Implications of the 750 GeV γγ Resonance as a Case Study for the International Linear Collider

H. Fujii, Christophe Grojean, Michael E. Peskin, Tim Barklow, Yuanning Gao, Shinya Kanemura, Hyung Do Kim, Jenny List, Mihoko M. Nojiri, Maxim Perelstein, R. Pöschl, Jürgen Reuter, F. Simon, T. Tanabe, J. S. Yu, James D. Wells, Adam Falkowski, Shigeki Matsumoto, Takeo Moroi, François Richard, Junping Tian, M. Vos, Hiroshi Yokoya, Hitoshi Murayama, H. Yamamoto

TL;DR

This paper explores the implications of a potential 750 GeV resonance (dubbed Φ) observed at the LHC for the future International Linear Collider (ILC). It argues that even if the Φ is confirmed, the ILC's precision measurements of the Higgs, top quark, and electroweak interactions will be crucial for distinguishing between various theoretical models explaining the Φ. Furthermore, an upgraded ILC operating at 1 TeV could directly produce and study the Φ in γγ and e⁺e⁻ collisions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In late 2015, preliminary hints of a new particle, a resonance at approximately 750 GeV decaying into two photons (γγ), emerged from LHC data. While this signal was not statistically significant enough to be a definitive discovery, it sparked considerable theoretical interest. The central question this paper addresses is: If this 750 GeV resonance is real, what does it mean for the physics program and future development of the International Linear Collider (ILC)? The authors use this potential discovery as a case study to highlight the ILC's unique capabilities and its role in a comprehensive high-energy physics program, complementing LHC discoveries. They aim to demonstrate how the ILC can either confirm or constrain theories proposed to explain such a resonance, even if the new particles involved are beyond the LHC's direct reach.

Methods

The paper adopts a model-driven approach. It first reviews the basic properties of the hypothetical 750 GeV resonance (Φ), assuming it's a color singlet with spin 0 or 2. Then, it delves into various theoretical models proposed to explain the Φ. For each model class, the authors analyze its predictions for precision measurements at the ILC, focusing on:

  • Precision measurements of Higgs boson couplings: Deviations from Standard Model predictions in Higgs couplings to gluons (gg), photons (γγ), W and Z bosons, and fermions (like bottom quarks and tau leptons).
  • Precision measurements of top quark couplings: Shifts in the top quark's electroweak couplings.
  • 4-fermion interactions: Precision measurements of processes like e⁺e⁻ → f f̄.

These precision measurements are presented as powerful tools to discriminate between models, especially if the new particles associated with the Φ are too heavy for direct LHC observation.

Additionally, the paper explores the potential of an upgraded ILC operating at 1 TeV. This includes:

  • Direct production of Φ in e⁺e⁻ collisions: Investigating processes like e⁺e⁻ → Φγ and e⁺e⁻ → ΦZ.
  • Photon-Photon (γγ) linear collider: Utilizing a converted ILC to produce Φ in γγ collisions.
  • Resonant production in e⁺e⁻ collisions: Exploring the possibility of direct e⁺e⁻ → Φ production if the Φ has a coupling to leptons.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it relies on:

  • Existing LHC data: Primarily the preliminary results from ATLAS and CMS experiments concerning the 750 GeV γγ resonance.
  • Theoretical calculations and simulations: Based on the Standard Model and various extensions, using established theoretical frameworks and cross-section calculations.
  • ILC design parameters: Utilizing specifications for the ILC at 500 GeV and its proposed 1 TeV upgrade, including expected luminosities and beam polarizations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • ILC's Complementarity: The Φ resonance serves as a compelling example of how the ILC's precision measurements offer a complementary probe of new physics to the LHC's direct search approach. Even if the LHC discovers new particles, the ILC's precision can help unravel their nature and relationships.
  • Model Discrimination Power: The diverse theoretical models proposed for the Φ (e.g., vectorlike fermions, extended Higgs sectors, composite models, Randall-Sundrum models) predict distinct signatures in ILC precision observables. This allows the ILC to effectively "winnow" these models.
  • The 1 TeV Upgrade is Crucial: For direct observation of the Φ and its associated particles, an energy upgrade of the ILC to 1 TeV is essential. This upgrade opens up new production channels and allows for more detailed studies.
  • γγ Colliders as Powerful Tools: A photon-photon linear collider, potentially built upon the ILC infrastructure, is highlighted as an ideal environment for studying the Φ, offering clean signals and access to various decay modes.
  • The Φ as a Window to TeV-Scale Physics: The Φ resonance, if real, could be a signpost pointing towards new physics at the TeV scale, potentially related to electroweak symmetry breaking, dark matter, or even gravity.

