Latin American Studies since the 1980s: From Apocalyptic Dreams to Assimilationist Consolidation

Thiago Dumont Oliveira, Juan Grigera, Pedro Mendes LoureiroarXiv 2026 · arXiv

This study provides a data-driven autopsy of how Latin American Studies (LAS) has transformed over the last four decades. By analyzing thousands of articles, the authors demonstrate that while the field has successfully consolidated into a highly interdisciplinary "bridge" between social sciences, this maturity has come at a cost: the marginalization of Latin American-based journals and a growing pressure for regional scholars to mimic Anglophone academic norms to achieve visibility.

TL;DR

Latin American Studies has evolved from a fragmented, Cold War-era discipline into a robust, interdisciplinary field that acts as a vital connector between social science disciplines. However, this "assimilationist consolidation" has reinforced Northern academic hierarchies, leading to a decline in the influence of Latin American-based journals and a convergence of citation practices toward Anglophone standards.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, Area Studies—fields focused on specific geographic regions—have faced an existential crisis. During the Cold War, they were funded for strategic and military intelligence. With the rise of globalization in the 1990s, critics (the so-called areastreit or "area studies struggle") argued that region-specific knowledge was becoming obsolete, favoring "universal" social science methods like rational choice theory and large-scale econometrics.

The authors set out to determine how LAS survived this period. Did it lose its soul to mainstream political science? Did it become more or less interdisciplinary? Most importantly, they investigate the "geographies of knowledge": who is producing the research, and are Latin American scholars being integrated into the global conversation on equal terms, or are they being forced to abandon regional intellectual traditions to fit into Northern (US/UK) academic boxes?

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged computational approach to map the field's evolution:

  • Network Analysis: They constructed co-citation networks where journals are "nodes" and links represent how often they are cited together. They specifically used betweenness centrality to identify which journals act as "bridges" between different academic disciplines.
  • Text Mining: They analyzed word frequency and "composite terms" (e.g., grouping various statistical terms under "quantitative methods") in article abstracts to track thematic shifts.
  • Bibliographic Coupling: This technique measures the similarity between two groups (in this case, authors based in Latin America vs. those based elsewhere) by looking at the overlap in their reference lists.
  • Longitudinal Comparison: The data was split into two windows: 1982–2003 (the Cold War and early globalization era) and 2004–2024 (the era of consolidation).

Datasets

The authors extracted metadata for 3,629 articles from three flagship journals: Journal of Latin American Studies (JLAS), Latin American Perspectives (LAP), and Latin American Research Review (LARR). The data was retrieved from the Web of Science (WoS) and included bibliographical references, abstracts, and institutional affiliations.

Table 1. Article Count per Journal, 1982-2003 vs. 2004-2024

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Rise of the "Bridge" Journal: LAS journals have become significantly more central to the broader academic network. They aren't just niche outlets; they now act as connectors that facilitate information flow between neighboring disciplines like sociology, geography, and political science.
  • From History to Political Science: There has been a massive disciplinary shift. In the first period, history was a dominant force. In the second, political science journals doubled their share of citations (from 14.2% to 27.1%), while history plummeted (from 18.4% to 4.1%).
  • The "Mimicry" Trap: While the participation of Latin American-based authors has doubled (reaching 32% of articles), their citation patterns have converged toward those of Northern scholars. To get published in top journals, regional scholars are increasingly citing Northern-based literature and ignoring journals published within Latin America.
  • Marginalization of the Periphery: Despite more Latin American authors being published, journals actually based in Latin America have been pushed to the periphery of the citation network. Their share of citations in top outlets has halved over the last 20 years.

Key Results

  • Network Density: The density of the co-citation network increased from 0.41 to 0.62, indicating that the field has become much less compartmentalized and more integrated.
  • Centrality Scores: LAS journals like JLAS and BLAR now rank higher in betweenness centrality than many mainstream disciplinary journals, proving their role as interdisciplinary hubs.
  • Thematic Shifts: Text mining revealed a sharp decline in Marxist and political economy vocabulary (e.g., "class" down 42%, "Marxism" down 65%) and a surge in terms like "governance" (+565%) and "ethnography" (+340%).
  • Citation Homogeneity: The link strength (similarity) between Latin American and non-Latin American authors rose from 5,571 to 10,611, showing that the two groups now cite almost identical sets of literature.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their study is limited to three specific journals, which, while prestigious, do not represent the entirety of the field. They also highlight a modern concern: the rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) in research. They warn that since LLMs are trained on existing literature, they may reinforce the very biases identified in this paper by over-referencing prominent Northern scholars and further marginalizing regional voices.

Future research could expand this analysis to a broader set of regional journals and investigate how national evaluation policies (like those in Ecuador or Argentina) specifically drive scholars toward "assimilationist" publishing strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate how Latin American Studies (LAS) has evolved since 1982 in three leading LAS journals. Using network analysis, text mining, and bibliometrics, we trace transformations in disciplinary positioning, authorship, and citation patterns. Our main claim is that LAS has undergone an assimilationist consolidation. The field is now institutionally recognisable, with core LAS journals occupying central positions in disciplinary networks and acting as bridges across fields. Yet this consolidation has reinforced hierarchies privileging Anglophone academic norms. Journals based in Latin America, once central, have been marginalised. The share of Latin American authors has grown, but their profiles converge towards Northern standards.
BibTeX
@misc{oliveira2026latin,
  author = {Thiago Dumont Oliveira and Juan Grigera and Pedro Mendes Loureiro},
  title = {{Latin American Studies since the 1980s: From Apocalyptic Dreams to Assimilationist Consolidation}},
  year = {2026},
  eprint = {2611.13216},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.13216},
}
Figure