Implications of the 750 GeV gamma-gamma Resonance as a Case Study for the International Linear Collider

H. Fujii, Hiroshi Yokoya, Maxim Perelstein, Christophe Grojean, Y. Gao, Jenny List, Hitoshi Murayama, Hyung Do Kim, Shinya Kanemura, Adam Falkowski, H. Yamamoto, T. Tanabe, Michael E. Peskin, Shigeki Matsumoto, J. S. Yu, F. Simon, R. Pöschl, Junping Tian, Tim Barklow, Mihoko M. Nojiri, François Richard, James D. Wells, M. Vos, Jürgen Reuter, Takeo Moroi

Abstract

If the $\gamma\gamma$ resonance at 750 GeV suggested by 2015 LHC data turns out to be a real effect, what are the implications for the physics case and upgrade path of the International Linear Collider? Whether or not the resonance is confirmed, this question provides an interesting case study testing the robustness of the ILC physics case. In this note, we address this question with two points: (1) Almost all models proposed for the new 750 GeV particle require additional new particles with electroweak couplings. The key elements of the 500 GeV ILC physics program—precision measurements of the Higgs boson, the top quark, and 4-fermion interactions—will powerfully discriminate among these models. This information will be important in conjunction with new LHC data, or alone, if the new particles accompanying the 750 GeV resonance are beyond the mass reach of the LHC. (2) Over a longer term, the energy upgrade of the ILC to 1 TeV already discussed in the ILC TDR will enable experiments in $\gamma\gamma$ and $e^+e^-$ collisions to directly produce and study the 750 GeV particle from these unique initial states.

Introduction

In late 2015, the ATLAS and CMS experiments at the LHC reported a surplus of events in the diphoton channel, suggesting a potential new resonance, $\Phi$, at 750 GeV. This discovery, though later found to be a statistical fluctuation, raised a critical strategic question for the particle physics community: if a new particle is discovered at an energy scale beyond the direct reach of a proposed facility like the International Linear Collider (ILC), does that facility lose its relevance? This paper argues the opposite, using the 750 GeV resonance as a case study to demonstrate that the ILC's precision measurements at 500 GeV and its potential 1 TeV upgrade are essential for characterizing high-mass discoveries.

Methodology

The study performs a phenomenological analysis of various Beyond-the-Standard-Model (BSM) theories proposed to explain the resonance, including vector-like quarks and leptons, extended Higgs sectors (e.g., 2HDM, NMSSM), and Randall-Sundrum warped extra dimensions. The analysis focuses on two main avenues:

  1. Indirect Sensitivity: Calculating how new particles associated with the 750 GeV resonance would modify Standard Model (SM) observables, such as Higgs couplings and top quark properties, through quantum loop effects.
  2. Direct Characterization: Evaluating the cross-sections and event yields for the 750 GeV particle at a 1 TeV ILC upgrade, particularly in the $e^+e^-$ and Photon Linear Collider (PLC) configurations.

Results and Model Discrimination

The primary finding is that the ILC acts as a "high-resolution microscope." Even if the $\Phi$ particle is too heavy for direct production at 500 GeV, its required couplings to the SM—often mediated by new vector-like fermions—induce measurable deviations in precision observables.

Constraints on the partial widths of the 750 GeV resonance to gluons and photons, showing regions excluded by LHC dijet searches.

As shown in Figure 1, the parameter space for such a resonance is constrained by existing LHC data, such as dijet searches ($pp \to jj$). The ILC's 500 GeV program provides a unique "fingerprinting" capability. For instance, models involving Randall-Sundrum gravitons predict ~8% deviations in Higgs-to-vector-boson couplings, which the ILC can measure with sub-percent precision. Similarly, vector-like leptons with masses multi-TeV can be probed through 2-fermion scattering cross-sections.

The Role of the Photon Linear Collider (PLC)

A significant advantage of the ILC is its flexibility. By using laser backscattering, the ILC can be converted into a Photon Linear Collider. If a particle is discovered via its decay to two photons, the PLC is the ideal environment for its study. At a 1 TeV upgrade, a PLC could produce approximately 400,000 $\Phi$ events, allowing for the measurement of rare decay branches and the definitive determination of the particle's spin (0 vs. 2) through angular distribution analysis.

Conclusion

While the 750 GeV resonance did not persist in subsequent LHC data, the methodology of this case study remains a vital template for future discovery. It highlights the complementarity between hadron and lepton colliders: while the LHC excels at the energy frontier for initial discovery, the ILC provides the precision and unique initial states (like $\gamma\gamma$) necessary to fully decode the underlying physics of new phenomena.

Summary updated

Abstract

If the gamma-gamma resonance at 750 GeV suggested by 2015 LHC data turns out to be a real effect, what are the implications for the physics case and upgrade path of the International Linear Collider? Whether or not the resonance is confirmed, this question provides an interesting case study testing the robustness of the ILC physics case. In this note, we address this question with two points: (1) Almost all models proposed for the new 750 GeV particle require additional new particles with electroweak couplings. The key elements of the 500 GeV ILC physics program---precision measurements of the Higgs boson, the top quark, and 4-fermion interactions---will powerfully discriminate among these models. This information will be important in conjunction with new LHC data, or alone, if the new particles accompanying the 750 GeV resonance are beyond the mass reach of the LHC. (2) Over a longer term, the energy upgrade of the ILC to 1 TeV already discussed in the ILC TDR will enable experiments in gamma-gamma and e+e- collisions to directly produce and study the 750 GeV particle from these unique initial states.
BibTeX
@misc{fujii2016implications,
  author = {H. Fujii and Hiroshi Yokoya and Maxim Perelstein and Christophe Grojean and Y. Gao and Jenny List and Hitoshi Murayama and Hyung Do Kim and Shinya Kanemura and Adam Falkowski and H. Yamamoto and T. Tanabe and Michael E. Peskin and Shigeki Matsumoto and J. S. Yu and F. Simon and R. Pöschl and Junping Tian and Tim Barklow and Mihoko M. Nojiri and François Richard and James D. Wells and M. Vos and Jürgen Reuter and Takeo Moroi},
  title = {{Implications of the 750 GeV gamma-gamma Resonance as a Case Study for the International Linear Collider}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1607.03829},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1607.03829},
}
Figure