I/Q Imbalance Aware Nonlinear Wireless-Powered Relaying of B5G Networks: Security and Reliability Analysis

Xingwang Li, Mengyan Huang, Yuanwei Liu, Varun G. Menon, Anand Paul, Zhiguo Ding

TL;DR

This paper provides a rigorous mathematical framework for evaluating Beyond 5G (B5G) relay networks that rely on wireless energy harvesting. By accounting for realistic hardware flaws—specifically I/Q imbalance and channel estimation errors—the authors reveal a fascinating "security-reliability trade-off" where hardware imperfections can actually make it harder for eavesdroppers to intercept signals, even as they degrade the network's overall reliability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As we move toward B5G networks, two major challenges emerge: energy efficiency for massive numbers of low-power devices and robust security against eavesdropping. While Physical Layer Security (PLS) offers a way to secure communications without heavy encryption overhead, most theoretical models assume "perfect" hardware.

In the real world, radio frequency (RF) front-ends suffer from In-phase and Quadrature-phase Imbalance (IQI)—mismatches in amplitude and phase between signal branches. Furthermore, devices rarely have perfect knowledge of the wireless channel (Channel Estimation Errors), and the circuits used to harvest energy from radio waves are nonlinear, meaning they saturate once the incoming power reaches a certain level. This paper bridges the gap between idealized theory and messy reality by analyzing how these combined factors impact a multi-relay system.

Methods

The authors model a system where a source sends data to a destination via multiple "Decode-and-Forward" (DF) relays. These relays are "wireless-powered," meaning they first harvest energy from a power beacon using a Time-Switching (TS) protocol before transmitting data.

Key technical components include:

  • Nonlinear Energy Harvesting Model: Unlike simpler linear models, this accounts for the saturation of real-world harvesting circuits.
  • Hardware Impairment Modeling: They incorporate asymmetrical IQI at both the transmitter (TX) and receiver (RX).
  • Relay Selection Strategies: They compare three approaches:
  • Optimal Relay Selection (ORS): Choosing the relay that maximizes the end-to-end capacity.
  • Suboptimal Relay Selection (SRS): Choosing based only on the source-to-relay link quality.
  • Random Relay Selection (RRS): Used as a baseline.
  • Analytical Framework: The team derived exact, closed-form expressions for Outage Probability (OP) (reliability) and Intercept Probability (IP) (security) under Rayleigh fading conditions.

Datasets

This is a theoretical and analytical paper; therefore, it does not use external empirical datasets. Instead, the authors validated their mathematical derivations using extensive Monte Carlo simulations (10^7 iterations) to ensure the accuracy of their closed-form expressions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The IQI Silver Lining: While IQI is generally seen as a nuisance that increases the Outage Probability (hurting reliability), the authors found it actually improves security. The hardware mismatches effectively "scramble" the signal, making it harder for an eavesdropper to successfully wiretap the transmission.
  • The "Error Floor" Problem: Due to Channel Estimation Errors (CEEs), the system hits a performance ceiling. Beyond a certain signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), increasing transmit power no longer improves reliability. This results in a "diversity order" of zero in high-SNR regimes.
  • Relay Scaling: Increasing the number of available relays significantly improves reliability (lower OP) under Optimal Relay Selection, but it doesn't help the eavesdropper as much as one might fear, provided the selection strategy is robust.
  • Energy Harvesting Trade-offs: There is a "sweet spot" for the time-allocation factor ($\alpha$). If you spend too much time harvesting energy, there isn't enough time left for data transmission; too little, and the relays don't have enough power to reach the destination.

Key Results

  • Reliability: ORS consistently outperforms SRS and RRS. However, all schemes suffer from an "error floor" in the presence of CEEs.
  • Security: The Intercept Probability (IP) is lower (better) when hardware is non-ideal compared to the "perfect hardware" case.
  • Quantitative Impact: Numerical results show that while amplitude/phase mismatches limit the OP, they can significantly enhance IP performance in high-SNR regions.
  • Asymptotic Analysis: The paper mathematically proves that the diversity order for all considered selection schemes is zero under non-ideal conditions, highlighting the dominant impact of hardware impairments over transmit power.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several areas for expansion:

  • Simplified Fading Models: The study uses Rayleigh fading; future work could explore more complex environments like Rician or Nakagami-m fading.
  • Single Eavesdropper: The model assumes a single eavesdropper. Real-world scenarios might involve multiple colluding eavesdroppers.
  • Other Imperfections: While IQI and CEE are covered, other factors like phase noise, amplifier non-linearities, and quantization errors remain to be integrated into this specific framework.
  • Multi-Antenna Systems: The current model uses single-antenna nodes; extending this to MIMO (Multiple-Input Multiple-Output) systems is a logical next step for B5G research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Physical layer security is known as a promising paradigm to ensure secure performance for the future beyond 5G (B5G) networks. In light of this fact, this paper elaborates on a tractable analysis framework to evaluate the reliability and the security of wireless-powered decode-and-forward (DF) multi-relay networks. More practical, the nonlinear energy harvesters, in-phase and quadrature-phase imbalance (IQI) and channel estimation errors (CEEs) are taken into account. To further enhance the secure performance, two relay selection strategies are presented: <italic xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">1) suboptimal relay selection (SRS); 2) optimal relay selection (ORS)</i> . Specifically, exact analytical expressions for the outage probability (OP) and the intercept probability (IP) are derived in closed-form. For the IP, we consider that the eavesdropper can wiretap the signal from the source or the relay. In order to obtain more deep insights, we carry out the asymptotic analysis as well as the diversity orders for the OP in the high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) regimes. Numerical results show that: 1) Although the mismatches of amplitude/phase of transmitter (TX)/receiver (RX) limit the OP performance, it can enhance IP performance; 2) Large number of relays yields better OP performance; 3) There are error floors for the OP due to the CEEs; 4) There is a trade-off for the OP and IP to obtain the balance between reliability and security.
BibTeX
@article{li2021i,
  author = {Xingwang Li and Mengyan Huang and Yuanwei Liu and Varun G. Menon and Anand Paul and Zhiguo Ding},
  title = {{I/Q Imbalance Aware Nonlinear Wireless-Powered Relaying of B5G Networks: Security and Reliability Analysis}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Network Science \& Engineering},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1109/tnse.2020.3020950},
}
Figure