Abstract: Recent determinations of the total rate of the $^{12}\text{C}+^{12}\text{C}$ nuclear reaction show non-negligible differences with the reference reaction rate commonly used in previous stellar simulations. In addition, the current uncertainties in determining each exit channel constitute one of the main uncertainties in shaping the inner structure of super asymptotic giant branch stars that could have a measurable impact on the properties of pulsating ultra-massive white dwarfs (WDs). We explore how new determinations of the nuclear reaction rate and its branching ratios affect the evolution of WD progenitors. We show that the current uncertainties in the branching ratios constitute the main uncertainty factor in determining the inner composition of ultra-massive WDs and their progenitors. We found that the use of extreme branching ratios leads to differences in the central abundances of $^{20}\text{Ne}$ of at most 17%, which are translated into differences of at most 1.3 and 0.8% in the cooling times and size of the crystallized core. However, the impact on the pulsation properties is small, less than 1 s for the asymptotic period spacing. We found that the carbon burns partially in the interior of ultra-massive WD progenitors within a particular range of masses, leaving a hybrid CONe-core composition in their cores. The evolution of these new kinds of predicted objects differs substantially from the evolution of objects with pure CO cores. Differences in the size of the crystallized core and cooling times of up to 15 and 6%, respectively leading to distinct patterns in the period spacing distribution.
Introduction
In the life cycle of stars between 7 and 10 solar masses, carbon fusion represents a critical transition point. These stars eventually evolve into ultra-massive white dwarfs (WDs), typically composed of oxygen and neon (ONe). However, determining the $^{12}\text{C} + ^{12}\text{C}$ reaction rate at stellar energies is extremely challenging due to the "Coulomb barrier"—the electrostatic repulsion between nuclei. Experimental data varies significantly, and uncertainties in "branching ratios"—the probability of the reaction producing neon ($^{20}\text{Ne} + \alpha$) versus sodium ($^{23}\text{Na} + p$)—persist. This study quantifies how these nuclear physics uncertainties propagate into the macroscopic properties of white dwarfs, including cooling times, internal composition, and pulsation frequencies.
Methods and Modeling
The researchers employed a multi-stage numerical approach to track the impact of nuclear uncertainties. Using the MESA (Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics) code, they simulated stars from the main sequence through the Super Asymptotic Giant Branch (SAGB) phase where carbon burns. They compared the standard CF88 reaction rate against newer HIN and HINRES determinations, which account for different theoretical treatments of hindrance and resonances at low energies.
The resulting stellar structures were then transitioned into the LPCODE stellar evolutionary code to simulate the cooling and crystallization of the resulting white dwarfs. Finally, the LP-PUL code was used to calculate non-radial g-mode pulsations, assessing whether these nuclear uncertainties would be detectable through telescopes.
Key Insights: The Dominance of Branching Ratios
A primary finding is that uncertainty in branching ratios is the dominant factor in determining final chemical composition, outweighing the uncertainty in the total reaction rate. Specifically, the ratio of alpha-particle to proton exit channels determines the final $^{20}\text{Ne}$ abundance in the core.
One of the most significant discoveries is the "hybrid" core. For a specific mass range (around $6.85$ $M_\odot$), the carbon flame can "quench" before reaching the center, leaving an unburnt Carbon-Oxygen (CO) core surrounded by an Oxygen-Neon (ONe) mantle. Post-evolutionary mixing creates a "hybrid CONe" core, which differs substantially from standard ONe cores.
Impact on White Dwarf Properties
The internal composition directly influences the timing and nature of crystallization. Since crystallization releases latent heat, these uncertainties affect the predicted age of a white dwarf based on its temperature.
- Compositional Shifts: Using extreme (but experimentally plausible) branching ratios leads to a 17% difference in the central abundance of $^{20}\text{Ne}$.
- Cooling and Size: For standard ONe white dwarfs, these uncertainties translate to a 1.3% difference in cooling times and a 0.8% difference in the size of the crystallized core.
- Hybrid Impact: In the newly predicted hybrid CONe objects, the impact is much larger: differences of up to 15% in the crystallized core size and 6% in cooling times compared to pure CO models.
- Mass Thresholds: Higher branching ratios for the alpha channel release more energy, slightly lowering the minimum initial mass required for a star to undergo a "carbon flash" by about 1.5%.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
While this study highlights the sensitivity of stellar models to nuclear data, it also points to significant limitations. The 1D stellar models show carbon flame quenching (creating the hybrid cores), but 3D hydrodynamic simulations are necessary to confirm if this quenching is a physical reality or a numerical artifact of 1D modeling.
Furthermore, there is a critical need for more precise nuclear measurements at energies below 3 MeV. Until the "resonance" structures of the $^{12}\text{C} + ^{12}\text{C}$ reaction are better understood in the lab, our models of the most massive white dwarfs in the galaxy will remain somewhat blurred.
Summary updated