Labor Movements and Social Change in Latin America and the Caribbean

Eric MitchellInternational Labor and Working-Class History 1989 · DOI

Introduction

In October 1988, the Centre for Research on Latin America and the Caribbean (CERLAC) convened an international conference at York University to mark its tenth anniversary. This gathering brought together 44 academics and trade unionists from 19 countries to address the shifting dynamics of labor movements in the region. The conference highlighted a "triple threat" facing labor: the burden of international debt, the rise of multinational corporations (MNCs) with high capital mobility, and profound internal social shifts.

The Challenge of Global Capital and Austerity

A central theme of the conference was the impact of multinational corporate strategies on labor discipline. Presenters noted that management often uses the "spectre of relocation"—the threat of moving production to other countries—to suppress worker demands. This creates a forced competition between workers across borders, effectively undermining local solidarity and suppressing wage demands.

Furthermore, the Caribbean trade union movement faced a "massive retrenchment" during this period. IMF-mandated austerity and debt servicing requirements pushed labor conditions back to levels not seen since before the 1930s. In Guyana, the conference examined how state manipulation of the Trades Union Council (TUC) over two decades neutralized independent unionism, illustrating the dangers of state co-optation and the erosion of democratic labor structures.

Methodological and Theoretical Revisions

The conference challenged existing academic models that often viewed labor through narrow economic lenses or isolated workers from their broader social contexts. Participants advocated for several shifts in how labor is studied:

  • The Informal Sector Link: Participants argued against "dual economy" models that separate formal wage earners from the urban informal sector. Instead, they proposed a "class-formation" approach to understand how labor organizes across these boundaries.
  • Feminist Revisionism: Research into Argentine labor history debunked the myth of women as merely "sentimental" participants. By analyzing anarchist and socialist archives (such as La Protesta and La Vanguardia), researchers revealed women as active leaders and organizers whose roles had been obscured by male-centric historical accounts.
  • Sexual Politics in Nicaragua: In Nicaragua, the labor struggle evolved beyond traditional production issues to include "public sexual politics." This included addressing workplace harassment, abortion rights, and the systemic challenge of machismo within the Asociación de Trabajadores del Campo (ATC).

Redefining Democracy

A significant portion of the dialogue focused on the limitations of conventional parliamentary models of democracy. Presenters argued that for the "popular classes," true democratization requires addressing systemic racism, sexism, and centralism. The conference emphasized that the formal reestablishment of democratic governments does not automatically resolve underlying issues of poverty and human rights violations, necessitating a broader definition of democratic participation.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The 1988 CERLAC conference served as a critical bridge between academic theory and trade union practice. However, it also identified several areas for future work to ensure research remains relevant to the "logic of conflict" on the ground:

  1. Cross-National Comparison: Moving beyond isolated case studies to identify broader regional patterns of labor resistance and adaptation.
  2. Integration of Theory and Practice: Moving away from "imported evolutionary frameworks" of development and focusing on historical data that reflects actual labor struggles.
  3. Overcoming Ideological Divides: Addressing the ideological differences (such as Catholic vs. Socialist orientations) that can prevent cross-border solidarity, even when unions share similar organizational goals.

The event underscored that labor movements remain central to the quest for social change and genuine democracy in Latin America and the Caribbean, provided they can adapt to the increasingly globalized nature of capital and the diverse social identities of the workforce.

Summary updated

Abstract

In celebration of its tenth anniversary, the Centre for Research on Latin America and the Caribbean (CERLAC) held an international conference on labor movements and social change in the regions 13-15 October 1988 at York University. Forty-four academics and trade unionists from nineteen countries gave presentations, which were organized into twelve sessions, on a range of issues, including labor and development problems, women's relationships to trade unions, and labor and democratization.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mitchell1989labor,
  author = {Eric Mitchell},
  title = {{Labor Movements and Social Change in Latin America and the Caribbean}},
  booktitle = {International Labor and Working-Class History},
  year = {1989},
  doi = {10.1017/s0147547900009352},
}
Figure