Abstract
Superconductivity was recently discovered in rhombohedral trilayer graphene (RTG) in the absence of a moiré potential. Superconductivity is observed proximate to a metallic state with reduced isospin symmetry, but it remains unknown whether this is a coincidence or a key ingredient for superconductivity. Using a Hartree-Fock analysis and constraints from experiments, we argue that the symmetry breaking is inter-valley coherent (IVC) in nature. We evaluate IVC fluctuations as a possible pairing glue, and find that they lead to chiral unconventional superconductivity when the fluctuations are strong. We further elucidate how the inter-valley Hund's coupling determines the spin-structure of the IVC ground state and breaks the degeneracy between spin-singlet and triplet superconductivity. Remarkably, if the normal state is spin-unpolarized, we find that a ferromagnetic Hund's coupling favors spin-singlet superconductivity, in agreement with experiments. Instead, if the normal state is spin-polarized, then IVC fluctuations lead to spin-triplet pairing.
Introduction
In the burgeoning field of "twistronics," superconductivity is typically engineered by stacking graphene layers at precise "magic angles" to induce a moiré potential. However, the recent discovery of superconductivity in ABC-stacked rhombohedral trilayer graphene (RTG) challenged this paradigm, as RTG lacks a moiré pattern. This discovery raised critical questions regarding the nature of the "partially isospin polarized" (PIP) metallic phase adjacent to the superconducting regions, the identity of the pairing "glue," and the physical origin of the distinct spin-singlet (SC1) and spin-triplet (SC2) phases.
Methods
The study utilizes a self-consistent six-band Hartree-Fock model to evaluate the energies of candidate metallic states under experimental constraints, such as the absence of an anomalous Hall effect. To investigate superconductivity, the authors treat fluctuations of the metallic order parameter as the pairing interaction, solving the linearized Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) gap equations. The model incorporates Random Phase Approximation (RPA) to account for itinerant electron screening of the Coulomb interaction. Tight-binding parameters are derived from established experimental and ab-initio studies, ensuring consistency with the phase diagrams and transport data reported in landmark RTG experiments.
Inter-Valley Coherence and Isospin Fluctuations
The researchers identify the mysterious PIP phase as an Inter-Valley Coherent (IVC) metal. In this state, electrons occupy a coherent quantum superposition of both valleys, effectively tripling the crystal's unit cell. Analogous to spin fluctuations in high-temperature cuprates, isospin fluctuations near the IVC transition provide the repulsive interaction necessary for unconventional pairing.
A critical component of this mechanism is the inter-valley Hund’s coupling—a lattice-scale magnetic interaction. The analysis reveals that a ferromagnetic Hund’s coupling favors spin-singlet pairing in unpolarized regions (SC1) but shifts to favoring spin-triplets when the parent metal is spin-polarized (SC2).
Results and Superconducting Symmetry
The Hartree-Fock phase diagram successfully reproduces the sequence of metallic transitions observed experimentally as a function of electron density and displacement field. The calculated transition temperatures ($T_c$) range from 0.1 to 1 K, aligning with experimental observations.
The model predicts that SC1 is a spin-singlet chiral $d+id$ state, while SC2 is a spin-triplet state inheriting the polarization of its parent metal. This framework naturally explains why SC1 respects the Pauli paramagnetic limit while SC2 violates it. Furthermore, strong fluctuations are predicted to lead to chiral superconductivity, which breaks time-reversal symmetry.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
While the current model provides a robust explanation for RTG superconductivity, it simplifies the interaction by omitting frequency dependence (retardation effects) near critical points. Future experimental verification via Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM) could confirm the predicted tripled unit cell of the IVC phase. Although the predicted phases are chiral, they are likely topologically trivial in the specific geometry of RTG, suggesting that further engineering may be required to realize robust Majorana fermions for quantum computation.
Summary updated