson and Eun-Ah Kim},
  title = {{Cold-spots and glassy nematicity in underdoped cuprates}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.94.014204},
}
Figure