Impact of Current Uncertainties in the 12C+12C Nuclear Reaction Rate on Intermediate-mass Stars and Massive White Dwarfs

Francisco C. De Gerónimo, M. M. Miller Bertolami, Tiara Battich, Xiaodong Tang, M. Catelan, A. H. Córsico, Y. Li, Xiao Fang, Leandro G. Althaus

TL;DR

This paper investigates how uncertainties in the 12C+12C nuclear reaction rate and its branching ratios affect the evolution of stars that become massive white dwarfs (WDs). The findings reveal that these uncertainties significantly influence the internal composition of WDs, potentially leading to a new class of "hybrid" CO-Ne core WDs with distinct evolutionary and pulsation properties.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The core of this research lies in understanding the impact of nuclear physics uncertainties on stellar evolution, specifically for stars destined to become massive white dwarfs. The 12C+12C nuclear reaction is a crucial process during the late stages of evolution for stars more massive than about 7 solar masses. This reaction fuels the transition from a carbon-oxygen (CO) core to an oxygen-neon (ONe) core, a key step in forming massive WDs.

However, there are significant discrepancies in the measured rates of this reaction, particularly at the low energies relevant to stellar interiors. Furthermore, the way the 24Mg nucleus, formed in this reaction, decays into different channels (producing, for instance, 20Ne or 23Na) is also uncertain. These uncertainties in both the total reaction rate and its branching ratios can lead to different predictions for the internal structure and subsequent evolution of stars, and ultimately, the properties of the white dwarfs they become. Previous studies have explored the impact of the total reaction rate on massive stars, but this work specifically focuses on the consequences for intermediate-mass stars and their resulting ultra-massive WDs, including their observable pulsation properties.

Methods

The researchers employed sophisticated stellar evolution codes, specifically MESA (Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics) for progenitor evolution and LPCODE for WD cooling and crystallization. They computed evolutionary sequences for stars with initial masses ranging from 6.85 to 8.50 solar masses, covering the crucial carbon-burning phase.

A key aspect of their methodology was the systematic exploration of different nuclear reaction rate prescriptions. They utilized the canonical rate from Caughlan & Fowler (CF88) as a baseline and compared it with newer rates from Monpribat et al. (2022), specifically the HIN and HINRES rates. Crucially, they also investigated a wide range of branching ratios for the alpha (producing 20Ne) and proton (producing 23Na) exit channels of the 12C+12C reaction, from extreme ratios like [50/50] to [90/10].

After the progenitor evolution, the resulting WD cores were evolved through their cooling tracks using LPCODE, incorporating crystallization physics. Finally, the pulsation properties of these WDs were analyzed using the LP-PUL code, focusing on g-mode pulsations and their period spacing, which are sensitive to the internal structure.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical models and experimental nuclear physics data, not on observational datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Branching Ratios are Key: While uncertainties in the total 12C+12C reaction rate have a noticeable impact, the branching ratios of the reaction's exit channels are identified as the primary driver of differences in the internal composition of ultra-massive WDs and their progenitors.
  • The Rise of Hybrid CO-Ne Cores: Under specific mass ranges and branching ratio scenarios, carbon burning can be incomplete. This leads to the formation of "hybrid" CO-Ne core WDs, a distinct evolutionary outcome from pure CO cores. These objects possess a significant amount of 20Ne mixed within their core.
  • Hybrid WDs Evolve Differently: The presence of 20Ne in hybrid WDs significantly alters their evolution. They start crystallizing earlier and exhibit distinct cooling times and crystallized core sizes compared to pure CO-core WDs.
  • Pulsation Signatures: While the impact on asymptotic period spacing is minor for pure CO or ONe core WDs, the hybrid CO-Ne core WDs show perceptible differences in their g-mode pulsation properties, specifically in mode-trapping characteristics, which could be observable.

Key Results

  • Compositional Differences: Extreme branching ratios can lead to differences in the central abundance of 20Ne by up to 17%.
  • Cooling Times and Core Size: Differences in cooling times and crystallized core sizes for ONe-core WDs due to branching ratio uncertainties are up to 1.3% and 0.8%, respectively.
  • Hybrid WD Evolution: For hybrid CO-Ne core WDs, differences in crystallized core size and cooling times can reach up to 15% and 6%, respectively, compared to pure CO-core WDs.
  • Pulsation Impact: The impact on asymptotic period spacing for pure CO/ONe core WDs is small (< 1 s). However, hybrid WDs show longer trapping cycles in their period spacing distribution compared to pure CO-core WDs.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Data Needed: The paper strongly emphasizes the need for further experimental work to precisely constrain the 12C+12C reaction rate and its branching ratios at astrophysically relevant energies.
  • Convective Boundary Mixing: The study acknowledges that assumptions about convective boundary mixing can influence the mass ranges for different evolutionary outcomes (e.g., hybrid vs. pure CO cores). More detailed 3D hydrodynamic simulations or improved 1D prescriptions for mixing could refine these boundaries.
  • Temperature Profile Above Crystallized Core: The precise temperature profile above the crystallized core in WDs is a subject of ongoing discussion, which can affect the interpretation of pulsation properties.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further investigation into the impact of these uncertainties on other stellar types and the potential for asteroseismic detection of hybrid WDs is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Recent determinations of the total rate of the 12 C+ 12 C nuclear reaction show non-negligible differences with the reference reaction rate commonly used in previous stellar simulations. In addition, the current uncertainties in determining each exit channel constitute one of the main uncertainties in shaping the inner structure of super asymptotic giant branch stars that could have a measurable impact on the properties of pulsating ultramassive white dwarfs (WDs). We explore how new determinations of the nuclear reaction rate and its branching ratios affect the evolution of WD progenitors. We show that the current uncertainties in the branching ratios constitute the main uncertainty factor in determining the inner composition of ultramassive WDs and their progenitors. We found that the use of extreme branching ratios leads to differences in the central abundances of 20 Ne of at most 17%, which are translated into differences of at most 1.3% and 0.8% in the cooling times and size of the crystallized core, respectively. However, the impact on the pulsation properties is small, less than 1 s for the asymptotic period spacing. We found that the carbon burns partially in the interior of ultramassive WD progenitors within a particular range of masses, leaving a hybrid CONe-core composition in their cores. The evolution of these new kinds of predicted objects differs substantially from the evolution of objects with pure CO cores. Differences in the size of the crystallized core and cooling times of up to 15% and 6%, respectively, lead to distinct patterns in the period spacing distribution.
BibTeX
@article{geronimo2024impact,
  author = {Francisco C. De Gerónimo and M. M. Miller Bertolami and Tiara Battich and Xiaodong Tang and M. Catelan and A. H. Córsico and Y. Li and Xiao Fang and Leandro G. Althaus},
  title = {{Impact of Current Uncertainties in the <sup>12</sup>C+<sup>12</sup>C Nuclear Reaction Rate on Intermediate-mass Stars and Massive White Dwarfs}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ad7d8e},
}

Loading related content...

Figure