INO volume 37 issue 1 Cover and Front matter

Robert Populism, Timothy J. McKeown, Michael Shafer, Robert East, William M. Reisinger, Stanley Hoffmann, James A. Caporaso, Robert Cox, Jorge I. Domínguez, Albert Fishlow, Robert Gılpın, Leon Gordenker, Peter Gourevitch, Ernst B. Haas, Wolfgang Hager, Gerald K. Helleiner, Alfred O. Hero, K. J. Holsti, Harold K. Jacobson, Abdul Aziz, Jalloh Gerd, Junne Takashi, Inoguchi Robert, O Keohane, Stephen D. Krasner, Theodore H. Moran, Lynn Krieger Mytelka, Joseph S. Nye, Janice Guillermo O'donnell, Susan E. Stein, Laura Strange, William C. Tyson, Louis Wallace, Thomas G. Wells, Mark Willett, Robert M. Cutler, Hartmat Elsenhans, R. A. Johnson, Harvey PickeringInternational Organization 1983 · DOI

Abstract

The Winter 1983 issue of International Organization (Volume 37, Number 1) represents a critical juncture in International Relations (IR) scholarship. This review synthesizes the collective themes of the issue, which addressed the friction between the Global North and South, challenged Hegemonic Stability Theory, and analyzed the complexities of resource sovereignty during the twilight of the Cold War.

Introduction: The NIEO and the Crisis of Development

The early 1980s were defined by the "New International Economic Order" (NIEO) debates. Developing nations sought to restructure the global economy to move away from perceived neo-colonial dependencies. This issue of International Organization brought together a formidable group of scholars to dissect these tensions, bridging the gap between political theory and economic reality.

The Editorial Board and contributors for this issue include many of the foundational figures in modern International Relations theory, such as Robert Keohane, Joseph Nye, and Robert Gilpin.

Challenging Hegemonic Stability

One of the most significant theoretical contributions in this volume is Timothy J. McKeown’s critique of Hegemonic Stability Theory. By examining 19th-century European tariff data, McKeown argued that Great Britain’s behavior—often cited as the archetype of a stabilizing hegemon—was inconsistent with the theory. Instead, he proposed a "political business cycle" model, suggesting that domestic economic pressures often outweigh the systemic role of a dominant power. This shift pushed IR scholarship away from simple power-based models toward more complex domestic and institutional explanations.

The "Insulation" Theory and Nationalization

Michael Shafer’s comparative study of the copper industries in Zaire and Zambia provided a sobering look at resource sovereignty. He introduced the concept of "corporate insulation," arguing that multinational corporations act as a buffer for states. When these industries were nationalized, the states lost this insulation, becoming directly exposed to market volatility and operational risks they were ill-equipped to handle. The study showed that nationalization often led to a loss of benefits because states could not replicate the risk-management functions of the corporations they ousted.

Global South Dynamics and Bloc Politics

The issue also explored the intersection of Cold War dynamics and development. Robert M. Cutler analyzed how the Soviet-led CMEA (Council for Mutual Economic Assistance) interacted with the Group of 77 (G77) within UNCTAD. These "issue-specific coalitions" allowed the East Bloc to refashion trade environments to favor state-trading structures, demonstrating that international law was a tool for strategic alignment rather than just a neutral framework.

Conclusion: A Legacy of Complexity

Collectively, the articles in Volume 37, Number 1 moved the field toward a more nuanced understanding of the global political economy. While some analyses remain rooted in the bipolar logic of the 1980s, the core insights—particularly regarding the limitations of hegemonic power and the risks of state-led industrial management—continue to resonate in contemporary scholarship. The issue remains a testament to a period when IR theory was forced to grapple with the practical failures of both Western capitalism and Southern nationalism in the periphery.

Summary updated

Abstract

An abstract is not available for this content so a preview has been provided. As you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{populism1983ino,
  author = {Robert Populism and Timothy J. McKeown and Michael Shafer and Robert East and William M. Reisinger and Stanley Hoffmann and James A. Caporaso and Robert Cox and Jorge I. Domínguez and Albert Fishlow and Robert Gılpın and Leon Gordenker and Peter Gourevitch and Ernst B. Haas and Wolfgang Hager and Gerald K. Helleiner and Alfred O. Hero and K. J. Holsti and Harold K. Jacobson and Abdul Aziz and Jalloh Gerd and Junne Takashi and Inoguchi Robert and O Keohane and Stephen D. Krasner and Theodore H. Moran and Lynn Krieger Mytelka and Joseph S. Nye and Janice Guillermo O'donnell and Susan E. Stein and Laura Strange and William C. Tyson and Louis Wallace and Thomas G. Wells and Mark Willett and Robert M. Cutler and Hartmat Elsenhans and R. A. Johnson and Harvey Pickering and Harvey Pickering},
  title = {{INO volume 37 issue 1 Cover and Front matter}},
  booktitle = {International Organization},
  year = {1983},
  doi = {10.1017/s0020818300004161},
}
Figure