Abstract
Two-phase loop thermosyphon is promising in free cooling of data center, base station, and other industrial buildings with high temperature heat source. The largescale circulation loop of its natural phase-change cycle is complex with high internal flow resistance in these context and thus is hardly related to the thermodynamic properties of working medium, which has yet to be revealed in detail. In this study, a distributed steady-state model was implemented to verify the heat transfer performance of a two-phase loop thermosyphon with different working mediums under high internal flow resistance for building air-conditioning. Simulative study shows that the behaviors of R744 and R410A are relatively superior, and R744 is outstanding at the extreme high thermal resistance condition. The operating states with different mixed refrigerants are more stable in comparison with pure refrigerants. Ecofriendly mixed refrigerants with low cost and high safety are alternative selections for two-phase loop thermosyphon in building applications.
Introduction
Two-phase loop thermosyphons (TPLTs) are highly efficient, passive heat transfer devices that leverage gravity and phase-change cycles (boiling and condensation) to transport heat without the need for mechanical pumps. These systems are particularly well-suited for "free cooling" applications in data centers, telecommunication base stations, and industrial facilities where high-temperature heat sources are present.
However, scaling TPLTs for large-scale building applications introduces significant challenges. The complex piping networks required for such installations create substantial internal flow resistance, which can impede the natural circulation of the working fluid. While the fundamental principles of TPLTs are well-understood in simpler configurations, the impact of high internal flow resistance on different working mediums remains under-explored. This study aims to evaluate how various pure and mixed refrigerants perform under these constrained conditions.
Methodology
The researchers developed a distributed steady-state parameter model to simulate the TPLT's performance. The model is a one-dimensional framework based on the conservation of momentum, energy, and mass. It was implemented using MATLAB 2018, with fluid properties sourced from the high-accuracy REFPROP 9 database.
To simulate varying degrees of internal flow resistance, the model incorporated a virtual "gate valve" in the vapor line. Resistance was categorized into three classes corresponding to valve openings of 90°, 60°, and 30°. The study evaluated eight different refrigerants, including pure fluids like R744 (CO2) and R290 (Propane), and mixtures such as R410A and R507A. Heat transfer coefficients were calculated using established engineering correlations, including Gnielinski for liquid phases and McAdams for two-phase flow regimes.
Results and Discussion
The simulation results highlight significant performance differences among the tested working mediums, particularly as flow resistance increases.
Heat Exchange Capacity and Flow Resistance
As expected, increasing flow resistance leads to a decrease in heat exchange capacity across all refrigerants. However, R744 (CO2) emerged as the superior performer. At the highest resistance level (Class 3), R744 maintained a heat exchange capacity of 138.6 W, which is over 50% higher than any other refrigerant tested.
Thermal Resistance Analysis
The performance advantage of R744 is largely attributed to its low internal thermal resistance. For R744, internal resistance accounts for only 58.7% of the total thermal resistance, whereas for other fluids, this internal "chokepoint" is significantly higher. Specifically, R744 exhibited an internal thermal resistance of just 0.08 K/W, compared to 0.16–0.20 K/W for most mixed refrigerants.
Stability and Refrigerant Selection
The study also found that mixed refrigerants generally offer more stable operating states compared to pure refrigerants as resistance increases. While R744 and R410A are recommended for scenarios with extreme resistance, eco-friendly mixed refrigerants are identified as viable, cost-effective, and safe alternatives for standard building applications. Furthermore, the study confirmed a correlation between high "overheat" and reduced heat exchange capacity, with R744 maintaining the lowest overheat and undercooling values.
Conclusion
This research demonstrates that the choice of working medium is critical for the performance of large-scale TPLTs facing high internal flow resistance. R744 stands out for its exceptional heat transfer capabilities under extreme conditions, while mixed refrigerants provide operational stability. Future work should address the limitations of this study, such as the reliance on steady-state modeling and the economic implications of high-pressure piping required for R744 systems.
Summary updated