Idology and Its Applications in Public Security and Network Security

Shenghui Su, Jianhua Zheng, Shuwang Lü, Zhiqiu Huang, Zhoujun Li, Zhenmin Tang

TL;DR

This paper introduces "idology," a formalized scientific framework dedicated to the study of identification and anti-fraud technologies. The authors propose the BingFu Identity Digitized (BFID)—a chipless, lightweight asymmetric identity string—and demonstrate how it can secure everything from physical banknotes and pharmaceuticals to network protocols like IPv6.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Fraud, counterfeiting, and identity theft pose massive threats to both physical public safety and digital network security. The authors argue that a fundamental gap exists in how we approach security: while secrecy relies on encryption, anti-fraud relies entirely on identification.

Most modern identification methods rely on "symmetric identities" (such as passwords, barcodes, or raw biometrics like fingerprints). These are inherently insecure because verification requires comparing a claim against an identical duplicate stored in a database. If an insider leaks the database, or if data is wiretapped during transmission, the identity is compromised. This paper introduces secure, "asymmetric" identification methods that eliminate the need for centralized biometric databases or expensive electronic chips.

Methods

The authors formalize the field of Idology, dividing it into identity confection (creation), denotation (binding), sensing (detection), and verification. To achieve secure, lightweight identification, they introduce several novel components:

  • BFID (BingFu Identity Digitized): Inspired by the ancient Chinese BingFu (a physical military tally split into asymmetric halves), a BFID is a chipless asymmetric credential. Instead of an electronic chip, it uses a short string of 16–22 printable characters.
  • Optimized REESSE1+ Signing Scheme: The mathematical backbone of the BFID. Its security is based on the hardness of multivariate permutation and transcendental logarithm problems, making it highly compact and resistant to quantum-era attacks (like Shor's algorithm).
  • Juna Hash Function: A novel, non-iterative one-way compression function that uses "bit shadow" rules to process data securely without traditional iterative vulnerabilities.
  • United Verification Platform: A cloud-based architecture designed to handle BFID verification across different industries while keeping sensitive data isolated within secure inner networks.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The research is entirely theoretical, algorithmic, and architectural; it does not evaluate performance using empirical datasets or machine learning benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Biometrics are Symmetric: A surprising insight is that fingerprints and irises function as symmetric credentials in practice. Because they are verified via direct comparison with a stored template, they cannot guard against inside jobs or network eavesdropping unless they are converted into an asymmetric format.
  • The Ancient Roots of Asymmetry: The concept of asymmetric identification isn't uniquely modern. The authors highlight the ancient Chinese BingFu, where a commander's tally was split into asymmetric left and right halves. Verification relied on the physical coincidence of the two unique halves.
A physical BingFu tally split into asymmetric halves.
The process of verification using a BingFu tally.
  • Chipless Asymmetric Security: While Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) provides asymmetric security, it requires an expensive, environmentally unfriendly microchip. BFID achieves the same asymmetric verification properties purely through text strings, making it ideal for disposable, high-volume consumable goods like food, drugs, and cosmetics.
  • IPv6+ for Network Security: To eliminate IP spoofing, the authors propose "IPv6+", which restructures the standard 128-bit IP address to include explicit fields for a Nation ID, Domestic Routing Indicator, Subnet ID, and an 80-bit Interface ID acting as a BFID.

Key Results

  • Cryptographic Efficiency: The optimized REESSE1+ scheme achieves a security magnitude of $2^{80}$ using an 80-bit modulus, whereas Elliptic Curve Cryptography (ECC) requires 160 bits for the same security level. The resulting signature is only 160 bits, compared to ECC's 320 bits.
  • Compact Footprint: The system successfully compresses an 80-bit digital signature into a highly practical 16–22 character printable string.
  • Privacy-Preserving Real-Name Attestation: The paper outlines a method for real-name internet registration using BFIDs that hides sensitive personal data (like the birth date embedded in Chinese national ID numbers) from the destination server while still proving valid citizenship.

Limitations and Future Work

While the mathematical foundations of the REESSE1+ scheme are theoretically sound against quantum attacks, the paper lacks empirical performance metrics, such as verification latency or computational overhead on low-power mobile devices. Furthermore, implementing the proposed "IPv6+" protocol would require massive, highly improbable global coordination to alter core internet routing standards.

The authors note that future work will focus heavily on expanding "post-quantum idology" to ensure long-term resistance against evolving quantum computing threats.

Summary updated

Abstract

Fraud (swindling money, property, or authority by fictionizing, counterfeiting, forging, or imitating things, or by feigning persons privately) forms its threats against public security and network security. Anti-fraud is essentially the identification of a person or thing. In this paper, the authors first propose the concept of idology - a systematic and scientific study of identifications of persons and things, and give the definitions of a symmetric identity and an asymmetric identity. Discuss the converting symmetric identities (e.g., fingerprints) to asymmetric identities. Make a comparison between a symmetric identity and an asymmetric identity, and emphasize that symmetric identities cannot guard against inside jobs. Compare asymmetric RFIDs with BFIDs, and point out that a BFID is lightweight, economical, convenient, and environmentalistic, and more suitable for the anti-counterfeit and source tracing of consumable merchandise such as food, drugs, and cosmetics. The authors design the structure of a united verification platform for BFIDs and the composition of an identification system, and discuss the wide applications of BFIDs in public security and network security - antiterrorism and dynamic passwords for example.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{su2017idology,
  author = {Shenghui Su and Jianhua Zheng and Shuwang Lü and Zhiqiu Huang and Zhoujun Li and Zhenmin Tang},
  title = {{Idology and Its Applications in Public Security and Network Security}},
  booktitle = {PAISI},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-319-57463-9\_9},
}
Figure