Indirect Shared Control of Highly Automated Vehicles for Cooperative Driving between Driver and Automation

Renjie Li, Yanan Li, Shengbo Eben Li, Etienne Burdet, Bo Cheng

Abstract

This paper proposes an "indirect shared control" framework for steer-by-wire vehicles, where automation and human drivers cooperate without physical haptic feedback. By modeling the human driver as an adaptive agent who learns and incorporates the vehicle's assistance strategy into their own internal predictive model, the authors develop a system that can automatically shift control authority during critical maneuvers like undetected obstacle avoidance.

Introduction

As we transition toward fully autonomous vehicles, keeping the "human in the loop" remains vital for safety and situational awareness. Traditionally, this is achieved via haptic shared control, where the driver and the computer both apply physical torque to a mechanical steering wheel. While effective, this can lead to driver fatigue, discomfort, or "fighting" the wheel.

This research addresses two primary gaps in current systems. First, the rise of steer-by-wire technology allows for physical decoupling, moving away from mechanical "tug-of-wars" toward digital blending of inputs. Second, most shared control models treat the human as a static controller. In reality, humans are highly adaptive; they learn how the car assists them and adjust their effort accordingly. Failing to model this adaptation leads to inaccurate simulations and sub-optimal controller design.

Comparison between (a) haptic shared control and (b) the proposed indirect shared control framework.

Methodology

The paper introduces a mathematical framework for Indirect Shared Control, defined by a weighted summation of driver input ($u_D$) and automation input ($u_A$):

$$u = \lambda_D u_D + \lambda_A u_A$$

Adaptive Driver Modeling

The authors utilize Model Predictive Control (MPC) to model the driver. Crucially, they assume the driver identifies the controller’s strategy through motor learning and incorporates it into their own internal model. This allows the driver to "anticipate" the car's help, leading to a more natural cooperative experience. The authors derived a closed-form analytical solution for this adaptive strategy, demonstrating how authority weights ($\lambda$) mathematically shape driver behavior.

Automatic Weight Switching

To handle scenarios where the driver and automation disagree (e.g., an undetected obstacle), the system employs a sliding window detector. It monitors the error between actual driver input and the predicted "cooperative" input. If the error exceeds a threshold, the system assumes a change in driver intention and automatically shifts more authority ($\lambda_D$) to the human.

Key Results and Discussion

The study was validated through numerical simulations using a linearized dynamic bicycle model. Two primary scenarios were tested: continuous path-following and sudden lane changes for obstacle avoidance.

The "Relaxation" Effect and Effort Reduction

In path-following tasks, the adaptive model revealed that drivers naturally reduce their steering effort when they realize the automation is assisting. A non-adaptive model would over-predict the human workload. As shown in the simulation results, indirect shared control significantly reduced driver control effort while simultaneously improving path-tracking accuracy compared to manual driving.

Simulation results for path-following: (a) lateral displacement $y$ and (b) driver steering input $u_D$ showing the relaxation effect.

Conflict Resolution and Switching

In obstacle-avoidance scenarios where the automation was "blind" to the hazard, static shared control performed poorly as the car attempted to pull the driver back to the original path. However, the automatic weight switching mechanism detected the driver's change in intention within 1 second. Once triggered, it successfully reallocated authority to the driver, allowing for a smooth avoidance maneuver that would have been hindered by a static controller.

Conclusion and Future Work

Indirect shared control offers a promising path for steer-by-wire systems by complementing the driver’s input "behind the scenes," reducing physical workload and discomfort. However, the authors noted a "jerk" problem where sudden authority shifts cause input discontinuities. Future work will focus on developing smoother weight-shifting processes and validating the model with actual human subjects to account for the noisy and imperfect nature of real-world human learning.

Summary updated

Abstract

It is widely acknowledged that drivers should remain in the control loop before automated vehicles completely meet real-world operational conditions. This paper presents an “indirect shared control” framework for steer-by-wire vehicles, which allows the control authority to be continuously shared between the driver and automation through an weighted-input-summation method. A “best-response” driver steering model based on model predictive control (MPC) for indirect shared control is proposed. Unlike any conventional driver model for manual driving, this model assumes that drivers can learn and incorporate the controller strategy into their internal model for predictive path following. The analytic solution to the driver model is provided to enable off-line simulations. A driving-simulator experiment was conducted to demonstrate the advantages of the indirect shared control system in a highway lane-keeping task. The result showed that the proposed indirect shared control method was effective to improve the subjects’ lane-keeping performance and reduce steering control effort. The proposed driver steering model was also validated by the experiment data, which produced a smaller prediction error than the conventional MPC driver model.
BibTeX
@article{li2021indirect,
  author = {Renjie Li and Yanan Li and Shengbo Eben Li and Etienne Burdet and Bo Cheng},
  title = {{Indirect Shared Control of Highly Automated Vehicles for Cooperative Driving between Driver and Automation}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Intell. Transp. Syst.},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1109/tits.2020.3010620},
}
Figure