Key Results

  • Precision Measurements as Discriminators: The paper details how precision measurements of Higgs and top quark couplings at the ILC can distinguish between various models proposed for the Φ. For instance, deviations in Higgs couplings to photons and gluons are predicted to be significant in many scenarios.
  • 1 TeV ILC Capabilities: Estimates show that an upgraded ILC at 1 TeV could produce a significant number of Φ events in γγ and e⁺e⁻ collisions, enabling the study of its decay modes.
  • γγ Collider Potential: A γγ collider operating at 1 TeV could provide a very clean experimental setting for measuring the Φ's decay branching ratios to electroweak gauge bosons, offering a precise determination of its properties.
  • Sensitivity to New Particles: The ILC's precision program is shown to be sensitive to new particles with masses below a few TeV, even if they are not directly produced.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dependence on LHC Data: The study is predicated on the assumption that the 750 GeV resonance is a real physical phenomenon. If it turns out to be a statistical fluctuation, the specific implications for the ILC would change, though the general arguments for the ILC's precision program remain valid.
  • Model-Specific Predictions: While the paper surveys various model classes, the precise quantitative predictions for ILC observables depend on the specific parameters within each model.
  • Technological Challenges for γγ Colliders: The paper acknowledges that adapting the ILC for a photon-photon collider requires modifications, such as increasing the beam crossing angle, and that the development of high-power lasers needs to be matched to the ILC's time structure.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further study is needed to determine the best path for developing a γγ collider and to refine estimates for background processes. They also emphasize the need for continued theoretical work to explore the implications of the Φ for specific models and to guide experimental searches.

Summary updated

Abstract

If the γγ resonance at 750 GeV suggested by 2015 LHC data turns out to be a real effect, what are the implications for the physics case and upgrade path of the International Linear Collider? Whether or not the resonance is confirmed, this question provides an interesting case study testing the robustness of the ILC physics case. In this note, we address this question with two points: (1) Almost all models proposed for the new 750 GeV particle require additional new particles with electroweak couplings. The key elements of the 500 GeV ILC physics program - precision measurements of the Higgs boson, the top quark, and 4-fermion interactions - will powerfully discriminate among these models. This information will be important in conjunction with new LHC data, or alone, if the new particles accompanying the 750 GeV resonance are beyond the mass reach of the LHC. (2) Over a longer term, the energy upgrade of the ILC to 1 TeV already discussed in the ILC TDR will enable experiments in γγ and e+e- collisions to directly produce and study the 750 GeV particle from these unique initial states.
BibTeX
@misc{fujii2016implications,
  author = {H. Fujii and Christophe Grojean and Michael E. Peskin and Tim Barklow and Yuanning Gao and Shinya Kanemura and Hyung Do Kim and Jenny List and Mihoko M. Nojiri and Maxim Perelstein and R. Pöschl and Jürgen Reuter and F. Simon and T. Tanabe and J. S. Yu and James D. Wells and Adam Falkowski and Shigeki Matsumoto and Takeo Moroi and François Richard and Junping Tian and M. Vos and Hiroshi Yokoya and Hitoshi Murayama and H. Yamamoto},
  title = {{Implications of the 750 GeV γγ Resonance as a Case Study for the International Linear Collider}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1607.03829},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1607.03829},
}

Loading related content...

Figure